Abstract:Background: Facial activity during pain is composed of varying combinations of a few elementary facial responses (so-called Action Units). A previous study of experimental pain showed that these varying combinations can be clustered into distinct facial activity patterns of pain. In the present study, we examined whether comparable facial activity patterns can also be identified among people suffering from clinical pain; namely, shoulder pain. Methods: Facial expressions of patients suffering from shoulder pain (N = 126) were recorded while twice undergoing a battery of passive range-of-motion tests to their affected limbs (UNBC-McMaster Shoulder Pain Expression Archive Database), which elicited peaks of acute pain. Facial expressions were analysed using the Facial Action Coding System to extract facial Action Units (AUs). Hierarchical cluster analyses were used to look for characteristic combinations of these AUs. Results: Cluster analyses revealed four distinct activity patterns during painful movements. Each cluster was composed of different combinations of pain-indicative AUs, with one AU common to all clusters, namely, "narrowed eyes". Besides these four clusters, there was a "stoic" pattern, characterized by no discernible facial action. The identified clusters were relatively stable across time and comparable to the facial activity patterns found previously for experimental heat pain. Conclusions: These findings corroborate the hypothesis that facial expressions of acute pain are not uniform. Instead, they are composed of different combinations of pain-indicative facial responses, with one omnipresent response, namely, "narrowed eyes". Raising awareness about these inter-individually different "faces of pain" could improve the recognition and, thereby, its diagnostic training for professionals, like nurses and physicians. Significance: Similar to experimental pain, facial activity during evoked pain episodes in shoulder pain patients could be clustered into distinct faces of pain. Each cluster was composed of different combinations of single facial responses, namely: narrowed eyes, which is displayed either alone or in combination with opened mouth or wrinkled nose, or furrowed brows and closed eyes. These distinct faces of pain may inform the training of professionals and computers how to best recognize pain based on facial expressions.

Vicarious facilitation of facial responses to pain

Vicarious facilitation of facial responses to pain: Does the others' expression need to be painful?

Brain responses to the vicarious facilitation of pain by facial expressions of pain and fear

The effect of modification of expressive displays on vicarious emotional arousal

Dispositional empathy modulates vicarious effects of dynamic pain expressions on spinal nociception, facial responses and acute pain

Repeated exposure to vicarious pain alters electrocortical processing of pain expressions

Expressive suppression to pain in others reduces negative emotion but not vicarious pain in the observer

Facial expression of pain: an evolutionary account

High Levels of Vicarious Exposure Bias Pain Judgments

Enhanced Empathic Pain by Facial Feedback

A distributed brain response predicting the facial expression of acute nociceptive pain

Emotional mimicry signals pain empathy as evidenced by facial electromyography

Empathy for pain motivates actions without altruistic effects: evidence of motor dynamics and brain activity.

Pain modulates early sensory brain responses to task-irrelevant emotional faces

Beyond Physical Sensations: Investigating Empathy and Prosocial Behavior in Vicarious-Pain Responders

Facial representations of complex affective states combining pain and a negative emotion

Ongoing first-hand pain facilitates somatosensory resonance but inhibits affective sharing in empathy for pain

Faces of clinical pain: Inter-individual facial activity patterns in shoulder pain patients

Embodied Neural Responses to Others' Suffering.

Perspective taking is associated with specific facial responses during empathy for pain

The effect of observational learning on the development of central sensitization