Multi-source dynamic ensemble prediction of infectious disease and application in COVID-19 case

Jianping Huang,Yingjie Zhao,Wei Yan,Xinbo Lian,Rui Wang,Bin Chen,Siyu Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21037/jtd-23-234

2023-07-30

Journal of Thoracic Disease

Abstract:Keywords: Infectious diseases; coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19); multiwave; multi-source dynamic ensemble prediction (MDEP)

respiratory system

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Forecasting the Long-Term Trend of COVID-19 Epidemic Using a Dynamic Model

Jichao Sun,Xi Chen,Ziheng Zhang,Shengzhang Lai,Bo Zhao,Hualuo Liu,Shuojia Wang,Wenjing Huan,Ruihui Zhao,Man Tat Alexander Ng,Yefeng Zheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-020-78084-w

IF: 4.6

2020-01-01

Scientific Reports

Abstract:The current outbreak of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has recently been declared as a pandemic and spread over 200 countries and territories. Forecasting the long-term trend of the COVID-19 epidemic can help health authorities determine the transmission characteristics of the virus and take appropriate prevention and control strategies beforehand. Previous studies that solely applied traditional epidemic models or machine learning models were subject to underfitting or overfitting problems. We propose a new model named Dynamic-Susceptible-Exposed-Infective-Quarantined (D-SEIQ), by making appropriate modifications of the Susceptible-Exposed-Infective-Recovered (SEIR) model and integrating machine learning based parameter optimization under epidemiological rational constraints. We used the model to predict the long-term reported cumulative numbers of COVID-19 cases in China from January 27, 2020. We evaluated our model on officially reported confirmed cases from three different regions in China, and the results proved the effectiveness of our model in terms of simulating and predicting the trend of the COVID-19 outbreak. In China-Excluding-Hubei area within 7 days after the first public report, our model successfully and accurately predicted the long trend up to 40 days and the exact date of the outbreak peak. The predicted cumulative number (12,506) by March 10, 2020, was only 3·8% different from the actual number (13,005). The parameters obtained by our model proved the effectiveness of prevention and intervention strategies on epidemic control in China. The prediction results for five other countries suggested the external validity of our model. The integrated approach of epidemic and machine learning models could accurately forecast the long-term trend of the COVID-19 outbreak. The model parameters also provided insights into the analysis of COVID-19 transmission and the effectiveness of interventions in China.
Ensemble Prediction Method Based on Decomposition–Reconstitution–Integration for COVID-19 Outbreak Prediction

Wenhui Ke,Yimin Lu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/math12030493

IF: 2.4

2024-02-05

Mathematics

Abstract:Due to the non-linear and non-stationary nature of daily new 2019 coronavirus disease (COVID-19) case time series, existing prediction methods struggle to accurately forecast the number of daily new cases. To address this problem, a hybrid prediction framework is proposed in this study, which combines ensemble empirical mode decomposition (EEMD), fuzzy entropy (FE) reconstruction, and a CNN-LSTM-ATT hybrid network model. This new framework, named EEMD-FE-CNN-LSTM-ATT, is applied to predict the number of daily new COVID-19 cases. This study focuses on the daily new case dataset from the United States as the research subject to validate the feasibility of the proposed prediction framework. The results show that EEMD-FE-CNN-LSTM-ATT outperforms other baseline models in all evaluation metrics, demonstrating its efficacy in handling the non-linear and non-stationary epidemic time series. Furthermore, the generalizability of the proposed hybrid framework is validated on datasets from France and Russia. The proposed hybrid framework offers a new approach for predicting the COVID-19 pandemic, providing important technical support for future infectious disease forecasting.

mathematics
Predictive Modeling for Epidemic Outbreaks: A New Approach and COVID-19 Case Study

Jian Chen,Michael C. Fu,Wenhong Zhang,Junhua Zheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/s0217595920500281

2020-01-01

Abstract:Since the onset of the COVID-19 outbreak in Wuhan, China, numerous forecasting models have been proposed to project the trajectory of coronavirus infection cases. Most of these forecasts are based on epidemiology models that utilize deterministic differential equations and have resulted in widely varying predictions. We propose a new discrete-time Markov chain model that directly incorporates stochastic behavior and for which parameter estimation is straightforward from available data. Using such data from China’s Hubei province (for which Wuhan is the provincial capital city and which accounted for approximately 82% of the total reported COVID-19 cases in the entire country), the model is shown to be flexible, robust, and accurate. As a result, it has been adopted by the first Shanghai assistance medical team in Wuhan’s Jinyintan Hospital, which was the first designated hospital to take COVID-19 patients in the world. The forecast has been used for preparing medical staff, intensive care unit (ICU) beds, ventilators, and other critical care medical resources and for supporting real-time medical management decisions.
An autoregressive integrated moving average and long short-term memory (ARIM-LSTM) hybrid model for multi-source epidemic data prediction

