Developing a core outcome set for fistulising perianal Crohn's disease
Kapil Sahnan,Phil J Tozer,Samuel O Adegbola,Matthew J Lee,Nick Heywood,Angus G K McNair,Daniel Hind,Nuha Yassin,Alan J Lobo,Steven R Brown,Shaji Sebastian,Robin K S Phillips,Phillip F C Lung,Omar D Faiz,Kay Crook,Sue Blackwell,Azmina Verjee,Ailsa L Hart,Nicola S Fearnhead,ENiGMA collaborators,John Abercrombie,Austin Acheson,Simon Anderson,Aidan Armstrong,James Arthur,Katherine Ashton,Sathish Babu,Ian Beales,Gauraang Bhatnagar,Stuart Bloom,Dominic Blunt,Matthew Brown,David Burling,Jeffrey Butterworth,Christopher Calvert,Rachel Cooney,Peter Coyne,Thomas Creed,Tamzin Cuming,Robert Dennis,Walter Douie,Irene Dunkley,Jayne Eaden,Jonathan Epstein,Martyn Evans,Simon Fallis,Beverley Fieldsend,Catherine Fraser,James Goodhand,Catherine Grierson,Ben Griffiths,Arun Gupta,Sanjay Gupta,Richard Guy,Alex Hall,Diane Hall,Nigel Hall,Steve Halligan,Laura Hancock,Marcus Harbord,Rachel Hargest,Barney Hawthorne,Bu Hayee,Emma Helbren,Paul Henderson,Tim Hoare,Stephen Holtham,Rajapandian Ilangovan,Matthew Johnson,Cheryl Kemp,Nicholas A Kennedy,Fevronia Kiparissi,Charles Knowles,Bee Lee,Wendy Lewis,Jimmy Limdi,Richard Lovegrove,Peter Maclean,Janis Maginnis,Steven Mann,John Mansfield,Michele Marshall,Charles Maxwell-Armstrong,Alistair Mcnair,Jasbir Nahal,Arvind Pallan,Gareth Parkes,Rajan Patel,Uday Patel,Leon Pee,Kathryn Phillis,Thomas Pinkney,Katie Planche,Richard Pollok,Niall Power,Mark Puckett,Abdul Razack,Kerry Robinson,Dan Rogers,Richard K Russell,Mathew Rutter,Suzanne Ryan,Judith Salaman,John Saunders,Christian Selinger,Irshad Shaikh,Ian Shaw,Baljit Singh,Ederis Sitchon,Christopher Smart,Neil Smart,Adam Stearns,Ben Stubbs,Stuart A Taylor,Julian Teare,Tony C Tham,Pradeep Thomas,John Todd,Jared Torkington,Simon Travis,Mark Tremelling,Tracey Tyrrell,Christos Tzivinikos,Carolynne Vaizey,Oliver Warren,Janindra Warusavitarne,Emma Wesley,Debbie West,Emma Whitehead,Graham Williams,Mark Wills,Graeme Wilson,Eleanor Wood,Hannah Yarrow,Lisa Younge
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/gutjnl-2017-315503
IF: 24.5
Gut
Abstract:Objective: Lack of standardised outcomes hampers effective analysis and comparison of data when comparing treatments in fistulising perianal Crohn's disease (pCD). Development of a standardised set of outcomes would resolve these issues. This study provides the definitive core outcome set (COS) for fistulising pCD. Design: Candidate outcomes were generated through a systematic review and patient interviews. Consensus was established via a three-round Delphi process using a 9-point Likert scale based on how important they felt it was in determining treatment success culminating in a final consensus meeting. Stakeholders were recruited nationally and grouped into three panels (surgeons and radiologists, gastroenterologists and IBD specialist nurses, and patients). Participants received feedback from their panel (in the second round) and all participants (in the third round) to allow refinement of their scores. Results: A total of 295 outcomes were identified from systematic reviews and interviews that were categorised into 92 domains. 187 stakeholders (response rate 78.5%) prioritised 49 outcomes through a three-round Delphi study. The final consensus meeting of 41 experts and patients generated agreement on an eight domain COS. The COS comprised three patient-reported outcome domains (quality of life, incontinence and a combined score of patient priorities) and five clinician-reported outcome domains (perianal disease activity, development of new perianal abscess/sepsis, new/recurrent fistula, unplanned surgery and faecal diversion). Conclusion: A fistulising pCD COS has been produced by all key stakeholders. Application of the COS will reduce heterogeneity in outcome reporting, thereby facilitating more meaningful comparisons between treatments, data synthesis and ultimately benefit patient care.