Accounting practitioners' perspectives of professional skills and audit capabilities of first year trainee accountants

Rolien Kunz

Abstract:As an unconscious reaction to changes within the working environment in which accounting professionals operate, accounting practitioners increasingly expect accounting graduates to possess not only the technical knowledge necessary to do their work, but also the broader range of professional skills that will help them to be successful in the working environment. This paper focuses on determining the professional skills expectations of employers, and the proficiency in these skills demonstrated by first year trainee accountants in the first three months of their training contracts (these trainees will be referred to as newly employed first year trainee accountants for the remainder of the research paper), within a South African context: it identifies and quantifies the issues of “what is expected”, “how much do they know” and “how big is the gap”. A questionnaire survey was used to determine the perceptions and expectations of audit managers, and their assessments of the actual capabilities of newly employed first year trainee accountants with regard to professional skills. The findings indicated that audit managers expect the highest level of capability (capable with minimum/without supervision) to be achieved in the business ethics professional skills category, and that newly employed first year trainee accountants do not meet audit managers’ expectations: the audit managers’ expectations always exceeded newly employed first year trainee accountants’ performance. The professional skills category with the largest expectation-performance difference was the personal attributes category, with a 31.6% difference. The findings reported in this paper could assist the South African Institute of Chartered Accountants (SAICA) to improve its competency framework and (re)assess the effectiveness of the implementation and evaluation of the development of professional skills at/by accredited universities. It could also be © University of Pretoria 16 utilised by accredited universities and academics to prompt reflection on ways to improve the manner in which professional skills are presented in their syllabi. Lastly, the findings could assist training officers at audit firms and other approved training providers to (re)develop and implement appropriate professional skills training opportunities for trainee accountants. 2.

Medicine,Business