Benfeng Wang,Yuqi Shen,Xiaoran Yan,Xiangjie Kong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj-cs.2046

2024-05-02

PeerJ Computer Science

Abstract:The COVID-19 pandemic has far-reaching impacts on the global economy and public health. To prevent the recurrence of pandemic outbreaks, the development of short-term prediction models is of paramount importance. We propose an ARIMA-LSTM (autoregressive integrated moving average and long short-term memory) model for predicting future cases and utilize multi-source data to enhance prediction performance. Firstly, we employ the ARIMA-LSTM model to forecast the developmental trends of multi-source data separately. Subsequently, we introduce a Bayes-Attention mechanism to integrate the prediction outcomes from auxiliary data sources into the case data. Finally, experiments are conducted based on real datasets. The results demonstrate a close correlation between predicted and actual case numbers, with superior prediction performance of this model compared to baseline and other state-of-the-art methods.

computer science, information systems, artificial intelligence, theory & methods
Deep Dynamic Epidemiological Modelling for COVID-19 Forecasting in Multi-level Districts

Ruhan Liu,Jiajia Li,Yang Wen,Huating Li,Ping Zhang,Bin Sheng,David Dagan Feng

2023-06-21

Abstract:Objective: COVID-19 has spread worldwide and made a huge influence across the world. Modeling the infectious spread situation of COVID-19 is essential to understand the current condition and to formulate intervention measurements. Epidemiological equations based on the SEIR model simulate disease development. The traditional parameter estimation method to solve SEIR equations could not precisely fit real-world data due to different situations, such as social distancing policies and intervention strategies. Additionally, learning-based models achieve outstanding fitting performance, but cannot visualize mechanisms. Methods: Thus, we propose a deep dynamic epidemiological (DDE) method that combines epidemiological equations and deep-learning advantages to obtain high accuracy and visualization. The DDE contains deep networks to fit the effect function to simulate the ever-changing situations based on the neural ODE method in solving variants' equations, ensuring the fitting performance of multi-level areas. Results: We introduce four SEIR variants to fit different situations in different countries and regions. We compare our DDE method with traditional parameter estimation methods (Nelder-Mead, BFGS, Powell, Truncated Newton Conjugate-Gradient, Neural ODE) in fitting the real-world data in the cases of countries (the USA, Columbia, South Africa) and regions (Wuhan in China, Piedmont in Italy). Our DDE method achieves the best Mean Square Error and Pearson coefficient in all five areas. Further, compared with the state-of-art learning-based approaches, the DDE outperforms all techniques, including LSTM, RNN, GRU, Random Forest, Extremely Random Trees, and Decision Tree. Conclusion: DDE presents outstanding predictive ability and visualized display of the changes in infection rates in different regions and countries.

Machine Learning,Artificial Intelligence,Populations and Evolution
DDE: Deep Dynamic Epidemiological Modeling for Infectious Illness Development Forecasting in Multi-level Geographic Entities

Ruhan Liu,Jiajia Li,Yang Wen,Huating Li,Ping Zhang,Bin Sheng,David Dagan Feng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s41666-024-00167-4

2024-05-28

Abstract:Understanding and addressing the dynamics of infectious diseases, such as coronavirus disease 2019, are essential for effectively managing the current situation and developing intervention strategies. Epidemiologists commonly use mathematical models, known as epidemiological equations (EE), to simulate disease spread. However, accurately estimating the parameters of these models can be challenging due to factors like variations in social distancing policies and intervention strategies. In this study, we propose a novel method called deep dynamic epidemiological modeling (DDE) to address these challenges. The DDE method combines the strengths of EE with the capabilities of deep neural networks to improve the accuracy of fitting real-world data. In DDE, we apply neural ordinary differential equations to solve variant-specific equations, ensuring a more precise fit for disease progression in different geographic regions. In the experiment, we tested the performance of the DDE method and other state-of-the-art methods using real-world data from five diverse geographic entities: the USA, Colombia, South Africa, Wuhan in China, and Piedmont in Italy. Compared to the state-of-the-art method, DDE significantly improved accuracy, with an average fitting Pearson coefficient exceeding 0.97 across the five geographic entities. In summary, the DDE method enhances the accuracy of parameter fitting in epidemiological models and provides a foundation for constructing simpler models adaptable to different geographic areas.
Advanced forecasting of COVID-19 epidemic: Leveraging ensemble models, advanced optimization, and decomposition techniques

