Relaxing the assumption of conditional independence in an asymptotic single risk factor model

Frederic Menninger

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21314/jor.2024.013

IF: 0.645

2024-12-04

The Journal of Operational Risk

Abstract:Within the framework of dynamic credit provisioning and stress testing, this paper shows how conditional correlation impacts an asymptotic single risk factor model.

business, finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Credit Risk Meets Random Matrices: Coping with Non-Stationary Asset Correlations

Andreas Mühlbacher,Thomas Guhr

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1803.00261

2018-03-01

Abstract:We review recent progress in modeling credit risk for correlated assets. We start from the Merton model which default events and losses are derived from the asset values at maturity. To estimate the time development of the asset values, the stock prices are used whose correlations have a strong impact on the loss distribution, particularly on its tails. These correlations are non-stationary which also influences the tails. We account for the asset fluctuations by averaging over an ensemble of random matrices that models the truly existing set of measured correlation matrices. As a most welcome side effect, this approach drastically reduces the parameter dependence of the loss distribution, allowing us to obtain very explicit results which show quantitatively that the heavy tails prevail over diversification benefits even for small correlations. We calibrate our random matrix model with market data and show how it is capable of grasping different market situations. Furthermore, we present numerical simulations for concurrent portfolio risks, i.e., for the joint probability densities of losses for two portfolios. For the convenience of the reader, we give an introduction to the Wishart random matrix model.

Risk Management,Statistical Finance
Asymptotics for A Class of Dependent Random Variables

Li-Xin Zhang,Yang Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spl.2015.05.018

IF: 0.718

2015-01-01

Statistics & Probability Letters

Abstract:We consider a class of dependent random variables where the dependence structure involves a factor driven by Sn/n. Under very mild conditions for the innovation, we obtain several asymptotic results for the partial sums including basic asymptotics and strong limit theorems. The fact that the asymptotic properties differ strikingly in a neighbour of a critical point makes the model very interesting.
Conditional Tail Expectation Decomposition and Conditional Mean Risk Sharing for Dependent and Conditionally Independent Losses

Michel Denuit,Christian Y. Robert

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11009-021-09888-0

2021-10-09

Methodology And Computing In Applied Probability

Abstract:Conditional tail expectations are often used in risk measurement and capital allocation. Conditional mean risk sharing appears to be effective in collaborative insurance, to distribute total losses among participants. This paper develops analytical results for risk allocation among different, correlated units based on conditional tail expectations and conditional mean risk sharing. Results available in the literature for independent risks are extended to correlated ones, in a unified way. The approach is applied to mixture models with correlated latent factors that are often used in practice. Conditional Monte Carlo simulation procedures are proposed in that setting.

statistics & probability
Asymptotics for the sum-ruin probability of a bi-dimensional compound risk model with dependent numbers of claims

Zhangting Chen,Dongya Cheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s0269964824000093

2024-09-22

Probability in the Engineering and Informational Sciences

Abstract:This paper studies a bi-dimensional compound risk model with quasi-asymptotically independent and consistently varying-tailed random numbers of claims and establishes an asymptotic formula for the finite-time sum-ruin probability. Additionally, some results related to tail probabilities of random sums are presented, which are of significant interest in their own right. Some numerical studies are carried out to check the accuracy of the asymptotic formula.

engineering, industrial,operations research & management science,statistics & probability
Modelling Correlations in Portfolio Credit Risk

Bernd Rosenow,Rafael Weissbach,Frank Altrock

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cond-mat/0401329

2004-01-19

Abstract:The risk of a credit portfolio depends crucially on correlations between the probability of default (PD) in different economic sectors. Often, PD correlations have to be estimated from relatively short time series of default rates, and the resulting estimation error hinders the detection of a signal. We present statistical evidence that PD correlations are well described by a (one-)factorial model. We suggest a method of parameter estimation which avoids in a controlled way the underestimation of correlation risk. Empirical evidence is presented that, in the framework of the CreditRisk+ model with integrated correlations, this method leads to an increased reliability of the economic capital estimate.

