Willie: The Life of W. Somerset Maugham by Robert Calder

Munro Beattie

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1353/esc.1990.0042

1990-01-01

Abstract:porary scene of literary production, but also with a tradition of fiction that continues into the twentieth century. At the very end of his study Mulvihill mentions that some of Aldous Huxley’s early work may owe something to Peacock, and that perhaps the novels of Evelyn Waugh, Thomas Pynchon, and John Barth may also fall back on Peacock’s influence. These connec­ tions may or may not be tenuous, but if we need more work on Peacock, if we want to bring him in from the cold of the margins, then this is the direction further study might take. Another introduction we need not. g . k i m b l a n k / University of Victoria Robert Calder, Willie: The Life of W. Somerset Maugham (Toronto: Gen­ eral, 1989). xviii, 429, photos. $34.95 Are we really in need of a new biography of Somerset Maugham? Robert Calder (professor of English at the University of Saskatchewan) contends that, with one exception, none of the earlier studies — such as Robin Maugham’s Somerset and All the Maughams, Garson Kanin’s Remembering Mr. Maugham, Frederic Raphael’s Somerset Maugham and His World, and Anthony Curtis’s Somerset Maugham — tells the whole story. The excep­ tion, Ted Morgan’s Maugham of 1980, does indeed expose Maugham with a fullness and explicitness never before possible but with gross misjudgments of emphasis and tone. The reader of Morgan’s Maugham should probably confess to a depraved taste. It reveals, in Calder’s view, “an essential dis­ taste for its subject, which casts almost everything in the darkest light.” Calder raises few questions about Morgan’s factual accuracy, but emphat­ ically, and somewhat resentfully, impugns his interpretation of Maugham’s character. “I am convinced,” Calder declares, “that the longstanding and inaccurate perception of [Maugham] as a malicious, bitter, and spiteful mis­ anthrope must be replaced by a portrait which recognizes his sensitivity, wit, loyalty, and numerous kindnesses to many people.” Calder’s biography is thorough, reasonable, and perceptive. It provides an abundance of data for a re-assessment of Maugham’s personality. The title — Willie, as Maugham was known to a host of acquaintances — suggests what Calder has aimed at: a close-up view through understanding eyes. (Another celebrated Willie moved through some of the same years though in different circles: W.B. Yeats.) No one, not even Calder, can make of Somerset Maugham an entirely sympathetic character. Kenneth Clark was a frequent guest at the Villa Mauresque at Cap Ferrat, the opulent by-product of a singularly remunerative career. Clark and his wife found their visits 11 4 “rather a strain. . . . Mr. Maugham was exceedingly kind to us and we grew to have a genuine affection for him, so it sounds ungrateful to say that we always left the Villa Mauresque with feelings of relief.” Maugham, another observer remembered, brought a chill into whatever room he entered. Robin Maugham believed that “his uncle could have written a great novel had he been free to deal openly with a homosexual subject.” All things are possible, but Calder is content to conclude his discussion with a question that is already merely rhetorical: “ . . . what enormous damage was done to Maugham’s creativity by his shutting off or disguising his most natu­ ral and deeply felt urges — those of the homosexual?” He copes fairly well with this theme, the effect of covert homosexuality upon Maugham’s fiction. Not altogether convincing are his endeavours to find intimations of homosexuality in, for instance, The Narrow Corner, “Red,” “The Book Bag,” or “The Facts of Life.” He eyes suspiciously, as others have done, the sexuality of Mildred in Of Human Bondage — speculation here much vexed by Bette Davis’s high camp image, irresistible but scarcely accurate, in the 1934 film version — but shies away, in the end, from a clear-cut verdict. Not that it matters much. The Agnostinelli-Albertine permutations are the least interesting of Proustian topics. Calder is more rewarding when he discovers in Maugham’s style as a writer, as in his behaviour as a man, a strenuous control which may speak of internal tension and torment. The reproduction on the dust-jacket of Graham Sutherland’s powerful...