Abstract:An increasing number of studies using real-time fMRI neurofeedback have demonstrated that successful regulation of neural activity is possible in various brain regions. Since these studies focused on the regulated region(s), little is known about the target-independent mechanisms associated with neurofeedback-guided control of brain activation, i.e. the regulating network. While the specificity of the activation during self-regulation is an important factor, no study has effectively determined the network involved in self-regulation in general. In an effort to detect regions that are responsible for the act of brain regulation, we performed a post-hoc analysis of data involving different target regions based on studies from different research groups. We included twelve suitable studies that examined nine different target regions amounting to a total of 175 subjects and 899 neurofeedback runs. Data analysis included a standard first- (single subject, extracting main paradigm) and second-level (single subject, all runs) general linear model (GLM) analysis of all participants taking into account the individual timing. Subsequently, at the third level, a random effects model GLM included all subjects of all studies, resulting in an overall mixed effects model. Since four of the twelve studies had a reduced field of view (FoV), we repeated the same analysis in a subsample of eight studies that had a well-overlapping FoV to obtain a more global picture of self-regulation. The GLM analysis revealed that the anterior insula as well as the basal ganglia, notably the striatum, were consistently active during the regulation of brain activation across the studies. The anterior insula has been implicated in interoceptive awareness of the body and cognitive control. Basal ganglia are involved in procedural learning, visuomotor integration and other higher cognitive processes including motivation. The larger FoV analysis yielded additional activations in the anterior cingulate cortex, the dorsolateral and ventrolateral prefrontal cortex, the temporo-parietal area and the visual association areas including the temporo-occipital junction. In conclusion, we demonstrate that several key regions, such as the anterior insula and the basal ganglia, are consistently activated during self-regulation in real-time fMRI neurofeedback independent of the targeted region-of-interest. Our results imply that if the real-time fMRI neurofeedback studies target regions of this regulation network, such as the anterior insula, care should be given whether activation changes are related to successful regulation, or related to the regulation process per se. Furthermore, future research is needed to determine how activation within this regulation network is related to neurofeedback success.

Preliminary findings on long‐term effects of fMRI neurofeedback training on functional networks involved in sustained attention

Exploring the Effects of EEG-Based Alpha Neurofeedback on Working Memory Capacity in Healthy Participants

Network-based fMRI-neurofeedback training of sustained attention

Neural Mechanisms of Feedback Processing and Regulation Recalibration during Neurofeedback Training

Neurofeedback Training Effects on Inhibitory Brain Activation in ADHD: A Matter of Learning?

Functional near-infrared spectroscopy-based neurofeedback training regulates time-on-task effects and enhances sustained cognitive performance

Self‐regulation of ventromedial prefrontal cortex activation using real‐time fMRI neurofeedback—Influence of default mode network

Can we predict real‐time fMRI neurofeedback learning success from pretraining brain activity?

Closed-loop brain training: the science of neurofeedback

Changes in the Brain’s Intrinsic Organization in the Resting State with Real-Time Fmri Neurofeedback Training of Posterior Cingulate Cortex Activity

Functional near-infrared spectroscopy-based neurofeedback training targeting the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex induces changes in cortico-striatal functional connectivity

Meta-analysis of Real-Time Fmri Neurofeedback Studies Using Individual Participant Data: How is Brain Regulation Mediated?

Real-time fMRI neurofeedback: the promising potential of brain-training technology to advance clinical neuroscience

Meta-analysis of real-time fMRI neurofeedback studies: how is brain regulation mediated?

Effects of one session of theta or high alpha neurofeedback on EEG activity and working memory

The impact of successful learning of self-regulation on reward processing in children with ADHD using fMRI

A brief real-time fNIRS-informed neurofeedback training of the prefrontal cortex changes brain activity and connectivity during subsequent working memory challenge

Reorganization of functional brain networks mediates the improvement of cognitive performance following real-time neurofeedback training of working memory.

Respiratory sinus arrhythmia during biofeedback is linked to persistent improvements in attention, short-term memory, and positive self-referential episodic memory

Dynamic Functional Network Connectivity Changes Associated with fMRI Neurofeedback of Right Premotor Cortex

Mindfulness-based Neurofeedback: A Systematic Review of EEG and fMRI studies