Abstract:By filling in missing values in datasets, imputation allows these datasets to be used with algorithms that cannot handle missing values by themselves. However, missing values may in principle contribute useful information that is lost through imputation. The missing-indicator approach can be used in combination with imputation to instead represent this information as a part of the dataset. There are several theoretical considerations why missing-indicators may or may not be beneficial, but there has not been any large-scale practical experiment on real-life datasets to test this question for machine learning predictions. We perform this experiment for three imputation strategies and a range of different classification algorithms, on the basis of twenty real-life datasets. In a follow-up experiment, we determine attribute-specific missingness thresholds for each classifier above which missing-indicators are more likely than not to increase classification performance. And in a second follow-up experiment, we evaluate numerical imputation of one-hot encoded categorical attributes. We reach the following conclusions. Firstly, missing-indicators generally increase classification performance. Secondly, with missing-indicators, nearest neighbour and iterative imputation do not lead to better performance than simple mean/mode imputation. Thirdly, for decision trees, pruning is necessary to prevent overfitting. Fourthly, the thresholds above which missing-indicators are more likely than not to improve performance are lower for categorical attributes than for numerical attributes. Lastly, mean imputation of numerical attributes preserves some of the information from missing values. Consequently, when not using missing-indicators it can be advantageous to apply mean imputation to one-hot encoded categorical attributes instead of mode imputation.

Introduction to Bayesian Data Imputation

Missing Data Imputation: Focusing on Single Imputation.

On Missing Data Imputation for IRB Models

In-Database Data Imputation

Imputing Missing Data by Fully Conditional Models : Some Cautionary Examples and Guidelines

Imputation for categorical attributes with probabilistic reasoning

19 Incomplete Data in Epidemiology and Medical Statistics

A Benchmark for Data Imputation Methods

Robust Bayesian Classification with Incomplete Data

MCFlow: Monte Carlo Flow Models for Data Imputation

Statistical inference for the binomial Ar(1) model with missing data

Bayesian Recurrent Framework for Missing Data Imputation and Prediction with Clinical Time Series

Does imputation matter? Benchmark for predictive models

A Probabilistic Approach for Missing Data Imputation

BayOTIDE: Bayesian Online Multivariate Time series Imputation with functional decomposition

Imputation for prediction: beware of diminishing returns

Nonparametric imputation by data depth

Bayes and Multiple Imputation

What Is a Good Imputation Under MAR Missingness?

The `Why' behind including `Y' in your imputation model

No imputation without representation