Yingyu Yin,Iman Ahmadianfar,Faten Khalid Karim,Hela Elmannai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compbiomed.2024.108442

Abstract:In the global effort to address the outbreak of the new coronavirus pneumonia (COVID-19) pandemic, accurate forecasting of epidemic patterns has become crucial for implementing successful interventions aimed at preventing and controlling the spread of the disease. The correct prediction of the course of COVID-19 outbreaks is a complex and challenging task, mainly because of the significant volatility in the data series related to COVID-19. Previous studies have been limited by the exclusive use of individual forecasting techniques in epidemic modeling, disregarding the integration of diverse prediction procedures. The lack of attention to detail in this situation can yield worse-than-ideal results. Consequently, this study introduces a novel ensemble framework that integrates three machine learning methods (kernel ridge regression (KRidge), Deep random vector functional link (dRVFL), and ridge regression) within a linear relationship (L-KRidge-dRVFL-Ridge). The optimization of this framework is accomplished through a distinctive approach, specifically adaptive differential evolution and particle swarm optimization (A-DEPSO). Moreover, an effective decomposition method, known as time-varying filter empirical mode decomposition (TVF-EMD), is employed to decompose the input variables. A feature selection technique, specifically using the light gradient boosting machine (LGBM), is also implemented to extract the most influential input variables. The daily datasets of COVID-19 collected from two countries, namely Italy and Poland, were used as the experimental examples. Additionally, all models are implemented to forecast COVID-19 at two-time horizons: 10- and 14-day ahead (t+10 and t+14). According to the results, the proposed model can yield higher correlation coefficient (R) for both case studies: Italy (t+10 = 0.965, t+14 = 0.961) and Poland (t+10 = 0.952, t+14 = 0.940) than the other models. The experimental results demonstrate that the model suggested in this paper has outstanding results in various kinds of complex epidemic prediction situations. The proposed ensemble model demonstrates exceptional accuracy and resilience, outperforming all similar models in terms of efficacy.
Leveraging Human Mobility Data for Efficient Parameter Estimation in Epidemic Models of COVID-19

Cunqi Shao,Mincheng Wu,Shibo He,Zhiguo Shi,Chao Li,Xinjiang Ye,Jiming Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/tits.2022.3223229

IF: 8.5

2024-01-01

IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems

Abstract:Effectively predicting the evolution of COVID-19 is of great significance to contain the pandemic. Extensive previous studies proposed a great number of SIR variants, which are efficient to capture the transmission characteristics of COVID-19. However, the parameter estimation methods in previous studies are based on data from epidemiological investigations, which inevitably have caused a large delay. The popularity of digital trajectory data world-wide makes it possible to understand epidemic spreading from human mobility perspective. The major advantage of digital trajectory data lies in that the co-location level of a population is reflected at every moment, making it possible to forecast the evolution in advance. We showed that the mobility data contributed by mobile phone users could be exploited to estimate the contact probability between individuals, thus revealing the dynamic transmission of COVID-19. Specifically, we developed an estimation method to obtain human co-location levels and quantified the variations of human mobility during the epidemic. Then, we extended the infection rate with a real-time co-location level to further forecast the transmission of an epidemic, predicting the epidemic size much more accurately than conventional methods. Finally, the proposed method was applied to evaluate the quantitative effect of different non-pharmacological interventions by predicting the epidemic situations with various mobility characteristics. The empirical results and simulations corroborated our theoretical analysis, providing effective guidance to contain the pandemic.
A dynamic ensemble model for short-term forecasting in pandemic situations

