Blending Efficiency and Resilience in the Performance Assessment of Urban Intersections: A Novel Heuristic Informed by Literature Review

Nazanin Zare,Elżbieta Macioszek,Anna Granà,Tullio Giuffrè

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16062450

IF: 3.9

2024-03-16

Sustainability

Abstract:Urban mobility underscores the vital importance of ensuring traffic efficiency on road segments, intersections, and transportation networks, especially in challenging circumstances. In this perspective, the essential approach to improving urban intersection efficiency should involve understanding critical factors for maintaining operational performance in the face of disruptions such as storms. This paper, inspired by a systematic literature review, presents a novel heuristic for evaluating urban intersection efficiency, with resilience as its guiding principle. The methodological path was designed to address the fundamental question: How can urban intersections be designed and managed to ensure efficiency and resilience in the face of disruptions? Drawing inspiration from the Highway Capacity Manual procedure, the methodological approach encompasses both pre-storm and post-storm scenarios, comparing delay times at roundabouts and signalized intersections before and after a storm. The results reveal significant changes in delay times for traffic signals, although the choice between roundabouts and signalized intersections should be context-specific, considering factors like traffic conditions, resilience requirements, and associated trade-offs. By shedding light on the interplay between intersection design, control strategies, and urban resilience, this research provides valuable insights into integrating resilience considerations into intersection performance assessment and management strategies. It also underscores how particular intersection designs can impact efficiency and recovery, essential considerations when assessing whether a road or intersection project is resilient.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Aims to Solve

This paper aims to address the issue of evaluating the efficiency and resilience of urban intersections in the face of sudden events such as natural disasters. Specifically, the study proposes a new heuristic method to assess the efficiency of urban intersections, with resilience as the core principle.

#### Research Background
- **Urban Mobility**: Ensuring that road segments, intersections, and traffic networks operate efficiently under challenging conditions (e.g., during storms) is crucial.
- **Concept of Resilience**: Resilience involves not only adaptability but also the ability of the system to recover when facing external threats (e.g., natural disasters) and internal challenges (e.g., increased traffic demand).
- **Limitations of Existing Literature**: Current assessment tools lack evidence-based analysis, and systematic and comprehensive resilience assessment methods are underutilized in urban areas and complex road infrastructures.

#### Research Methods
- **Heuristic Method**: This method combines pre-storm and post-storm scenarios, comparing the changes in delay times at roundabouts and signal-controlled intersections before and after the storm.
- **Indicator Selection**: The average control delay time is chosen as the measurement indicator, defined as the additional travel time experienced by drivers, passengers, or pedestrians.
- **Case Study**: An analysis is conducted using actual urban road intersection cases to explore the impact of different designs and control modes on efficiency and resilience.

#### Main Contributions
- **Comprehensive Assessment Framework**: A flexible assessment method is proposed, seamlessly integrating efficiency and resilience, applicable to various intersection design scenarios.
- **Social Contribution**: Provides key insights into the relationship between intersection design, control strategies, and urban resilience, aiding in the future design and management of traffic infrastructure.

Through this study, the authors fill a specific gap in the existing literature regarding the combined assessment of efficiency and resilience in urban intersection performance evaluation.