Statistical Mechanics,Disordered Systems and Neural Networks,Statistical Finance
The Underlying Dynamics of Credit Correlations

Arthur M. Berd,Robert F. Engle,Artem Voronov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1001.0786

2010-01-06

Abstract:We propose a hybrid model of portfolio credit risk where the dynamics of the underlying latent variables is governed by a one factor GARCH process. The distinctive feature of such processes is that the long-term aggregate return distributions can substantially deviate from the asymptotic Gaussian limit for very long horizons. We introduce the notion of correlation surface as a convenient tool for comparing portfolio credit loss generating models and pricing synthetic CDO tranches. Analyzing alternative specifications of the underlying dynamics, we conclude that the asymmetric models with TARCH volatility specification are the preferred choice for generating significant and persistent credit correlation skews. The characteristic dependence of the correlation skew on term to maturity and portfolio hazard rate in these models has a significant impact on both relative value analysis and risk management of CDO tranches.

Pricing of Securities,Risk Management
Asymmetric Conditional Correlations in Stock Returns

Hui Jiang,Patrick W. Saart,Yingcun Xia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1214/16-aoas924

2016-01-01

Abstract:Modeling and estimation of correlation coefficients is a fundamental step in risk management, especially with the aftermath of the financial crisis in 2008, which challenged the traditional measuring of dependence in the financial market. Because of the serial dependence and small signal-to-noise ratio, patterns of the dependence in the data cannot be easily detected and modeled. This paper introduces a common factor analysis into the conditional correlation coefficients to extract the features of dependence. While statistical properties are thoroughly derived, extensive empirical analysis provides us with common patterns for the conditional correlation coefficients that give new insight into a number of important questions in financial data, especially the asymmetry of cross-correlations and the factors that drive the cross-correlations.
Entropy and credit risk in highly correlated markets

Sylvia Gottschalk

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1604.07042

2016-04-24

Risk Management

Abstract:We compare two models of corporate default by calculating the Jeffreys-Kullback-Leibler divergence between their predicted default probabilities when asset correlations are either high or low. Our main results show that the divergence between the two models increases in highly correlated, volatile, and large markets, but that it is closer to zero in small markets, when asset correlations are low and firms are highly leveraged. These findings suggest that during periods of financial instability the single-and multi-factor models of corporate default will generate increasingly inconsistent predictions.
Asymptotic bayes optimality under sparsity for equicorrelated multivariate normal test statistics

Rahul Roy,Subir Kumar Bhandari

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2208.11924

2022-08-25

Methodology

Abstract:Here we address dependence among the test statistics in connection with asymptotically Bayes' optimal tests in presence of sparse alternatives. Extending the setup in Bogdan et.al. (2011) we consider an equicorrelated ( with equal correlation $\rho$ ) multivariate normal assumption on the joint distribution of the test statistics, while conditioned on the mean vector $\boldsymbol{\mu}$. Rest of the set up is identical to Bogdan et.al. (2011) with a slight modification in the asymptotic framework. We exploit an well known result on equicorrelated multivariate normal variables with equal marginal variances to decompose the test statistics into independent random variables. We then identify a set of independent yet unobservable gaussian random variables sufficient for the multiple testing problem and chalk out the necessary and sufficient conditions for single cutoff tests to be ABOS based on those dummy variables following Bogdan et.al. (2011). Further we replaced the dummy variables with deviations of the statistics from their arithmetic means which were easily calculable from the observations due to the decomposition used earlier. Additional assumptions are then derived so that the necessary and sufficient conditions for single cutoff tests to be ABOS using the independent dummy variables plays the same role with the replacement variable as well (with a deviation of order $o(1)$). Next with the same additional assumption, necessary and sufficient conditions for single cutoff tests to control the Bayesian FDRs are derived and as a consequence under various sparsity assumptions we proved that the classical Bonferroni and Benjamini-Hochberg methods of multiple testing are ABOS if the same conditions are satisfied.
A factor-model approach for correlation scenarios and correlation stress-testing

