Central Counterparties for Over-the-Counter Derivatives

M. Hollanders,Jacob Gyntelberg,Stephen G. Cecchetti

2009-09-01

Abstract:Wider use of central counterparties (CCPs) for over-the-counter derivatives has the potential to improve market resilience by lowering counterparty risk and increasing transparency. However, CCPs alone are not sufficient to ensure the resilience and efficiency of derivatives markets.

Business,Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Using Central Counterparties to Limit Global Financial Crises

Christoph Henkel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3530022

2020-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:Conventional economic analysis assumes that Central Counterparties (CCPs) may help to reduce systemic risk and avoid future financial crises by mandating the central clearing of over-the-counter (OTC) derivatives. This view largely goes unchallenged by governments, regulators, practitioners, and many international standard setting bodies. But if this assumption is correct, why are we increasingly confronted with the potential failure of CCPs? Why do these potential failures threaten significant spillover and cascade effects, which may cause financial crises rather than preventing them? This article attempts to provide a compelling explanation for these negative effects.In this article, I question the received wisdom about the role that CCPs play in preventing financial crises. I further challenge the conventional view about how counterparties should be used by focusing on CCP recovery and resolution mechanisms in the U.S. context. This article analyzes why the current approach, which assumes that CCPs serve as financial risk mitigators, is problematic and may cause future global financial crises.
Central Counterparties in the OTC Derivatives Market from the Perspective of the Legal Theory of Finance, Financial Market Stability and the Public Good

Max Weber

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40804-016-0031-5

IF: 1.79

2016-03-14

European Business Organization Law Review

Abstract:AbstractIn light of the recent global financial crisis, regulatory attention has been focused on the Janus-headed activity of over-the-counter (OTC) credit derivatives. As a result, heavy-handed measures have been introduced, such as those in the Dodd–Frank Act and the European market infrastructure regulation, which mandate central counterparty clearing for OTC credit derivatives. The deployment of central counterparties (CCPs) is by no means a panacea for global financial stability. Drawing on the ongoing debate about the benefits of CCPs, this paper considers them through the lens of the Legal Theory of Finance proposed by Katharina Pistor. This leads to a number of observations: firstly, CCPs lack sufficient tools to adjust for the materialisation of unexpected circumstances, not least because of precarious state-contingent collateral calls. Moreover, the hierarchy of the financial system highlights a hierarchy with respect to the vindication of property rights in times of crisis. This causes one to consider financial stability as a public good and to argue in favour of stronger social responsibility in financial markets. Major financial players ought to be required to have more ‘skin in the game’. CCPs therefore lend themselves as a focal point for regulatory measures.

law,business
Capital Requirements for Over-the-Counter Derivatives Central Counterparties

Jay Surti,Li Lin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2216087

2013-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:The central counterparties dominating the market for the clearing of over-the-counter interest rate and credit derivatives are globally systemic. Employing methodologies similar to the calculation of banks’ capital requirements against trading book exposures, this paper assesses the sensitivity of central counterparties’ required risk buffers, or capital requirements, to a range of model inputs. We find them to be highly sensitive to whether key model parameters are calibrated on a point-in-time versus stress-period basis, whether the risk tolerance metric adequately captures tail events, and the ability — or lack thereof — to define exposures on the basis of netting sets spanning multiple risk factors. Our results suggest that there are considerable benefits from having prudential authorities adopt a more prescriptive approach for central counterparties’ risk buffers, in line with recent enhancements to the capital regime for banks.
On the recovery tools of a central counterparty

Ron Berndsen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21314/jfmi.2023.004

IF: 0.645

2024-01-23

The Journal of Operational Risk

Abstract:The author argues that assessments should be preferred over variation margin gains haircutting when CCP resilience is tested by cases of default loss being greater than prefunded financial resources.