Jonas Botz,Diego Valderrama,Jannis Guski,Holger Fröhlich

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.03.08.24303963

2024-03-12

Abstract:During the COVID-19 pandemic, many hospitals reached their capacity limits and could no longer guarantee treatment of all patients. At the same time, governments endeavored to take sensible measures to stop the spread of the virus while at the same time trying to keep the economy afloat. Many models extrapolating confirmed cases and hospitalization rate over short periods of time have been proposed, including several ones coming from the field of machine learning. However, the highly dynamic nature of the pandemic with rapidly introduced interventions and new circulating variants imposed non-trivial challenges for the generalizability of such models. In the context of this paper, we propose the use of ensemble models, which are allowed to change in their composition or weighting of base models over time and can thus adapt to highly dynamic pandemic or epidemic situations. In that regard, we also explored the use of secondary metadata - Google searches - to inform the ensemble model. We tested our approach using surveillance data from COVID-19, Influenza, and hospital syndromic surveillance of severe acute respiratory infections (SARI). In general, we found ensembles to be more robust than the individual models. Altogether we see our work as a contribution to enhance the preparedness for future pandemic situations.

Public and Global Health
DDE: Deep Dynamic Epidemiological Modelling for Infectious Illness Development Forecasting in Multi-level Geographic Entities

Ruhan Liu,Jiajia Li,Yang Wen,Huating Li,Ping Zhang,Bin Sheng,David Dagan Feng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-3407592/v1

2023-01-01

Abstract:Abstract Understanding and effectively addressing the dynamics of infectious diseases, including global diseases like COVID-19, is crucial for managing the current situation and developing effective intervention strategies. Epidemiologists commonly use epidemiological equations (EE) to model disease progression. Nevertheless, the traditional approach to parameter estimation in EE frequently faces challenges in accurately fitting real-world data, primarily due to factors like the different implementation of social distancing policies and intervention strategies. However, developing high-quality but complex EE models can be time-intensive for epidemiologists. Hence, we introduce a novel method known as the deep dynamic epidemiological (DDE) approach, which integrates the strengths of EE with the capabilities of deep neural networks (DNN) to enhance accuracy. The DDE method incorporates DNNs to model dynamic effects and adapt to evolving situations. It employs the neural ordinary differential equation (ODE) method to solve variant-specific equations, ensuring a precise fit to disease progression in diverse geographic regions. In this study, we introduce four variants of EE customized to address specific scenarios in different countries and regions. We assess the performance of our DDE method using real-world data from five diverse geographic entities (countries: the USA, Colombia, and South Africa; regions: Wuhan in China and Piedmont in Italy). We show that the DDE method outperforms alternative approaches, achieving the highest predictive accuracy in modeling disease progression across all five geographic entities. This paves the way for constructing a simplified EE model for various geographic levels.
Embracing the power of ensemble forecasting: A novel hybrid approach for advanced predictive modeling

Isha Malhotra,Nidhi Goel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ipm.2024.103954

IF: 7.466

2024-11-11

Information Processing & Management

Abstract:Amidst the persistent threat of epidemics, effectively managing their complexities requires accurate forecasting to anticipate their trajectory, thus enabling the preparation and implementation of effective mitigation strategies. With a special emphasis on COVID-19, the present work focuses on the Omicron variant, recognizing its significance in the global context of infectious diseases. The proposed research evaluates the effectiveness of both univariate and multivariate frameworks utilizing statistical and deep learning approaches to forecast the spread of the epidemic. Forecasting robustness is boosted by effectively correlating linear and non-linear components with the original series. To improve the performance, correlation is facilitated using correlation-driven weights within the statistically enforced deep learning model (WD-ensemble framework). The modeling process utilizes 493 data points and multivariate time-series records, including infected cases, vaccinated cases, and stringency index. The training dataset spans from November 1, 2021, to January 17, 2023, while the testing dataset covers the period from January 18, 2023, to March 8, 2023. The proposed WD-ensemble framework, incorporating stochasticity, outperforms all other state-of-the-art models, yielding highly reliable forecasts with remarkably low RMSE of 907.54, MAPE of 0.0008, and MAE of 670.78. It demonstrates a reduction in error percentages compared to the top-performing existing model, with decreases of 30.0267% in RMSE, 20% in MAPE, and 24.9411% in MAE. A pivotal revelation in this research is the robust negative correlation (-0.86) between vaccinated and confirmed cases as compared to the stringency index, implying that widespread vaccination could warrant the relaxation of stringent measures, including business and school closures.

computer science, information systems,information science & library science
Smooth Multi-Period Forecasting With Application to Prediction of COVID-19 Cases

Elena Tuzhilina,Trevor J. Hastie,Daniel J. McDonald,J. Kenneth Tay,Robert Tibshirani

