Sebastián Antonio Gutiérrez-Romero,Erika Sofía Torres-Narváez,Adrián Camilo Zamora-Gómez,Silvana Castillo-Castillo,Angela Liliana Latorre-Velásquez,Carolina Betancourt-Villamizar,Carlos O. Mendivil
Abstract:In this randomised, placebo-controlled trial, adults with impaired sleep (Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index ≥ 5) were randomly assigned using a minimization algorithm to receive a formulation containing l -theanine plus lemon balm, valerian, and saffron extracts, or placebo, during 6 weeks. Objective sleep quality parameters were measured using an actigraphy device. We enrolled and randomised 64 individuals, 31 from the active group and 27 from the placebo group completed the 6 week follow-up. Mean sleep efficiency remained unmodified in the active group, and increased by 3% in the placebo group, the between-group difference in the change was not statistically significant (p = 0.49). Total sleep time also improved more with placebo (13.0 vs. 1.33 min, p = 0.66). Time wake after sleep onset (WASO) decreased more in the active group (4.6% vs. 2.4%), but the difference was not significant (p = 0.33). Mean PSQI decreased by 3.11 points (32.3%) in the active group, and by 3.86 points (39.5%) in the placebo group (p = 0.41). SF-36 increased more with placebo (+ 18.3 in active, + 32.1 in placebo, p = 0.68). Salivary cortisol remained unchanged in both groups. No serious adverse events were reported. Among adults with impaired sleep, a nutraceutical combination did not improve objective or subjective sleep parameters more than a placebo infusion.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### The problems the paper attempts to solve
The paper aims to evaluate the effect of a combination of nutritional supplements on sleep quality, especially in adults with sleep disorders. Specifically, researchers hope to evaluate through a randomized, double - blind, placebo - controlled trial whether this combination of nutritional supplements containing green tea extract, lemon balm extract, valerian extract and saffron extract can effectively improve objective and subjective sleep parameters within 6 weeks.
### Research background
1. **The importance of sleep**:
- Sleep is a fundamental biological process for human health, which helps with energy conservation, tissue repair, metabolism and immune adaptation, as well as memory consolidation and the clearance of harmful metabolites.
- There are significant differences in sleep among different species, mainly influenced by environmental conditions and dietary requirements.
2. **The prevalence of sleep disorders**:
- According to the 2021 Philips Global Sleep Survey, only 55% of adults worldwide are satisfied with their sleep.
- Most adults have an average nightly sleep time that is 1.2 hours less than the recommended time (6.8 hours vs. 7 - 9 hours). Eighty percent of adults hope to improve their sleep quality, but less than half of them have consulted medical professionals.
3. **Interventions**:
- To improve sleep quality, a variety of interventions have been tested, including nutritional supplements made from plants or plant extracts.
- Although public interest in nutritional supplements and advertising exposure have increased rapidly, there is still a lack of high - quality randomized trial data, especially regarding the effectiveness and safety of these supplement combinations.
### Research objectives
- **Primary objective**: Evaluate the effect of a combination of nutritional supplements containing green tea extract, lemon balm extract, valerian extract and saffron extract on sleep efficiency.
- **Secondary objective**: Evaluate the effect of this combination of nutritional supplements on the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI), wake - after - sleep - onset time (WASO), total sleep time, salivary cortisol level and quality of life (SF - 36).
### Methods
- **Research design**: Randomized, double - blind, placebo - controlled clinical trial.
- **Participants**: Adults aged 18 years and older, with a Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI) ≥ 5, not receiving any specific sleep - improvement treatment, and not planning to use any sleep - improvement methods in the next 2 months.
- **Random grouping**: Grouped by age, gender and baseline PSQI using the minimization algorithm.
- **Intervention measures**: The experimental group takes the nutritional supplement containing the above - mentioned plant extracts 1 hour before going to bed every day, and the placebo group takes a placebo without active ingredients.
- **Evaluation indicators**: The primary outcome indicator is the change in sleep efficiency within 6 weeks. Secondary outcome indicators include changes in PSQI, WASO, total sleep time, salivary cortisol level and SF - 36 score.
### Results
- **Primary outcome**: There was no significant change in sleep efficiency in the experimental group, while the sleep efficiency in the placebo group increased by 3%, but the difference between the two groups was not statistically significant (p = 0.49).
- **Secondary outcomes**:
- PSQI improved significantly in both groups. It decreased by 3.11 points (32.3%) in the experimental group and 3.86 points (39.5%) in the placebo group, but the difference between the two groups was not significant (p = 0.41).
- WASO decreased by 4.6% in the experimental group and 2.4% in the placebo group, but the difference was not significant (p = 0.33).
- Total sleep time increased by 13.0 minutes in the placebo group, while it only increased by 1.33 minutes in the experimental group, but the difference was not significant (p = 0.66).
- The quality of life (SF - 36) score increased by 32.1 points in the placebo group and 18.3 points in the experimental group, but the difference was not significant (p = 0.68).
- Salivary cortisol levels remained stable in both groups.
### Conclusion
The study found that although both the experimental group and the placebo group improved in multiple sleep parameters, the combination of nutritional supplements was not significantly better than the placebo. This result emphasizes the potential importance of the placebo effect in objective sleep measurement.