Abstract:At the remote UNESCO Word Heritage Site Te Wāhipounamu, we show that eDNA analysis is a highly sensitive tool with strong potential for biodiversity surveys, which is still limited by the unavailability of local reference data. We hope that by demonstrating the extend of divergence between eDNA and more traditional tools in a real‐life case study of a remote region of high conservation interest, we further strengthen the case to fund the establishment of local eDNA reference data, also to benefit Te Wāhipounamu. Effective management of biodiversity requires regular surveillance of multiple species. Analysis of environmental DNA (eDNA) by metabarcoding holds promise to achieve this relatively easily. However, taxonomy‐focused eDNA surveys need suitable molecular reference data, which are often lacking, particularly at the species level and for remote locations. To evaluate the comparability of environmental DNA surveys and traditional surveys in a real‐life case study in a marine area of high conservation value, we conducted a biodiversity survey of the fish in remote and pristine Te Wāhipounamu/Fiordland (Aotearoa/New Zealand), incorporating multiple data sources. We compared eDNA‐derived species identifications against Baited Remote Underwater Video (BRUV) data collected at the same time and locations as eDNA. We also cross‐referenced both eDNA and BRUV data against literature and the Ocean Biodiversity Information System (OBIS), with literature and OBIS data representing a summary of multiple traditional surveying approaches. In total, we found 116 fish species in our study area. Environmental DNA detected 43 species; however, only three of those species overlap with species known from the literature, OBIS, or our BRUV analyses. A total of 61 fish species were known from the region from the literature, while OBIS listed 28 species, and our BRUV analyses picked up 26 species. BRUV data coincided more strongly than eDNA data with literature and OBIS data. Twenty of the 26 species detected by BRUV were known from literature and OBIS. We argue that limitated DNA reference databases are the main cause of this discrepancy, and our results indicate that eDNA of rare and endangered species can be detected if matching reference data were available. Environmental DNA analyses can only identify species present among reference data and with relaxed taxonomic assignment parameters may converge on relatives of detected species if the actually existing species themselves are missing among reference data. However, the high number of species detected by our eDNA analyses confirms that eDNA could be a powerful tool for biodiversity surveys if suitable investments in local reference databases were made.

Estimating the extent of urchin barrens and kelp forest loss in northeastern Aotearoa, New Zealand

Baseline seabed habitat and biotope mapping for a proposed marine reserve

Sea urchin roe quality within urchin barrens and improvement through kelp restoration

Quantifying vegetation cover on coastal active dunes using nationwide aerial image analysis

Marine reserves shape seascapes on scales visible from space

Modelling spatial distributions of biogenic habitat‐forming taxa to inform marine spatial planning

Potential of dynamic ocean management strategies for western Pacific leatherback sea turtle bycatch mitigation in New Zealand

Taxa‐dependent temporal trends in the abundance and size of sea urchins in subtropical eastern Australia

Unoccupied aerial vehicle-assisted monitoring of benthic vegetation in the coastal zone enhances the quality of ecological data

An evaluation of the error and uncertainty in epibenthos cover estimates from AUV images collected with an efficient, spatially-balanced design

Kelp forests versus urchin barrens: a comparison of ecosystem functions and services provided by two alternative stable marine habitats

Deep-sea seabed habitats: Do they support distinct mega-epifaunal communities that have different vulnerabilities to anthropogenic disturbance?

Multidisciplinary baselines quantify a drastic decline of mussel reefs and reveal an absence of natural recovery

Taking a deeper look at the biodiversity on temperate mesophotic reefs to inform adaptive management of impacts in Storm Bay, Tasmania

Ecological and archaeological consequences of ongoing, largely human-mediated colonisation of endemic soft, shelly habitats by mangroves in a northern New Zealand embayment

Combining unmanned aerial vehicles and satellite imagery to quantify areal extent of intertidal brown canopy‐forming macroalgae

Comparison of traditional and molecular surveys of fish biodiversity in southern Te Wāhipounamu/Fiordland (Aotearoa/New Zealand)

Small marine reserves provide conservation benefits for coastal sharks in southern New Zealand

Regional Variations in Live Proportions of Southwest Pacific Cold-Water Coral Reefs

Assessing lobster and co-predator feeding rates on barrens-forming sea urchins in South East Australia

Anchor scour from shipping and the defaunation of rocky reefs: A quantitative assessment