Natalie Packham,Fabian Woebbeking

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbankfin.2019.01.020

2019-01-29

Abstract:In 2012, JPMorgan accumulated a USD~6.2 billion loss on a credit derivatives portfolio, the so-called `London Whale', partly as a consequence of de-correlations of non-perfectly correlated positions that were supposed to hedge each other. Motivated by this case, we devise a factor model for correlations that allows for scenario-based stress testing of correlations. We derive a number of analytical results related to a portfolio of homogeneous assets. Using the concept of Mahalanobis distance, we show how to identify adverse scenarios of correlation risk. In addition, we demonstrate how correlation and volatility stress tests can be combined. As an example, we apply the factor-model approach to the "London Whale" portfolio and determine the value-at-risk impact from correlation changes. Since our findings are particularly relevant for large portfolios, where even small correlation changes can have a large impact, a further application would be to stress test portfolios of central counterparties, which are of systemically relevant size.

Risk Management,Portfolio Management
ASYMPTOTICS FOR A DISCRETE-TIME RISK MODEL WITH THE EMPHASIS ON FINANCIAL RISK

Enkelejd Hashorva,Jinzhu Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s026996481400014x

2014-06-27

Probability in the Engineering and Informational Sciences

Abstract:This paper focuses on a discrete-time risk model in which both insurance risk and financial risk are taken into account. We study the asymptotic behavior of the ruin probability and the tail probability of the aggregate risk amount. Precise asymptotic formulas are derived under weak moment conditions of involved risks. The main novelty of our results lies in the quantification of the impact of the financial risk.

engineering, industrial,operations research & management science,statistics & probability
Impact of correlation between interest rates and mortality rates on the valuation of various life insurance products

Griselda Deelstra,Pierre Devolder,Benjamin Roelants du Vivier

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/asb.2024.20

2024-09-11

Astin Bulletin

Abstract:In this paper, we question the traditional independence assumption between mortality risk and financial risk and model the correlation between these two risks, estimating its impact on the price of different life insurance products. The interest rate and the mortality intensity are modelled as two correlated Hull and White models in an affine set-up. We introduce two building blocks, namely the zero-coupon survival bond and the mortality density, calculate them in closed form and perform an investigation about their dependence on the correlation between mortality and financial risk, both with theoretical results and numerical analysis. We study the impact of correlation also for more structured insurance products, such as pure endowment, annuity, term insurance, whole life insurance and mixed endowment. We show that in some cases, the inclusion of correlation can lead to a severe underestimation or overestimation of the best estimate. Finally, we illustrate that the results obtained using a traditional affine diffusive set-up can be generalised to affine jump diffusion by computing the price of the zero-coupon survival bond in the presence of jumps.

economics,social sciences, mathematical methods,mathematics, interdisciplinary applications,statistics & probability
Portfolio credit risk with Archimedean copulas: asymptotic analysis and efficient simulation

Hengxin Cui,Ken Seng Tan,Fan Yang

2024-11-11

Abstract:In this paper, we study large losses arising from defaults of a credit portfolio. We assume that the portfolio dependence structure is modelled by the Archimedean copula family as opposed to the widely used Gaussian copula. The resulting model is new, and it has the capability of capturing extremal dependence among obligors. We first derive sharp asymptotics for the tail probability of portfolio losses and the expected shortfall. Then we demonstrate how to utilize these asymptotic results to produce two variance reduction algorithms that significantly enhance the classical Monte Carlo methods. Moreover, we show that the estimator based on the proposed two-step importance sampling method is logarithmically efficient while the estimator based on the conditional Monte Carlo method has bounded relative error as the number of obligors tends to infinity. Extensive simulation studies are conducted to highlight the efficiency of our proposed algorithms for estimating portfolio credit risk. In particular, the variance reduction achieved by the proposed conditional Monte Carlo method, relative to the crude Monte Carlo method, is in the order of millions.

