Abstract:The history and philosophy of music education are traced with varied efforts to hone, enhance, and shift a strong tradition of performance-based instruction. The purpose of this study is to summarize the research of Gumm's empirical models of eight music teaching and six conducting approaches and their application in the profession across three decades toward varied philosophical aims. Each approach coordinates a distinct set of instructional and motivational behaviors toward a particular learning effect or outcome. Different balances of approaches reveal broader aims, such as performance, comprehensive musicianship, cooperative, discovery, and affective learning, or even basic on-task behavior. Broader yet are two overarching aims found in common to both music teaching and conducting-to control or release. Controlling music teaching asserts correct on-task behavior through clear task directions and corrective feedback, motivates attention to task nonverbally, efficiently fills time with active tasks, and clarifies and affirms positive learning. In contrast, cooperative group leadership releases interdependent learning, questioning fosters music concept learning, imagery and movement release artistry, and discussing unique perspectives releases independent ideas and feelings. In conducting, precise gestures control accurate timing, signals and alerts motivate attention, and mimicry of musician exertions controls physical tone production; whereas shaping of phrases and score markings release musical expression, psychosocially familiarized gestures foster interdependence, and tension-easing gestures release freer independent tone production. Control-oriented teaching is most prevalent across the field, yet links to greater burnout and appeals to accommodating students motivated by effort and ability more than students motivated by social and affective enjoyment of music. In conducting, music-oriented precision and expression are more prevalent than musician-oriented approaches. Releasing approaches are more prevalent in Western than Eastern culture, upper levels, early rehearsals well before concerts, smaller ensembles, competitive ensembles, and teachers and conductors with greater experience or varied movement training. Conclusive implications are that the key to motivation is to draw attention to specific and intentional forms of learning, and that whatever is motivated to attention also motivates a particular philosophy of music education. Future research is suggested in general music and ethnic, folk, popular, community, and professional music ensembles.

Music education in the twenty-first century: a psychological perspective

Developing identities in music education

Practices of Music Education and Learning Across the Lifespan: An Exploration of Values and Purposes

The civilizational return of Eastern “Rites and Music” and Western “Ethics” in modern music education

Reconfiguring music education for future-making: how?

Music education in the twenty-first century: a cross-cultural comparison of German and American music education towards a new concept of international dialogue

Technological Diversification of Music Education: Views of Contemporary Foreign Researchers

Stimulating music educator worldview change through a pedagogy of provocation, critical thinking and peer-review

4E Music Pedagogy and the Principles of Self-Organization

How children listen: multimodality and its implications for K-12 music education and music teacher education

Increasing Musical Persistence and Engagement in the Contemporary Music Classroom

What is music education for? Understanding and fostering routes into lifelong musical engagement

21st century conceptions of musical ability

1. Neuro-Psychological Benefits of Music Education

A Mixed-Methods Systematic Review Regarding Musical Universality in Academic Literature.

A Review of 20 Research for Music Teaching in Contemporary Junior High Schools in China

(Re)organizing the music curriculum as multicultural music education

Music in medical education: A critical interpretive synthesis

Music motivation depends on what to motivate: research review of Gumm's music teaching and conducting models

A Study on the Application of Music Education to Improve College Students’ Mental Health in the Context of 5G

Affordances in music education