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10618600.2023.2285337

2024-01-10

Journal of Computational and Graphical Statistics

Abstract:Forecasting methodologies have always attracted a lot of attention and have become an especially hot topic since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic. In this article we consider the problem of multi-period forecasting that aims to predict several horizons at once. We propose a novel approach that forces the prediction to be "smooth" across horizons and apply it to two tasks: point estimation via regression and interval prediction via quantile regression. This methodology was developed for real-time distributed COVID-19 forecasting. We illustrate the proposed technique with the COVIDcast dataset as well as a small simulation example. Supplementary materials for this article are available online.

statistics & probability
HierST: A Unified Hierarchical Spatial-temporal Framework for COVID-19 Trend Forecasting

Shun Zheng,Zhifeng Gao,Wei Cao,Jiang Bian,Tie-Yan Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3459637.3481927

2021-01-01

Abstract:The outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic has largely influenced the world and our normal daily lives. To combat this pandemic efficiently, governments usually need to coordinate essential resources across multiple regions and adjust intervention polices at the right time, which all call for accurate and robust forecasting of future epidemic trends. However, designing such a forecasting system is non-trivial, since we need to handle all kinds of locations at different administrative levels, which include pretty different epidemic-evolving patterns. Moreover, there are dynamic and volatile correlations of pandemic conditions among these locations, which further enlarge the difficulty in forecasting. With these challenges in mind, we develop a novel spatial-temporal forecasting framework. First, to accommodate all kinds of locations at different administrative levels, we propose a unified hierarchical view, which mimics the aggregation procedure of pandemic statistics. Then, this view motivates us to facilitate joint learning across administrative levels and inspires us to design the crosslevel consistency loss as an extra regularization to stabilize model training. Besides, to capture those dynamic and volatile spatial correlations, we design a customized spatial module with adaptive edge gates, which can both reinforce effective messages and disable irrelevant ones. We put this framework into production to help the battle against COVID-19 in the United States. A comprehensive online evaluation across three months demonstrates that our projections are the most competitive ones among all results produced by dozens of international group and even surpass the official ensemble in many cases. We also visualize our unique edge gates to understand the evolvement of spatial correlations and present intuitive case studies. Besides, we open source our implementation at https://github.com/dolphin-zs/HierST to facilitate future research towards better epidemic modeling.
A unified framework of epidemic spreading prediction by empirical mode decomposition based ensemble learning techniques

Yun Feng,Bing-Chuan Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/TCSS.2019.2915615

2019-01-07

Abstract:In this paper, a unified susceptible-exposed-infected-susceptible-aware (SEIS-A) framework is proposed to combine epidemic spreading with individuals' on-line self-consultation behaviors. An epidemic spreading prediction model is established based on the SEIS-A framework. The prediction process contains two phases. In phase I, the time series data of disease density are decomposed through the empirical mode decomposition (EMD) method to obtain the intrinsic mode functions (IMFs). In phase II, the ensemble learning techniques which use the on-line query data as an additional input are applied to these IMFs. Finally, experiments for prediction of weekly consultation rates of Hand-foot-and-mouth disease (HFMD) in Hong Kong are conducted to validate the effectiveness of the proposed method. The main advantage of this method is that it outperforms other methods on fluctuating complex data.

Computational Engineering, Finance, and Science,Machine Learning,Data Analysis, Statistics and Probability
A novel hybrid supervised and unsupervised hierarchical ensemble for COVID-19 cases and mortality prediction

