Abstract:Mechanisms governing the migratory decisions of birds have long fascinated ecologists and sparked considerable debate. Identifying factors responsible for variation in migration distance, also known as differential migration, has been a popular approach to understanding the mechanisms underlying migratory behaviour more generally. However, research progress has been slowed by the continued testing of overlapping, non‐mechanistic, and circular predictions among a small set of historically entrenched hypotheses. We highlight the body size hypothesis and suggest that the predictions commonly tested have impeded progress because body size relationships with migration distance are predictions made by several distinct hypotheses with contrasting mechanisms. The cost of migration itself has not been adequately accounted for in most hypotheses, and we propose two flight efficiency hypotheses with time‐ and energy‐minimizing mechanisms that allow individuals to mitigate the risks inherent to longer migrations. We also advance two conceptual versions of the social dominance hypothesis based on two distinct underlying mechanisms related to distance minimization and food maximization that will help clarify the role of competition in driving migratory decisions. Overall, we describe and refine 12 mechanistic hypotheses proposed to explain differential migration (along with several other special‐case hypotheses), seven of which have underlying mechanisms related to food limitation as past research has identified this to be an important driver of differential migration. We also thoroughly reviewed 145 publications to assess the amount of support for 10 critical assumptions underlying alternative hypotheses for differential migration in birds. Our review reveals that surprisingly few studies explicitly evaluate assumptions within a differential migration context. Generating and testing strong predictions and critical assumptions underlying mechanisms of alternative hypotheses will improve our ability to differentiate among these explanations of differential migration. Additionally, future intraspecific progress will be greatest if investigators continue to focus on mechanisms underlying variation in migration distance within rather than among demographic classes, as previous research has found differing mechanisms to be responsible for differential migration among demographic classes. Interspecifically, a thorough comparative analysis that seeks to explain variation in migration distance among species would broaden both our understanding of the mechanisms regulating current differential migration patterns and those that led to the evolution of migration more generally. Collectively, we provide a framework that, together with advances in animal‐borne tracking and other technology, can be used to advance our understanding of the causes of differential migration distance, and migratory decisions more generally.

The regulatory basis of migratory behaviour in birds: different paths to similar outcomes

The genetics and epigenetics of animal migration and orientation: birds, butterflies and beyond

The genetics of bird migration

Animal tracking meets migration genomics: transcriptomic analysis of a partially migratory bird species

Gene regulation and speciation in a migratory divide between songbirds

Genetic Control of Avian Migration: Insights from Studies in Latitudinal Passerine Migrants

Understanding variation in migratory movements: A mechanistic approach

Mapping seasonal migration in a songbird hybrid zone -- heritability, genetic correlations, and genomic patterns linked to speciation.

The underlying causes of differential migration: assumptions, hypotheses, and predictions

Avian migration clocks in a changing world

Genomic architecture of migration timing in a long-distance migratory songbird

Migration direction in a songbird explained by two loci

Brain gene expression reveals pathways underlying nocturnal migratory restlessness

Bird migration research today: some achievements and new challenges

Genome‐wide transcriptomic changes reveal the genetic pathways involved in insect migration

Genomic correlates for migratory direction in a free-ranging cervid

Clock-linked genes underlie seasonal migratory timing in a diurnal raptor

Genomewide Transcriptional Signatures of Migratory Flight Activity in a Globally Invasive Insect Pest

Gene expression responses to environmental cues shed light on components of the migratory syndrome in butterflies

Transcriptome signatures in the brain of a migratory songbird

Genetic determination of migration strategies in large soaring birds: evidence from hybrid eagles