Abstract:Context: Health simulation is a recognized educational method for teaching and validating surgical procedural skills. The latter requires the development of adapted assessment tools, reaching different validity criteria. The aim of this study was to validate a multimodal assessment tool for a complex skin suturing exercise, combining a manual knot, an intradermal linear suturing and a needle holder tied knot. Methodology: The suturing exercise was realized on a synthetic skin model by voluntary participants after having obtained their written consent, including 9 postgraduate medical students, 40 surgical residents of different levels of experience, and a group of 9 senior surgeons. The multimodal assessment tool (MAT) combined a checklist, a speed score and a global rating scale. Each exercise was scored by two evaluators. Medical students' performances were filmed anonymously so that they could be scored iteratively. Content validity was tested through a satisfaction questionnaire randomly completed by participants. Results: The MAT was considered relevant or very relevant by 98% of the participants, with a better appreciation for the checklist than for the global rating scale. Internal consistency was strong with a Cronbach α coefficient at 0.78, and a good correlation between the results of the checklist and the global rating scale (r=0.79, P<0.0001). The MAT showed continuous improvement in mean scores from 34.4±3.6 for novices to 47.4±2.5/50 points for experts, passing through three intermediate levels groups, and allowed for significant discrimination between groups. The MAT was reliable, with a coefficient of correlation set at 0.88 for intra-observer reliability, and 0.72 for inter-observer reliability. On sub score analysis, the global rating scale and the speed score better discriminated between groups than the checklist, the latter moreover showing slightly lower reliability than the global rating scale. Conclusion: Despite its banality in any surgeon's practice and the fact that it is taught from the 2nd cycle of medical studies, suturing and its technical components have rarely been the subject of publications dedicated to the validation of specific assessment tools. Hence, this work on the MAT and its sub scores made it possible to validate them on many validity and reliability criteria. They can therefore be proposed to surgical teachers for evaluating a complex suturing exercise, with a checklist that is easier to use even for novices and a global rating scale showing better discrimination capacity.

Validation of an Educational Tool for Skin Abscess Incision and Drainage by Delphi and Angoff Methods

Which Way Would You Slice It? Evaluation of 3 Educational Models for the Loop Drainage Technique

Development of a Novel, Reusable Task Trainer for Foreign Body Removal and Abscess Incision and Drainage

[Assessment tool's validation study for a simulation-based skin suturing skill]

Development and Validation of Instrument for Operative Competency Assessment in Selective Neck Dissection

Red Leg Dilemma: Development and Validation of Clinical Decision Tools for Non-Necrotizing Bacterial Dermohypodermitis, Necrotizing Fasciitis, and Eczematous Dermatitis

Novel indigenous low cost (NICA) model for hands on training of surgical interns in incision and drainage procedure for superficial skin abscess

Teaching and Assessing Bedside Procedures: A Standardized Cross-Disciplinary Framework for Graduate Medical Education

Development and preliminary validation of a new task-based objective procedure-specific assessment of inguinal hernia repair procedural safety

Development and validation of the incontinence associated dermatitis knowledge, attitude and practice questionnaire

Development and Preliminary Validation of a Central Venous Access Device‐Associated Skin Impairment Classification Tool Using Modified Delphi and Clinimetric Methods

Mobile persuasive technology for the teaching and learning in surgical safety: Content validation

Content of a wound care mobile application for newly graduated nurses: an e-Delphi study

Development and Evaluation of a Web-Based Dermatology Teaching Tool for Preclinical Medical Students

Development of the Diabetic Wound Assessment Learning Tool (DiWALT) and validity evidence

Direct observation of procedural skills evaluation of suturing skills in surgical interns: A comprehensive analysis

Development and evaluation of an e-learning package for teaching skin examination. Action research

The LOOP technique: a novel incision and drainage technique in the treatment of skin abscesses in a pediatric ED

The Development and Validation of an Objective Assessment Tool for Performing Ultrasound-Guided Transversus Abdominis Plane Blocks

Development and validation of inventory tool to evaluate social accountability principles in case scenarios used in problem-based curriculum (Social accountability inventory for PBL)

Instructional and didactic support tool for teaching-learning Post-Partum Haemorrhage care in simulated settings: Creation and validation