Risk Management
Asymptotics for ruin probabilities in a bidimensional discrete-time risk model with dependent and consistently varying tailed net losses

Hongxia Wang,Qi Su,Yang Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17442508.2024.2315272

2024-03-14

Stochastics

Abstract:Consider an insurer who operates two lines of businesses and hence receives two types of insurance net losses. In the bidimensional discrete-time risk model with a constant interest rate, the net loss vectors from the two business lines form a sequence of independent and identically distributed real-valued random vectors. We propose a bidimensional extended regularly varying structure in terms of survival copulas to model the dependence between the two components of each net loss vector, which includes not only asymptotic independence but also asymptotic dependence . Under the framework of consistent variation, we obtain several (uniformly) asymptotic formulas for various ruin probabilities. In particular, the investigation of random-time ruin probabilities unifies and extends the results on both finite-time and infinite-time ruin probabilities. Some numerical studies are also performed to check the accuracy of our obtained asymptotic results.

mathematics, applied,statistics & probability
Asymptotic locations of bounded and unbounded eigenvalues of sample correlation matrices of certain factor models -- application to a components retention rule

Yohji Akama,Peng Tian

2024-07-10

Abstract:Let the dimension $N$ of data and the sample size $T$ tend to $\infty$ with $N/T \to c > 0$. The spectral properties of a sample correlation matrix $\mathbf{C}$ and a sample covariance matrix $\mathbf{S}$ are asymptotically equal whenever the population correlation matrix $\mathbf{R}$ is bounded (El Karoui 2009). We demonstrate this also for general linear models for unbounded $\mathbf{R}$, by examining the behavior of the singular values of multiplicatively perturbed matrices. By this, we establish: Given a factor model of an idiosyncratic noise variance $\sigma^2$ and a rank-$r$ factor loading matrix $\mathbf{L}$ which rows all have common Euclidean norm $L$. Then, the $k$th largest eigenvalues $\lambda_k$ $(1\le k\le N)$ of $\mathbf{C}$ satisfy almost surely: (1) $\lambda_r$ diverges, (2) $\lambda_k/s_k^2\to1/(L^2 + \sigma^2)$ $(1 \le k \le r)$ for the $k$th largest singular value $s_k$ of $\mathbf{L}$, and (3) $\lambda_{r + 1}\to(1-\rho)(1+\sqrt{c})^2$ for $\rho := L^2/(L^2 + \sigma^2)$. Whenever $s_r$ is much larger than $\sqrt{\log N}$, then broken-stick rule (Frontier 1976, Jackson 1993), which estimates $\mathrm{rank}\, \mathbf{L}$ by a random partition (Holst 1980) of $[0,\,1]$, tends to $r$ (a.s.). We also provide a natural factor model where the rule tends to "essential rank" of $\mathbf{L}$ (a.s.) which is smaller than $\mathrm{rank}\, \mathbf{L}$.

Statistics Theory
Interaction uncertainty in financial networks

Andrea Auconi

2023-11-30

Abstract:A minimal stochastic dynamical model of the interbank network is introduced, with linear interactions mediated by an integral of recent variations. Defining stress as the variance over the banks' states, the interaction correction to the stress expectation is derived and studied on the short-medium timescale in an expansion. It is shown that, while different interaction matrices can amplify or absorb fluctuations, on average interactions increase the stress expectation. More in general, this analytical framework enables to estimate the impact of uncertainty about financial exposures, and to draw conclusions about the importance of disclosure.

Mathematical Finance
Credit risk: Taking fluctuating asset correlations into account

Thilo A. Schmitt,Rudi Schäfer,Thomas Guhr

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1601.03015

2016-01-13

Abstract:In structural credit risk models, default events and the ensuing losses are both derived from the asset values at maturity. Hence it is of utmost importance to choose a distribution for these asset values which is in accordance with empirical data. At the same time, it is desirable to still preserve some analytical tractability. We achieve both goals by putting forward an ensemble approach for the asset correlations. Consistently with the data, we view them as fluctuating quantities, for which we may choose the average correlation as homogeneous. Thereby we can reduce the number of parameters to two, the average correlation between assets and the strength of the fluctuations around this average value. Yet, the resulting asset value distribution describes the empirical data well. This allows us to derive the distribution of credit portfolio losses. With Monte-Carlo simulations for the Value at Risk and Expected Tail Loss we validate the assumptions of our approach and demonstrate the necessity of taking fluctuating correlations into account.