business, finance
Systemic risk in markets with multiple central counterparties

Luitgard Anna Maria Veraart,Iñaki Aldasoro

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/mafi.12446

2024-08-26

Mathematical Finance

Abstract:We provide a framework for modeling risk and quantifying payment shortfalls in cleared markets with multiple central counterparties (CCPs). Building on the stylized fact that clearing membership is shared among CCPs, we develop a modeling framework that captures the interconnectedness of CCPs and clearing members. We illustrate stress transmission mechanisms using simple examples as well as empirical evidence based on calibrated data. Furthermore, we show how stress mitigation tools such as variation margin gains haircutting by one CCP can have spillover effects on other CCPs. The framework can be used to enhance CCP stress‐testing, which currently relies on the "Cover 2" standard requiring CCPs to be able to withstand the default of their two largest clearing members. We show that who these two clearing members are can be significantly affected if one considers higher‐order effects arising from interconnectedness through shared clearing membership. Looking at the full network of CCPs and shared clearing members is, therefore, important from a financial stability perspective.

economics,social sciences, mathematical methods,mathematics, interdisciplinary applications,business, finance
Will Central Counterparties become the New Rating Agencies?

Chris Kenyon,Andrew Green

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1211.6349

2012-11-28

Abstract:Central Counterparties (CCPs) are widely promoted as a requirement for safe banking with little dissent except on technical grounds (such as proliferation of CCPs). Whilst CCPs can have major operational positives, we argue that CCPs have many of the business characteristics of Rating Agencies, and face similar business pressures. Thus we see a risk that prices from CCPs may develop the characteristics attributed to ratings from Rating Agency pre-crisis. Business over-reliance on ratings of questionable accuracy is seen as a cause of the financial crisis. We see the potential for same situation to be repeated with prices from CCPs. Thus the regulatory emphasis on CCPs, rather than on collateralization, may create the preconditions for an avoidable repeat of the financial crisis.

General Finance
Central Counterparty Risk

Matthias Arnsdorf

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1205.1533

2012-05-08

Abstract:A clearing member of a Central Counterparty (CCP) is exposed to losses on their default fund and initial margin contributions. Such losses can be incurred whenever the CCP has insufficient funds to unwind the portfolio of a defaulting clearing member. This does not necessarily require the default of the CCP itself. In this note we aim to quantify the risk a financial institution has when facing a CCP. We show that a clearing member's CCP risk is given by a sum of exposures to each of the other clearing members. This arises because of the implicit default insurance that each member has provided in the form of mutualised, loss sharing collateral. We calculate the exposures by explicitly modeling the capital structure of a CCP as well as the loss distributions of the individual member portfolios. An important consideration in designing the model is the limited transparency with respect to the portfolio composition and collateral levels of individual clearing members. To overcome this we leverage the fact that, for a typical CCP, margin levels are risk-based. In particular, we parameterise the portfolio loss tail as a Pareto distribution and we calibrate this to the CCP defined probability of losses exceeding the posted initial margin levels. A key aspect of the model is that we explicitly take into account wrong-way risk, i.e. the fact that member defaults are more likely to occur in stressed market conditions, as well as potential contagion between a member's default and the losses on his portfolio.

Risk Management,Pricing of Securities
The Financial System’s Resilience is Everything, But at what Cost?

Melinda Friesz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.35551/pfq_2020_4_2

2020-01-01

Pénzügyi Szemle = Public Finance Quarterly

Abstract:The purpose of this study is to introduce the role of CCP in the market, the importance of the risk management framework, including the tools used in the case of insufficient guarantee funds. The study is descriptive, and besides detailing the EU-level regulatory framework, it also illustrates its possible setbacks from the perspective of the market participants and professionals. It points out that the common goal and interest of all actors are to ensure the viability of the CCP, but the poorly designed capital management and strategy can hinder this. Although the regulatory framework has been applied across Europe and its fine-tuning can be said to be constant, its effectiveness and resilience to shocks will be supported or refuted by an adverse event in the market.
The Network of Counterparty Risk: Analysing Correlations in OTC Derivatives

Vahan Nanumyan,Antonios Garas,Frank Schweitzer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0136638

