Abstract:In recent years, the research of humanoid robots that can change users' opinions has been conducted extensively. In particular, two robots have been found to be able to improve their persuasiveness by cooperating with each other in a sophisticated manner. Previous studies have evaluated the changes in opinions when robots showed consensus building. However, users did not participate in the conversations, and the optimal strategy may change depending on their prior opinions. Therefore, in this study, we developed a system that adaptively changes conversations between robots based on user opinions. We investigate the effect on the change in opinions when the discussion converges to the same position as the user and when it converges to a different position. We conducted two subject experiments in which a user and virtual robotic agents talked to each other using buttons in a crowded setting. The results showed that users with confidence in their opinions increased their confidence when the robot agents' opinions converged to the same position and decreased their confidence when the robot agents' opinions converged to a different position. This will significantly contribute to persuasion research using multiple robots and the development of advanced dialogue coordination between robots.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper aims to explore whether establishing a consensus through dialogue between robots can change users' opinions. Specifically, the researchers developed a system that adaptively changes the dialogue between robots based on the user's viewpoint. The study focuses on the following two aspects: 1. **When the dialogue ultimately aligns with the user's viewpoint**, does the user's confidence in their viewpoint increase? 2. **When the dialogue ultimately does not align with the user's viewpoint**, does the user's confidence in their viewpoint decrease? ### Research Background In recent years, there has been increasing research on humanoid robots capable of changing users' opinions. In particular, two robots can enhance their persuasiveness through cooperation. Previous studies have evaluated changes in users' opinions when robots demonstrate consensus-building, but in these studies, users did not participate in the dialogue, and the best strategy may vary depending on the user's initial viewpoint. Therefore, this study further explores the impact of different dialogue strategies on changes in users' opinions by involving users in the dialogue. ### Research Methods The researchers designed two experiments in which users engaged in dialogue with two virtual robot agents in a crowded environment. During the experiments, users responded to the robots' questions by selecting buttons. The researchers evaluated changes in users' opinions before and after the dialogue and analyzed the relationship between the effectiveness of dialogue strategies and the users' confidence in their opinions before the dialogue. ### Main Hypotheses - **H1**: When robots demonstrate the same opinion as the user, the user's confidence in their viewpoint will be higher than when they do not demonstrate it. - **H2**: When robots demonstrate a different opinion from the user, the user's confidence in their viewpoint will be lower than when they do not demonstrate it. ### Experimental Results - **Degree of Opinion Change**: Analysis using a linear mixed model (LMM) found a significant interaction between the condition (whether the robots agree with the user's viewpoint) and the user's initial confidence. Specifically, when the user's initial confidence was high, the user's confidence in their viewpoint significantly decreased when the robots disagreed with their viewpoint; this effect was not evident when the user's initial confidence was low. - **Questionnaire Results**: In subsequent questionnaires, the researchers found that when the robots agreed with the user's viewpoint, the user's ratings of the persuasiveness, friendliness, depth of understanding, and confidence in the dialogue were higher than when the robots disagreed with the user's viewpoint. ### Conclusion This study confirms that establishing a consensus through dialogue between robots can effectively change users' opinions. Specifically, when robots demonstrate the same opinion as the user, the user's confidence in their viewpoint increases; when robots demonstrate a different opinion from the user, the user's confidence in their viewpoint decreases. This finding is significant for the coordination strategies of multi-robot dialogue systems and persuasion research.

Effects of Demonstrating Consensus Between Robots to Change User's Opinion

Promoting Mutual Adaptation in Haptic Negotiation Using Adaptive Virtual Fixture

Acceptable dialogue robot with a side participant robot for group recommendation

Having Different Dialog Roles in Telecommunication by Using Two Teleoperated Robots Reduces an Operator's Guilt

Multiparty conversation via multirobot system: incorporation of nonverbal user responses for continued conversation

Improving User's Sense of Participation in Robot-Driven Dialogue

Can Robotic Cues Manipulate Human Decisions? Exploring Consensus Building via Bias-Controlled Non-linear Opinion Dynamics and Robotic Eye Gaze Mediated Interaction in Human-Robot Teaming

Assessing the effect of persuasive robots interactive social cues on users’ psychological reactance, liking, trusting beliefs and compliance

Building Persuasive Robots with Social Power Strategies

Multi-robot behavior adaptation to local and global communication atmosphere in humans-robots interaction

The role of reciprocity in human-robot social influence

Agreebot introduction dialogue in human–robot interaction: improving the acceptability of robot statements on incapable robotic experiences

Is Two Better than One? Effects of Multiple Agents on User Persuasion

Improving the closing sequences of interaction between human and robot through conversation analysis

"That Robot Stared Back at Me!": Demonstrating Perceptual Ability Is Key to Successful Human-Robot Interactions

Assessing the influence of an android robot's persuasive behaviors and context of violation on compliance

Influence of perspective taking through robotic virtual agents on prosocial behavior

Twin-Robot Dialogue System with Robustness against Speech Recognition Failure in Human-Robot Dialogue with Elderly People

Which One? Choosing Favorite Robot After Different Styles of Storytelling and Robots' Conversation

A study on the influence of service robots' level of anthropomorphism on the willingness of users to follow their recommendations

Empirical Investigation of Factors that Influence Human Presence and Agency in Telepresence Robot