Abstract:Gridded analyses of observed precipitation are an important data resource for environmental modelling, climate model evaluation and climate monitoring. In Europe, datasets that resolve the rich mesoscale variations widely exist for the national territories, but similar datasets covering the entire continent are more recent. Here, we evaluate daily precipitation in two newly available pan‐European datasets: E‐OBS (v19.0e), a statistical analysis from rain‐gauge data, and ERA5, the new global reanalysis from ECMWF. Special interest is on how the refinements of grid spacing, the methodological upgrades and the quantification of uncertainty (ensemble), bear on capabilities at the mesoscale. The evaluation is conducted in three subregions, the Alps, the Carpathians and Fennoscandia, and involves as reference high‐quality regional datasets derived from dense rain‐gauge data. The study suggests that E‐OBS and ERA5 agree qualitatively well with the reference datasets. Major mesoscale patterns in the climatology (mean, wet‐day frequency, 95% quantile) are reproduced. The improvement over earlier versions of the datasets is evident. ERA5 was found to overestimate mean precipitation in all regions, related to too many wet days. The accuracy of E‐OBS was found to depend on station density, with spatial and temporal variations clearly less accurate in data sparse regions. In comparison, E‐OBS turned out to be superior to ERA5 in regions with dense data, but the two datasets are on a par in regions with sparse data, and partly ERA5 has advantages. For both datasets we find that the spatial resolution is coarser than the grid spacing, with overly smooth fields and an underestimation of high quantiles. Also, both datasets were found to be clearly overconfident in their uncertainty characterization (too small ensemble spread). Overall, the two datasets advance the characterization of precipitation on a pan‐European scale, but users are advised to take residual limitations into account in applications. We found that both test datasets, E‐OBS and ERA5, reproduce major mesoscale patterns in the precipitation climatology and that they have improved over earlier versions of the datasets. While ERA5 overestimates mean precipitation in all investigated regions (Alps, Carpathians, Fennoscandia), the accuracy of E‐OBS was found to depend on station density. Overall, their spatial resolution is coarser than their grid spacing, with overly smooth fields. Also, both datasets were found to be overconfident in their uncertainty characterization.

Analysis of extreme precipitation over Europe from different reanalyses: a comparative assessment

Evaluation of daily precipitation analyses in E‐OBS (v19.0e) and ERA5 by comparison to regional high‐resolution datasets in European regions

Changes in regional daily precipitation intensity and spatial structure from global reanalyses

Impact of horizontal resolution and model time step on European precipitation extremes in the OpenIFS 43r3 atmosphere model

Investigating the comparative utility of ECMWF precipitation forecasts as an alternative to reanalysis data

Evaluation of IMERG and MSG-CPP precipitation estimates over Europe using EURADCLIM: a gauge-adjusted European composite radar dataset

Extreme Precipitation Changes in Europe from the Last Millennium to the End of the Twenty-First Century

A Climatology of Convective Precipitation over Europe

Are trends in convective parameters over the United States and Europe consistent between reanalyses and observations?

Evaluating long‐term trends in annual precipitation: A temporal consistency analysis of ERA5 data in the Alps and Italy

Variability of Hourly Precipitation During the Warm Season over Eastern China Using Gauge Observations and ERA5

Comparison of Products from ERA-40, NCEP-2, and CRU with Station Data for Summer Precipitation over China

Global-scale ERA5 Product Precipitation and Temperature Evaluation

Regional centennial precipitation variability over Germany from extended observation records

Intercomparison of annual precipitation indices and extremes over global land areas from in situ, space-based and reanalysis products

Multi-scale assessment of high-resolution reanalysis precipitation fields over Italy

Can Reanalysis Datasets Describe the Persistent Temperature and Precipitation Extremes over China?

Assessment of summer monsoon precipitation derived from five reanalysis datasets over East Asia

Indices for Daily Temperature and Precipitation Extremes in Europe Analyzed for the Period 1901–2000

How Well Does the ERA5 Reanalysis Capture the Extreme Climate Events Over China? Part I: Extreme Precipitation

Evaluation of IMERG and ERA5 precipitation products over the Mongolian Plateau