Measuring the solubility of tacrolimus in supercritical carbon dioxide (binary and ternary systems), comparing the performance of machine learning models with conventional models
Fariba Razmimanesh,Seyed Ali Sajadian,Ratna Surya Alwi,Arya Adhyaksa Waskita,Hamed Hamishehkar,Abolghasem Jouyban
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molliq.2024.126295
IF: 6
2024-10-27
Journal of Molecular Liquids
Abstract:The solubility of tacrolimus in a supercritical carbon dioxide (SC-CO 2 ) with and without co-solvent (ternary and binary system) was investigated. The experimental conditions include the temperatures of 308 to 338 K and the pressures of 12 to 30 MPa were considered. The values of tacrolimus solubilization in SC-CO 2 in binary and ternary systems were from 0.416 × 10 −5 to 1.589 × 10 −5 and from 0.389 × 10 −4 to 0.875 × 10 −4 , respectively. The obtained results presented that adding a co-solvent (ethanol) could affect tacrolimus solubility significantly, the mole fraction of tacrolimus in SC-CO 2 /co-solvent under all experimental conditions was at least 4.9 more than that of SC-CO 2 alone. The correlation of the solubility data was achieved by three distinct methods: (1) SRK EoS with van der Waals (vdW2) and Wong-Sandler (WS) as mixing rules, (2) solution theory, (3) empirical and (4) machine learning based models. The analysis of variance (ANOVA) results showed that Sparks et al. ( AIC −817.05, and AARD 5.08 %) and Bian et al . ( AIC −815.77 and AARD 5.17 %) models could correlate the experimental data of tacrolimus in SC-CO 2 with more accuracy, as compared to the other empirical models. Sodeifian and Sajadian model with AARD % and AIC of 2.99 and −726.22, respectively, has acted as the most accurate empirical model in ternary system. The solution theory was able to calculate the solubility for the tacrolimus-SC-CO 2 -ethanol system with high accuracy ( AARD , % 4.85, AIC −701.41, F value 169.70 and R adj 0.9622). Also, the Gradient Boosting model (AARD accurately predicted the outcomes with perfect accuracy for binary and ternary systems. Finally, total (ΔH total , 23.21 cal/mol), solvation (ΔH sol , −19.47 cal/mol) and vaporization (ΔH vap , 42.68 cal/mol) enthalpies were obtained by using an energy term in Chrastil and Bartle models.
chemistry, physical,physics, atomic, molecular & chemical