Vitaliy Yakovyna,Nataliya Shakhovska,Aleksandra Szpakowska

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-60637-y

IF: 4.6

2024-04-30

Scientific Reports

Abstract:Though COVID-19 is no longer a pandemic but rather an endemic, the epidemiological situation related to the SARS-CoV-2 virus is developing at an alarming rate, impacting every corner of the world. The rapid escalation of the coronavirus has led to the scientific community engagement, continually seeking solutions to ensure the comfort and safety of society. Understanding the joint impact of medical and non-medical interventions on COVID-19 spread is essential for making public health decisions that control the pandemic. This paper introduces two novel hybrid machine-learning ensembles that combine supervised and unsupervised learning for COVID-19 data classification and regression. The study utilizes publicly available COVID-19 outbreak and potential predictive features in the USA dataset, which provides information related to the outbreak of COVID-19 disease in the US, including data from each of 3142 US counties from the beginning of the epidemic (January 2020) until June 2021. The developed hybrid hierarchical classifiers outperform single classification algorithms. The best-achieved performance metrics for the classification task were Accuracy = 0.912, ROC-AUC = 0.916, and F1-score = 0.916. The proposed hybrid hierarchical ensemble combining both supervised and unsupervised learning allows us to increase the accuracy of the regression task by 11% in terms of MSE, 29% in terms of the area under the ROC, and 43% in terms of the MPP metric. Thus, using the proposed approach, it is possible to predict the number of COVID-19 cases and deaths based on demographic, geographic, climatic, traffic, public health, social-distancing-policy adherence, and political characteristics with sufficiently high accuracy. The study reveals that virus pressure is the most important feature in COVID-19 spread for classification and regression analysis. Five other significant features were identified to have the most influence on COVID-19 spread. The combined ensembling approach introduced in this study can help policymakers design prevention and control measures to avoid or minimize public health threats in the future.

multidisciplinary sciences
Predictive performance of multi-model ensemble forecasts of COVID-19 across European nations

Katharine Sherratt,Hugo Gruson,Rok Grah,Helen Johnson,Rene Niehus,Bastian Prasse,Frank Sandmann,Jannik Deuschel,Daniel Wolffram,Sam Abbott,Alexander Ullrich,Graham Gibson,Evan L Ray,Nicholas G Reich,Daniel Sheldon,Yijin Wang,Nutcha Wattanachit,Lijing Wang,Jan Trnka,Guillaume Obozinski,Tao Sun,Dorina Thanou,Loic Pottier,Ekaterina Krymova,Jan H Meinke,Maria Vittoria Barbarossa,Jan Mohring,Johanna Schneider,Jan Fuhrmann,Berit Lange,Isti Rodiah,Prasith Baccam,Heidi Gurung,Steven Stage,Bradley Suchoski,Jozef Budzinski,Robert Walraven,Inmaculada Villanueva,Vit Tucek,Martin Smid,Borja Reina,Nikos I Bosse,Sophie R Meakin,Lauren Castro,Geoffrey Fairchild,Isaac Michaud,Dave Osthus,Pierfrancesco Alaimo Di Loro,Antonello Maruotti,Andrea Kraus,David Kraus,Lenka Pribylova,Bertsimas Dimitris,Michael Lingzhi Li,Soni Saksham,Jonas Dehning,Sebastian Mohr,Viola Priesemann,Grzegorz Redlarski,Benjamin Bejar,Giovanni Ardenghi,Nicola Parolini,Giovanni Ziarelli,Wolfgang Bock,Stefan Heyder,Thomas Hotz,David E Singh,Miguel Guzman-Merino,Jose L Aznarte,Sergio Alonso,Clara Prats,Jan Pablo Burgard,Arne Rodloff,Tom Zimmermann,Alexander Kuhlmann,Janez Zibert,Fulvia Pennoni,Fabio Divino,Gianfranco Lovison,Paolo Giudici,Barbara Tarantino,Francesco Bartolucci,Giovanna Jona Lasinio,Marco Mingione,Alessio Farcomeni,Ajitesh Srivastava,Pablo Montero-Manso,Aniruddha Adiga,Benjamin Hurt,Bryan Lewis,Madhav Marathe,Przemyslaw Porebski,Srinivasan Venkatramanan,Rafal P Bartczuk,Filip Dreger,Anna Gambin,Krzysztof Gogolewski,Bartosz Krupa,Antoni Moszyński,Karol Niedzielewski,Jedrzej Nowosielski,Maciej Radwan,Franciszek Rakowski,Marcin Semeniuk,Ewa Szczurek,Jan Kisielewski,Barbara Pabjan,Yuri Kheifetz,Markus Scholz,Marcin Bodych,Maciej Filinski,Radoslaw Idzikowski,Tyll Krueger,Tomasz Ozanski,Johannes Bracher,Sebastian Funk,Cesar Pérez Álvarez,Daniel López,David Moriña,Enric Álvarez,Holger Kirsten,Jakub Zieliński,Jaroslaw Włazło,Magdalena Gruziel-Słomka,Marti Català,Milan Zajíček,Neele Leithäuser,Przemyslaw Biecek,Veronika Eclerová

DOI: https://doi.org/10.7554/elife.81916

IF: 7.7

2023-04-22

eLife

Abstract:Background: Short-term forecasts of infectious disease contribute to situational awareness and capacity planning. Based on best practice in other fields and recent insights in infectious disease epidemiology, one can maximise forecasts' predictive performance by combining independent models into an ensemble. Here we report the performance of ensemble predictions of COVID-19 cases and deaths across Europe from March 2021 to March 2022.