2015-09-15

Abstract:Counterparty risk denotes the risk that a party defaults in a bilateral contract. This risk not only depends on the two parties involved, but also on the risk from various other contracts each of these parties holds. In rather informal markets, such as the OTC (over-the-counter) derivative market, institutions only report their aggregated quarterly risk exposure, but no details about their counterparties. Hence, little is known about the diversification of counterparty risk. In this paper, we reconstruct the weighted and time-dependent network of counterparty risk in the OTC derivatives market of the United States between 1998 and 2012. To proxy unknown bilateral exposures, we first study the co-occurrence patterns of institutions based on their quarterly activity and ranking in the official report. The network obtained this way is further analysed by a weighted k-core decomposition, to reveal a core-periphery structure. This allows us to compare the activity-based ranking with a topology-based ranking, to identify the most important institutions and their mutual dependencies. We also analyse correlations in these activities, to show strong similarities in the behavior of the core institutions. Our analysis clearly demonstrates the clustering of counterparty risk in a small set of about a dozen US banks. This not only increases the default risk of the central institutions, but also the default risk of peripheral institutions which have contracts with the central ones. Hence, all institutions indirectly have to bear (part of) the counterparty risk of all others, which needs to be better reflected in the price of OTC derivatives.

Risk Management,Physics and Society,General Finance
The demand for central clearing: To clear or not to clear, that is the question!

Mario Bellia,Giulio Girardi,Roberto Panzica,Loriana Pelizzon,Tuomas Peltonen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfs.2024.101247

IF: 3.554

2024-02-26

Journal of Financial Stability

Abstract:This paper empirically analyses whether post-global financial crisis regulatory reforms have created appropriate incentives to voluntarily centrally clear over-the-counter (OTC) derivative contracts. We use confidential European trade repository data on single-name sovereign credit default swap (CDS) transactions and show that both seller and buyer manage counterparty exposures and capital costs, strategically choosing to clear when the counterparty is riskier. The clearing incentives seem particularly responsive to seller credit risk, which is in line with the notion that counterparty credit risk (CCR) is asymmetric in CDS contracts. The riskiness of the underlying reference entity also impacts the decision to clear as it affects both CCR capital charges for OTC contracts and central counterparty clearing house (CCP) margins for cleared contracts. Lastly, we find evidence that when a transaction helps netting positions with the CCP and hence lower margins, the likelihood of clearing is higher.

economics,business, finance
Systemic Risks in CCP Networks

Russell Barker,Andrew Dickinson,Alex Lipton,Rajeev Virmani

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1604.00254

2016-04-01

Abstract:We propose a model for the credit and liquidity risks faced by clearing members of Central Counterparty Clearing houses (CCPs). This model aims to capture the features of: gap risk; feedback between clearing member default, market volatility and margining requirements; the different risks faced by various types of market participant and the changes in margining requirements a clearing member faces as the system evolves. By considering the entire network of CCPs and clearing members, we investigate the distribution of losses to default fund contributions and contingent liquidity requirements for each clearing member; further, we identify wrong-way risks between defaults of clearing members and market turbulence.

Mathematical Finance,Risk Management
The Topology of Central Counterparty Clearing Networks and Network Stability

Rui Song,Richard B. Sowers,Jonathan Jones

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15326349.2014.868731

2014-01-02

Stochastic Models

Abstract:□ This paper derives a measure of central counterparty (CCP) clearing-network risk that is based on the probability that the maximum exposure (the N-th order statistic) of a CCP to an individual general clearing member is large. Our analytical derivation of this probability uses the theory of Laplace asymptotics, which is related to the large deviations theory of rare events. The theory of Laplace asymptotics is an area of applied probability that studies the exponential decay rate of certain probabilities and is often used in the analysis of the tails of probability distributions. We show that the maximum-exposure probability depends on the topology, or structure, of the clearing network. We also derive a CCP's Maximum-Exposure-at-Risk, which provides a metric for evaluating the adequacy of the CCP's and general clearing members’ loss-absorbing financial resources during rare but plausible market conditions. Based on our analysis, we provide insight into how clearing-network structure can affect the maximum-exposure risk of a CCP and, thereby, network stability. We show that the rate function (the exponential decay rate) of the maximum-exposure probability is informative and can be used to compare the relative maximum-exposure risks across different network configurations.

statistics & probability
Counterparty Credit Limits: The Impact of a Risk-Mitigation Measure on Everyday Trading

Martin D. Gould,Nikolaus Hautsch,Sam D. Howison,Mason A. Porter

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/1350486X.2021.1893770

2021-05-18

Applied Mathematical Finance

Abstract:A counterparty credit limit (CCL) is a limit that is imposed by a financial institution to cap its maximum possible exposure to a specified counterparty. CCLs help institutions to mitigate counterparty credit risk via selective diversification of their exposures. In this paper, we analyse how CCLs impact the prices that institutions pay for their trades during everyday trading. We study a high-quality data set from a large electronic trading platform in the foreign exchange spot market that allows institutions to apply CCLs. We find empirically that CCLs had little impact on the vast majority of trades in this data set. We also study the impact of CCLs using a new model of trading. By simulating our model with different underlying CCL networks, we highlight that CCLs can have a major impact in some situations.

