Residence Layout Examined and Optimized by Sunshine: A Comparative Study between Barcelona and Northern Chinese Cities

Yunan Zhang,Wenxuan Chen,Zhiqi Yang,Yingjie Liu,Zhipeng Tang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16052174

IF: 3.9

2024-03-07

Sustainability

Abstract:This article compares the differences and similarities in residential layout and scale between Barcelona, Spain and Tianjin, a northern Chinese city, using Ladybug. We obtained sunshine simulation results under the same conditions in terms of building façades, lower floors, streets, courtyards and other aspects in two cities. Based on this, this paper draws on the advantages and disadvantages of the dense street network in the Eixample district of Barcelona and provides suggestions for the residential layout of cities in northern China. The aim of this study is to improve the residential layout of cities in northern China, while meeting the requirements of plot ratio and taking into account the favorable sunshine conditions in Barcelona. A key aspect of this study is the emphasis on the importance of capturing sunlight in future urban designs. Specifically, it highlights the potential for installing solar panels in areas with effective sunlight exposure of more than three hours daily such as streets, façades, rooftops and courtyards to harness solar energy and conserve resources. This paper compares the similarities and differences between the residence layout and scale in Barcelona, Spain and northern Chinese cities, regarding the overall façade of the building, the lower part of the building, and the streets and courtyards of the two coastal cities by using Ladybug to obtain sunshine simulation results under the same conditions and drawing lessons from the small block, dense street network of Barcelona's Eixample district so as to put forward suggestions for the residential layout of northern Chinese cities. Research has found that the layout form of Barcelona housing is similar to the plot ratio of point and panel residential buildings in northern Chinese cities and has better hygiene conditions such as sunshine.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores how urban residential layouts can be optimized through design to improve sunlight conditions, thereby promoting sustainable urban development. Specifically, the study conducts a comparative analysis of residential layouts in Barcelona, Spain, and Tianjin, China, and uses the Ladybug tool for sunlight simulation.

The core objective of the paper is to improve the residential layouts in northern Chinese cities, ensuring that while meeting the floor area ratio requirements, they can also draw on the advantages of Barcelona, particularly its excellent sunlight conditions. The study emphasizes the importance of capturing sunlight and proposes the possibility of installing solar panels in areas with more than 3 hours of sunlight (such as streets, building facades, roofs, and courtyards) to harness solar energy and save resources.

The main contributions of the study include:
1. Establishing a simulation model to analyze the sunlight conditions of residential layouts in Barcelona and Tianjin, providing a comparative perspective on the impact of different urban planning on sunlight exposure.
2. Using Grasshopper to build a residential area model and conducting experimental setups based on the common residential area depth scale in China, utilizing Ladybug for sunlight analysis.
3. Conducting sunlight simulation tests on two common housing forms in the planning of residential areas in northern Chinese cities—point-type housing and slab-type housing.
4. Highlighting the advantages of small blocks and dense road networks (such as the Eixample district in Barcelona) in optimizing sunlight exposure and proposing optimized residential layout schemes for northern Chinese cities.

In summary, this study aims to explore how to enhance the sustainability of urban living environments, particularly in terms of sunlight conditions, through comparative analysis and simulation experiments by improving residential layouts.