biology
A dynamic ensemble approach based on trend analysis to COVID-19 incidence forecast

Jair Paulino de Sales,Paulo S.G. de Mattos Neto,Paulo R.A. Firmino

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bspc.2024.106435

IF: 5.1

2024-05-28

Biomedical Signal Processing and Control

Abstract:Traditional models have struggled to effectively predict COVID-19 incidence time series. Limitation arises from their difficulty in accurately capturing complex behaviors in COVID-19 data, including potential drifts, leading to underperformance in predictive accuracy. In response to this challenge, this paper introduces a novel approach, Dynamic Ensemble Selection based on Trend Classification (DESTC). DESTC addresses the shortcomings of traditional models by dynamically selecting the best specialist models for predicting different concepts within the COVID-19 series. The four main phases of DESTC involve classifying time series instances into trend categories, training ensemble models, evaluating and ranking models for each trend, and selecting the most appropriate models to forecast new test patterns based on their identified trend. Through experimental simulations involving eight datasets, DESTC demonstrated superior performance compared to seventeen literature single and ensemble approaches. These results highlight DESTC as a robust and competitive solution for forecasting COVID-19 incidence time series.

engineering, biomedical
Drivers and forecasts of multiple waves of the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic: A systematic analysis based on an interpretable machine learning framework

Zicheng Cao,Zekai Qiu,Feng Tang,Shiwen Liang,Yinghan Wang,Haoyu Long,Cai Chen,Bing Zhang,Chi Zhang,Yaqi Wang,Kang Tang,Jing Tang,Junhong Chen,Chunhui Yang,Yuzhe Xu,Yulin Yang,Shenglan Xiao,Dechao Tian,Guozhi Jiang,Xiangjun Du

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/tbed.14492

Abstract:Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has become a global pandemic and continues to prevail with multiple rebound waves in many countries. The driving factors for the spread of COVID-19 and their quantitative contributions, especially to rebound waves, are not well studied. Multidimensional time-series data, including policy, travel, medical, socioeconomic, environmental, mutant and vaccine-related data, were collected from 39 countries up to 30 June 2021, and an interpretable machine learning framework (XGBoost model with Shapley Additive explanation interpretation) was used to systematically analyze the effect of multiple factors on the spread of COVID-19, using the daily effective reproduction number as an indicator. Based on a model of the pre-vaccine era, policy-related factors were shown to be the main drivers of the spread of COVID-19, with a contribution of 60.81%. In the post-vaccine era, the contribution of policy-related factors decreased to 28.34%, accompanied by an increase in the contribution of travel-related factors, such as domestic flights, and contributions emerged for mutant-related (16.49%) and vaccine-related (7.06%) factors. For single-peak countries, the dominant ones were policy-related factors during both the rising and fading stages, with overall contributions of 33.7% and 37.7%, respectively. For double-peak countries, factors from the rebound stage contributed 45.8% and policy-related factors showed the greatest contribution in both the rebound (32.6%) and fading (25.0%) stages. For multiple-peak countries, the Delta variant, domestic flights (current month) and the daily vaccination population are the three greatest contributors (8.12%, 7.59% and 7.26%, respectively). Forecasting models to predict the rebound risk were built based on these findings, with accuracies of 0.78 and 0.81 for the pre- and post-vaccine eras, respectively. These findings quantitatively demonstrate the systematic drivers of the spread of COVID-19, and the framework proposed in this study will facilitate the targeted prevention and control of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic.
High-resolution short-term prediction of the COVID-19 epidemic based on spatial-temporal model modified by historical meteorological data

Bin Chen,Ruming Chen,Lin Zhao,Yuxiang Ren,Li Zhang,Yingjie Zhao,Xinbo Lian,Wei Yan,Shuoyuan Gao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fmre.2024.02.006