English Else
CCP Cleared or Bilateral CSA Trades with Initial/Variation Margins under credit, funding and wrong-way risks: A Unified Valuation Approach

Damiano Brigo,Andrea Pallavicini

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1401.3994

2014-01-16

Abstract:The introduction of CCPs in most derivative transactions will dramatically change the landscape of derivatives pricing, hedging and risk management, and, according to the TABB group, will lead to an overall liquidity impact about 2 USD trillions. In this article we develop for the first time a comprehensive approach for pricing under CCP clearing, including variation and initial margins, gap credit risk and collateralization, showing concrete examples for interest rate swaps. Mathematically, the inclusion of asymmetric borrowing and lending rates in the hedge of a claim lead to nonlinearities showing up in claim dependent pricing measures, aggregation dependent prices, nonlinear PDEs and BSDEs. This still holds in presence of CCPs and CSA. We introduce a modeling approach that allows us to enforce rigorous separation of the interconnected nonlinear risks into different valuation adjustments where the key pricing nonlinearities are confined to a funding costs component that is analyzed through numerical schemes for BSDEs. We present a numerical case study for Interest Rate Swaps that highlights the relative size of the different valuation adjustments and the quantitative role of initial and variation margins, of liquidity bases, of credit risk, of the margin period of risk and of wrong way risk correlations.

Pricing of Securities,Computational Finance
Compressing Over-the-Counter Markets

Marco D'Errico,Tarik Roukny

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1705.07155

2019-06-14

Abstract:Over-the-counter markets are at the center of the postcrisis global reform of the financial system. We show how the size and structure of such markets can undergo rapid and extensive changes when participants engage in portfolio compression, a post-trade netting technology. Tightly-knit and concentrated trading structures, as featured by many large over-the-counter markets, are especially susceptible to reductions of notional and reconfigurations of network structure resulting from compression activities. Using transaction-level data on credit-default-swaps markets, we estimate reduction levels consistent with the historical development observed in these markets since the Global Financial Crisis. Finally, we study the effect of a mandate to centrally clear over-the-counter markets. When participants engage in both central clearing and portfolio compression, we find large netting failures if clearinghouses proliferate. Allowing for compression across clearinghouses by-and-large offsets this adverse effect.

General Finance
CCPs, Central Clearing, CSA, Credit Collateral and Funding Costs Valuation FAQ: Re-hypothecation, CVA, Closeout, Netting, WWR, Gap-Risk, Initial and Variation Margins, Multiple Discount Curves, FVA?

Damiano Brigo,Andrea Pallavicini

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1312.0128

2013-12-03

Abstract:We present a dialogue on Funding Costs and Counterparty Credit Risk modeling, inclusive of collateral, wrong way risk, gap risk and possible Central Clearing implementation through CCPs. This framework is important following the fact that derivatives valuation and risk analysis has moved from exotic derivatives managed on simple single asset classes to simple derivatives embedding the new or previously neglected types of complex and interconnected nonlinear risks we address here. This dialogue is the continuation of the "Counterparty Risk, Collateral and Funding FAQ" by Brigo (2011). In this dialogue we focus more on funding costs for the hedging strategy of a portfolio of trades, on the non-linearities emerging from assuming borrowing and lending rates to be different, on the resulting aggregation-dependent valuation process and its operational challenges, on the implications of the onset of central clearing, on the macro and micro effects on valuation and risk of the onset of CCPs, on initial and variation margins impact on valuation, and on multiple discount curves. Through questions and answers (Q&A) between a senior expert and a junior colleague, and by referring to the growing body of literature on the subject, we present a unified view of valuation (and risk) that takes all such aspects into account.

