Abstract:The prevalence of childhood obesity is increasing globally (1) . While BMI is commonly used to define obesity, it is unable to differentiate between fat and muscle mass, leading to calls to measure body composition specifically (2) . While several tools are available to assess body composition in infancy, it is unclear if they are directly comparable. Among a subset of healthy infants born to mothers participating in a randomised controlled trial of a preconception and antenatal nutritional supplement (3) , measurements were made at ages 6 weeks (n = 58) and 6 months (n = 70) using air displacement plethysmography (ADP), whole-body dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA), and bioelectrical impedance spectroscopy (BIS). Estimates of percentage fat mass (%FM) were compared using Cohen's kappa statistic (κ) and Bland-Altman analysis (4,5) . There was none to weak agreement when comparing tertiles of %FM (κ = 0.15–0.59). When comparing absolute values, the bias (i.e., mean difference) was smallest when comparing BIS to ADP at 6 weeks (+1.7%). A similar bias was observed at 6 months when comparing DXA to ADP (+1.8%). However, when comparing BIA to DXA at both ages, biases were much larger (+7.6% and +4.7% at 6 weeks and 6 months, respectively). Furthermore, there was wide interindividual variance (limits of agreement [LOA] i.e., ± 1.96 SD) for each comparison. At 6 weeks, LOA ranged from ± 4.8 to ± 6.5% for BIA vs. DXA and BIA vs. ADP, respectively. At 6 months, LOA were even wider, ranging from ± 7.3 to ± 8.1% (DXA vs. ADP and BIA vs. DXA, respectively). Proportional biases were apparent when comparing BIS to the other tools at both ages, with BIS generally overestimating %FM more among infants with low adiposity. In addition to differences according to tool type, within-tool factors impacted body composition estimation. For ADP measurements, the choice of FFM density reference (Fomon vs. Butte) had minimal impact; however, choice of DXA software version (GE Lunar enCORE basic vs. enhanced) and BIS analysis approach (empirical equation vs. mixture theory prediction) led to very different estimates of body composition. In conclusion, when comparing body composition assessment tools in infancy, there was limited agreement between three commonly used tools. Therefore, researchers and clinicians must be cautious when conducting longitudinal analyses or when comparing findings across studies, as estimates are not comparable across tools.

Infant growth and body composition from birth to 24 months: are infants developing the same?

Anthropometric prediction models of body composition in 3 to 24month old infants: a multicenter international study

The association of intrauterine and postnatal growth patterns and nutritional status with toddler body composition

Body composition in healthy singleton-term infants using three-dimensional photonic scanning method: A multicentre cross-sectional study

Body composition assessment in 6-month-old infants: A comparison of two- and three-compartment models using data from the Baby-bod study

Infant body composition: A comprehensive overview of assessment techniques, nutrition factors, and health outcomes

Body composition from birth to 6 months in term small for gestational age Indian infants: Effect of catch-up growth

Longitudinal body mass index trajectories at preschool age: children with rapid growth have differential composition of the gut microbiota in the first year of life

Comparison of body composition assessment tools in infancy

Body Composition Measurements from Birth through 5 Years: Challenges, Gaps, and Existing & Emerging Technologies—A National Institutes of Health workshop

Associations of early childhood body mass index trajectories with body composition and cardiometabolic markers at age 10 years: the Ethiopian infant anthropometry and body composition (iABC) birth cohort study

990 Ethnic Differences in Neonatal Body Composition and the Impact of Parental Size. a Population-Based Cohort Study

Association of infant feeding patterns with body fat mass and obesity in the first 2 years of life: a longitudinal twin birth cohort study

Body mass index growth trajectories and body composition influencing factors: An ambidirectional preschooler cohort

Low length/weight growth trajectories of early-term infants during the first year: evidence from a longitudinal study in China

Trait-specific Tracking and Determinants of Body Composition: a 7-Year Follow-Up Study of Pubertal Growth in Girls

Growth and proportionality in early childhood. III. Differences between babies of low birthweight in well-nourished and malnourished populations

Body Composition in Early Pubescent Children with Obesity: Effects Following 1 Year of Non-Intervention

Body composition during the first 4 months in infants affected by neonatal abstinence syndrome: a pilot study

Longitudinal characterization of determinants associated with obesogenic growth patterns in early childhood

Associations of Early Nutrition with Growth and Body Composition in Very Preterm Infants: a Prospective Cohort Study