Risk Management
Inference for Conditional Value-at-risk of a Predictive Regression

Yi He,Yanxi Hou,Liang Peng,Haipeng Shen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1214/19-aos1937

2018-01-01

Abstract:Conditional value-at-risk is a popular risk measure in risk management. We study the inference problem of conditional value-at-risk under a linear predictive regression model. We derive the asymptotic distribution of the least squares estimator for the conditional value-at-risk. Our results relax the model assumptions made in (Oper. Res. 60 (2012) 739-756) and correct their mistake in the asymptotic variance expression. We show that the asymptotic variance depends on the quantile density function of the unobserved error and whether the model has a predictor with infinite variance, which makes it challenging to actually quantify the uncertainty of the conditional risk measure. To make the inference feasible, we then propose a smooth empirical likelihood based method for constructing a confidence interval for the conditional value-at-risk based on either independent errors or GARCH errors. Our approach not only bypasses the challenge of directly estimating the asymptotic variance but also does not need to know whether there exists an infinite variance predictor in the predictive model. Furthermore, we apply the same idea to the quantile regression method, which allows infinite variance predictors and generalizes the parameter estimation in (Econometric Theory 22 (2006) 173-205) to conditional value-at-risk in the Supplementary Material. We demonstrate the finite sample performance of the derived confidence intervals through numerical studies before applying them to real data.
A Note on the Asymptotic Covariance in Fama‐MacBeth Regression

R Jagannathan,ZY Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/0022-1082.334095

1998-01-01

Abstract:IN THEOREM 2 (page 44, Appendix B) of "The conditional CAPM and the crosssection of expected returns," which appeared in the March 1996 issue of The Journal of Finance (pages 3-53), we derive the sampling distribution of the parameters estimated using the cross-sectional regression approach. Unfortunately, there is an error in that derivation. We correct the error -in this note. In our derivations we assume that the residual from the regression of an asset return on one factor (say, factor yi) is orthogonal to the factor yj as well as to any other factor (say, factor Yk with k # j). In particular, using the notations in the paper, we assume that
The subjective discount factor and the coefficient of relative risk aversion under time-additive isoelastic expected utility model

Dominique Pepin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1604.03337

2016-06-29

Abstract:By analysing the restrictions that ensure the existence of capital market equilibrium, we show that the coefficient of relative risk aversion and the subjective discount factor cannot be high simultaneously as they are supposed to be to make the standard asset pricing consistent with financial stylised facts.

Computational Finance,General Finance

Relaxing the assumption of conditional independence in an asymptotic single risk factor model

Credit Risk Meets Random Matrices: Coping with Non-Stationary Asset Correlations

Asymptotics for A Class of Dependent Random Variables

Conditional Tail Expectation Decomposition and Conditional Mean Risk Sharing for Dependent and Conditionally Independent Losses

Asymptotics for the sum-ruin probability of a bi-dimensional compound risk model with dependent numbers of claims

Modelling Correlations in Portfolio Credit Risk

The Underlying Dynamics of Credit Correlations

Asymmetric Conditional Correlations in Stock Returns

Entropy and credit risk in highly correlated markets

Asymptotic bayes optimality under sparsity for equicorrelated multivariate normal test statistics

A factor-model approach for correlation scenarios and correlation stress-testing

ASYMPTOTICS FOR A DISCRETE-TIME RISK MODEL WITH THE EMPHASIS ON FINANCIAL RISK

Impact of correlation between interest rates and mortality rates on the valuation of various life insurance products

Portfolio credit risk with Archimedean copulas: asymptotic analysis and efficient simulation

Asymptotics for ruin probabilities in a bidimensional discrete-time risk model with dependent and consistently varying tailed net losses

Asymptotic locations of bounded and unbounded eigenvalues of sample correlation matrices of certain factor models -- application to a components retention rule

Interaction uncertainty in financial networks

Credit risk: Taking fluctuating asset correlations into account

Inference for Conditional Value-at-risk of a Predictive Regression

A Note on the Asymptotic Covariance in Fama‐MacBeth Regression

The subjective discount factor and the coefficient of relative risk aversion under time-additive isoelastic expected utility model