Pricing of Securities
Correlation breakdowns, spread positions and central counterparty margin models

David Li,Fernando Cerezetti,Roy Cheruvelil

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21314/jfmi.2024.006

IF: 0.645

2024-08-24

The Journal of Operational Risk

Abstract:The authors investigate correlation behavior during adverse market conditions and the potential impact on CCP margins, finding that such breakdowns appear to be more common than expected.

business, finance
Resilience centrality in complex networks.

Yongtao Zhang,Cunqi Shao,Shibo He,Jianxi Gao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.101.022304

IF: 2.707

2020-01-01

Physical Review E

Abstract:Resilience describes a system's ability to adjust its activity to retain the basic functionality when errors or failures occur in components (nodes) of the network. Due to the complexity of a system's structure, different components in the system exhibit diversity in the ability to affect the resilience of the system, bringing us a great challenge to protect the system from collapse. A fundamental problem is therefore to propose a physically insightful centrality index, with which to quantify the resilience contribution of a node in any systems effectively. However, existing centrality indexes are not suitable for the problem because they only consider the network structure of the system and ignore the impact of underlying dynamic characteristics. To break the limits, we derive a new centrality index: resilience centrality from the 1D dynamic equation of systems, with which we can quantify the ability of nodes to affect the resilience of the system accurately. Resilience centrality unveils the long-sought relations between the ability of nodes in a system's resilience and network structure of the system: the capacity is mainly determined by the degree and weighted nearest-neighbor degree of the node, in which weighted nearest-neighbor degree plays a prominent role. Further, we demonstrate that weighted nearest-neighbor degree has a positive impact on resilience centrality, while the effect of the degree depends on a specific parameter, average weighted degree beta(eff), in the 1D dynamic equation. To test the performance of our approach, we construct four real networks from data, which corresponds to two complex systems with entirely different dynamic characteristics. The simulation results demonstrate the effectiveness of our resilience centrality, providing us theoretical insights into the protection of complex systems from collapse.
The Effect of Anti‐Procyclical Central Counterparty Margins On Trading

Aniket Bhanu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/fut.22533

2024-06-25

Journal of Futures Markets

Abstract:The last decade has seen substantial research and debates on the procyclicality of Central Counterparty (CCP) margins, but these are limited to the sensitivity of margin models to market conditions. This paper establishes the effect of feedback loop between the sensitivity of margin models and trading behavior. It utilizes unique design and high‐frequency data from Indian markets to conduct an event study surrounding the revisions in the margin models to enhance their anti‐procyclicality (APC) characteristics. The analysis shows that current period volatility influences position exits in the subsequent period and vice‐versa. The analysis further shows that for the same price movement, position exits are lowered under stronger APC margin. The effect is weaker for participants having variation losses, where limiting losses may be an additional incentive to exit positions in addition to rise in initial margins. The findings support the argument that better APC characteristics of CCP margins can attenuate volatility.

business, finance

Central Counterparties for Over-the-Counter Derivatives

Using Central Counterparties to Limit Global Financial Crises

Central Counterparties in the OTC Derivatives Market from the Perspective of the Legal Theory of Finance, Financial Market Stability and the Public Good

Capital Requirements for Over-the-Counter Derivatives Central Counterparties

On the recovery tools of a central counterparty

Systemic risk in markets with multiple central counterparties

Will Central Counterparties become the New Rating Agencies?

Central Counterparty Risk

The Financial System’s Resilience is Everything, But at what Cost?

The Network of Counterparty Risk: Analysing Correlations in OTC Derivatives

The demand for central clearing: To clear or not to clear, that is the question!

Systemic Risks in CCP Networks

The Topology of Central Counterparty Clearing Networks and Network Stability

Counterparty Credit Limits: The Impact of a Risk-Mitigation Measure on Everyday Trading

CCP Cleared or Bilateral CSA Trades with Initial/Variation Margins under credit, funding and wrong-way risks: A Unified Valuation Approach

Compressing Over-the-Counter Markets

CCPs, Central Clearing, CSA, Credit Collateral and Funding Costs Valuation FAQ: Re-hypothecation, CVA, Closeout, Netting, WWR, Gap-Risk, Initial and Variation Margins, Multiple Discount Curves, FVA?

Correlation breakdowns, spread positions and central counterparty margin models

Resilience centrality in complex networks.

The Effect of Anti‐Procyclical Central Counterparty Margins On Trading