Can cooperation reduce yield risks associated with infectious diseases in shrimp aquaculture in Vietnam?

Ho Hong Lien,Yann de Mey,Dang Kieu Nhan,Simon Bush,Miranda P.M. Meuwissen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13657305.2024.2301996
IF: 4.016
2024-01-18
Aquaculture Economics & Management
Abstract:Infectious diseases are a major threat to Asian shrimp aquaculture, as they proliferate at system level rather than only the individual level. We assess the impact of various forms of cooperation among Vietnamese farmers on yield risks caused by white spot disease and acute hepatopancreatic necrosis disease. Using a stochastic simulation model, we simulate shrimp farming yield risks based on input from two expert workshops. The results provide a relative comparison of expected yield losses caused by both diseases comparing a baseline scenario (no cooperation) and three scenarios with varying degrees of synchronization and information sharing across farms. Results show lower expected yield losses in all three cooperation scenarios in comparison with the farm-based scenario, highlighting the value of synchronization and information sharing practices to mitigate yield losses. We discuss the potential this has to reduce systemic risks in aquaculture, thereby potentially incentivizing the reintroduction of risk-sharing mechanisms.
agricultural economics & policy,fisheries
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores whether different forms of cooperation in Vietnam's shrimp farming industry can reduce yield risks caused by infectious diseases, particularly White Spot Syndrome (WSD) and Acute Hepatopancreatic Necrosis Disease (AHPND). The research team constructed a stochastic simulation model to assess the impact of diseases on yield under a no-cooperation scenario (baseline scenario) and three different cooperation scenarios (synchronization, information sharing, and a combination of both). Specifically, the study collected data through two expert workshops to parameterize the stochastic simulation model. These workshops were conducted in English and Vietnamese, respectively, and included both international and local Vietnamese experts. The goal of the workshops was to discuss cooperation scenarios and assess disease incidence and mortality rates under each scenario. The study results indicate that the expected yield losses are lower in all three cooperation scenarios compared to the baseline scenario. Specifically, for WSD, experts from the English workshop considered synchronization to be the most effective strategy, while experts from the Vietnamese workshop believed that a combination of synchronization and information sharing was the most effective. For AHPND, experts from both workshops agreed that synchronization combined with information sharing was the most effective. In summary, the main issue addressed by the paper is whether cooperation among farmers in Vietnam's open shrimp farming systems can mitigate systemic yield risks caused by infectious diseases. The simulation study found that cooperation indeed helps to reduce such risks.