Authentic leadership – for better and for worse? Leader well-being and inconsistency as moderating factors in the relation between daily authentic leadership and follower well-being

Astrid. I. Macamo,Kai. N. Klasmeier
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/1359432x.2024.2361511
2024-06-05
European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology
Abstract:Despite comprehensive insights on favourable outcomes of authentic leadership for followers, there is a limited understanding about boundary conditions of authentic leadership. Leaders' decreased well-being (i.e. high trait emotional irritation and low trait work engagement) or inconsistency in authentic leadership may attenuate the relation between authentic leadership and follower well-being (i.e. emotional irritation and work engagement). We tested these assumptions using a daily diary study design over five consecutive working days with a sample of 64 leaders and 162 followers. We found partial support for the cross-level moderation of authentic leadership inconsistency across these five days, as daily authentic leadership was related to daily work engagement (but not emotional irritation) of followers, when authentic leadership inconsistency was low. Contrary to our predictions, neither high leader trait emotional irritation nor low leader trait work engagement attenuated the relation between daily authentic leadership and daily follower well-being. The results point out to the importance of consistency in authentic leadership behaviour. However, leaders do not need to be overly concerned about negative consequences for followers when they lead authentically while having a reduced trait well-being.
psychology, applied,management
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? This paper mainly explores the relationship between authentic leadership and follower well - being, especially whether this relationship will be affected when the leader's own well - being is low or shows inconsistency. Specifically, the authors focus on the following two boundary conditions: 1. **Reduction in leader well - being**: Including high trait emotional irritation and low trait work engagement, whether these factors will affect the positive impact of authentic leadership on follower well - being. 2. **Consistency of authentic leadership behavior**: Whether the authentic leadership behavior of leaders is consistent between different days, and whether this consistency will affect its impact on follower well - being. #### Research background and motivation Although previous studies have shown that authentic leadership has many positive impacts on subordinates, there are few studies on its boundary conditions. In particular, when the leader's own well - being is low or the behavior is inconsistent, the effect of authentic leadership may be weakened or even have a negative impact. Therefore, the researchers hope to better understand these boundary conditions through this study and thus provide guidance for practice. #### Main hypotheses 1. **Hypothesis 1**: Daily authentic leadership behavior will be negatively correlated with subordinates' daily emotional irritation (H1a) and positively correlated with subordinates' daily work engagement (H1b). 2. **Hypothesis 2**: The leader's emotional irritation will weaken the positive relationship between daily authentic leadership behavior and follower well - being (H2a: low emotional irritation; H2b: high work engagement). 3. **Hypothesis 3**: The leader's work engagement will strengthen the positive relationship between daily authentic leadership behavior and follower well - being (H3a: low emotional irritation; H3b: high work engagement). 4. **Hypothesis 4**: The consistency of authentic leadership behavior will weaken the positive relationship between daily authentic leadership behavior and follower well - being (H4a: low emotional irritation; H4b: high work engagement). #### Research methods The study adopted a five - day diary study design. The participants included 64 leaders and 162 subordinates. Through diary records, the researchers were able to capture daily authentic leadership behavior and its impact on follower well - being. In addition, the study also examined the moderating role of leader trait well - being (such as emotional irritation and work engagement) and the consistency of authentic leadership behavior on this relationship. ### Summary This paper aims to deeply explore the effect of authentic leadership under specific conditions, especially whether the impact of this leadership style on follower well - being will be weakened when the leader's own well - being is low or the behavior is inconsistent. The research results are not only helpful for theoretical deepening, but also provide important guiding significance for practical management.