Evaluating the Effect of Deficit Irrigation on Yield and Water Use Efficiency of Drip Irrigation Cotton under Film in Xinjiang Based on Meta-Analysis

Qi Xu,Xiaomei Dong,Weixiong Huang,Zhaoyang Li,Tongtong Huang,Zaijin Song,Yuhui Yang,Jinsai Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/plants13050640

2024-02-27

Plants

Abstract:Water scarcity constrains the sustainable development of Chinese agriculture, and deficit irrigation as a new irrigation technology can effectively alleviate the problems of water scarcity and water use inefficiency in agriculture. In this study, the drip irrigation cotton field under film in Xinjiang was taken as the research object. Meta-analysis and machine learning were used to quantitatively analyze the effects of different farm management practices, climate, and soil conditions on cotton yield and water use efficiency under deficit irrigation, to investigate the importance of the effects of different factors on cotton yield and water use efficiency, and to formulate appropriate optimization strategies. The results showed that deficit irrigation significantly increased cotton water use efficiency (7.39%) but decreased cotton yield (−15.00%) compared with full irrigation. All three deficit irrigation levels (80~100% FI, 60~80% FI, and 40~60% FI; FI: full irrigation) showed a significant decrease in cotton yield and a significant increase in water use efficiency. Under deficit irrigation, cotton yield reduction was the smallest and cotton water use efficiency increased the most when planted with one film, two tubes, a six-row cropping pattern, an irrigation frequency ≥10 times, a nitrogen application of 300~400 kg·ha−1, and a crop density ≥240,000 per hectare, and planted with the Xinluzhong series of cotton varieties; deficit irrigation in areas with average annual temperature >10 °C, annual evapotranspiration >2000 mm, annual precipitation <60 mm, and with loam, sandy soil had the least inhibition of cotton yield and the greatest increase in cotton water use efficiency. The results of the random forest showed that the irrigation amount and nitrogen application had the greatest influence on cotton yield and water use efficiency. Rational irrigation based on optimal management practices under conditions of irrigation not less than 90% FI is expected to achieve a win–win situation for both cotton yield and water use efficiency. The above results can provide the best strategy for deficit irrigation and efficient water use in drip irrigation cotton under film in arid areas.

plant sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the impact of deficit irrigation on the yield and water use efficiency of mulched drip-irrigated cotton in the Xinjiang region. The study employs meta-analysis and machine learning methods to quantitatively analyze the effects of different agricultural management practices, climate conditions, and soil conditions on cotton yield and water use efficiency.

Specifically, the study found:

1. **Overall Impact**:
- Compared to full irrigation, deficit irrigation significantly increased cotton water use efficiency (by approximately 7.39%) but reduced cotton yield (by approximately -15.00%).

2. **Impact of Irrigation Amount and Drip Tape Pattern**:
- When the irrigation amount was 80-100% of full irrigation, the reduction in cotton yield was minimal (approximately -7.46%); water use efficiency increased the most when the irrigation amount was 40-60% of full irrigation (approximately 25.95%).
- Using the "one film, two pipes, six rows" drip tape pattern, the reduction in cotton yield was minimal (approximately -7.65%), and the increase in water use efficiency was the greatest (approximately 28.10%).

3. **Impact of Irrigation Frequency and Nitrogen Fertilizer Application**:
- When the irrigation frequency was ≥10 times, the reduction in cotton yield was less (approximately -12.08%), and the increase in water use efficiency was more significant (approximately 13.90%).
- When the nitrogen fertilizer application was 300-400 kg/hectare, the reduction in cotton yield was less (approximately -13.91%), and the increase in water use efficiency was more significant (approximately 10.55%).

4. **Impact of Variety and Planting Density**:
- When planting the Xinlu series cotton varieties, the reduction in cotton yield was most significantly inhibited (approximately -12.68%), and the increase in water use efficiency was the greatest (approximately 16.55%).
- When the cotton planting density was ≥240,000 plants/hectare, the reduction in cotton yield was significantly lower.

5. **Impact of Climate and Soil Conditions**:
- Under conditions of an average annual temperature >10°C, annual evaporation >2000 mm, annual precipitation <60 mm, and sandy loam soil, the inhibitory effect of deficit irrigation on cotton yield was minimal, and the increase in water use efficiency was the greatest.
- When the soil was loam or sandy soil, the reduction in cotton yield caused by deficit irrigation was minimal.

6. **Irrigation Strategy and Balance Analysis**:
- The study found through a random forest model that irrigation amount, nitrogen fertilizer application, and average annual temperature had a significant impact on cotton yield; nitrogen fertilizer application, initial soil organic carbon content, and irrigation amount had a significant impact on water use efficiency.
- Rational irrigation strategies (irrigation amount not less than 90% of full irrigation) combined with optimal management measures are expected to achieve a win-win situation for cotton yield and water use efficiency.

In summary, the study reveals the potential of deficit irrigation technology in addressing water resource shortages and provides recommendations for optimizing irrigation strategies for mulched drip-irrigated cotton in the Xinjiang region.