2024-03-05

Abstract:In the global challenge of Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, accurate prediction of daily new cases is crucial for epidemic prevention and socioeconomic planning. In contrast to traditional local, one-dimensional time-series data-based infection models, the study introduces an innovative approach by formulating the short-term prediction problem of new cases in a region as multidimensional, gridded time series for both input and prediction targets. A spatial-temporal depth prediction model for COVID-19 (ConvLSTM) is presented, and further ConvLSTM by integrating historical meteorological factors (Meteor-ConvLSTM) is refined, considering the influence of meteorological factors on the propagation of COVID-19. The correlation between 10 meteorological factors and the dynamic progression of COVID-19 was evaluated, employing spatial analysis techniques (spatial autocorrelation analysis, trend surface analysis, etc.) to describe the spatial and temporal characteristics of the epidemic. Leveraging the original ConvLSTM, an artificial neural network layer is introduced to learn how meteorological factors impact the infection spread, providing a 5-day forecast at a 0.01° × 0.01° pixel resolution. Simulation results using real dataset from the 3.15 outbreak in Shanghai demonstrate the efficacy of Meteor-ConvLSTM, with reduced RMSE of 0.110 and increased R 2 of 0.125 (original ConvLSTM: RMSE = 0.702, R 2 = 0.567; Meteor-ConvLSTM: RMSE = 0.592, R 2 = 0.692), showcasing its utility for investigating the epidemiological characteristics, transmission dynamics, and epidemic development.
Ensemble Approaches for Robust and Generalizable Short-Term Forecasts of Dengue Fever. A retrospective and prospective evaluation study in over 180 locations around the world

Skyler Wu,Austin Meyer,Leonardo Clemente,Lucas Stolerman,Fred Lu,Atreyee Majumder,Rudi Verbeeck,Serge Masyn,Mauricio Santillana

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.10.22.24315925

2024-10-23

Abstract:Dengue fever, a tropical vector-borne disease, is a leading cause of hospitalization and death in many parts of the world, especially in Asia and Latin America. In places where timely and accurate dengue activity surveillance is available, decision-makers possess valuable information that may allow them to better design and implement public health measures, and improve the allocation of limited public health resources. In addition, robust and reliable near-term forecasts of likely epidemic outcomes may further help anticipate increased demand on healthcare infrastructure and may promote a culture of preparedness. Here, we propose ensemble modeling approaches that combine forecasts produced with a variety of independent mechanistic, statistical, and machine learning component models to forecast reported dengue case counts 1-, 2-, and 3-months ahead of current time at the province level in multiple countries. We assess the ensemble and each component models' monthly predictive ability in a fully out-of-sample and retrospective fashion, in over 180 locations around the world - all provinces of Brazil, Colombia, Malaysia, Mexico, and Thailand, as well as Iquitos, Peru, and San Juan, Puerto Rico - during at least 2-3 years. Additionally, we evaluate ensemble approaches in a multi-model, real-time, and prospective dengue forecasting platform - where issues of data availability and data completeness introduce important limitations - during an 11-month time period in the years 2022 and 2023. We show that our ensemble modeling approaches lead to reliable and robust prediction estimates when compared to baseline estimates produced with available information at the time of prediction. This can be contrasted with the high variability in the forecasting ability of each individual component model, across locations and time. Furthermore, we find that no individual model leads to optimal and robust predictions across time horizons and locations, and while the ensemble models do not always achieve the best prediction performance in any given location, they consistently provide reliable disease estimates - they rank in the top 3 performing models across locations and time periods - both retrospectively and prospectively.

Epidemiology

Multi-source dynamic ensemble prediction of infectious disease and application in COVID-19 case

Forecasting the Long-Term Trend of COVID-19 Epidemic Using a Dynamic Model

Ensemble Prediction Method Based on Decomposition–Reconstitution–Integration for COVID-19 Outbreak Prediction

Predictive Modeling for Epidemic Outbreaks: A New Approach and COVID-19 Case Study

An autoregressive integrated moving average and long short-term memory (ARIM-LSTM) hybrid model for multi-source epidemic data prediction

Deep Dynamic Epidemiological Modelling for COVID-19 Forecasting in Multi-level Districts

DDE: Deep Dynamic Epidemiological Modeling for Infectious Illness Development Forecasting in Multi-level Geographic Entities

Advanced forecasting of COVID-19 epidemic: Leveraging ensemble models, advanced optimization, and decomposition techniques

Leveraging Human Mobility Data for Efficient Parameter Estimation in Epidemic Models of COVID-19

A dynamic ensemble model for short-term forecasting in pandemic situations

DDE: Deep Dynamic Epidemiological Modelling for Infectious Illness Development Forecasting in Multi-level Geographic Entities

Embracing the power of ensemble forecasting: A novel hybrid approach for advanced predictive modeling

Smooth Multi-Period Forecasting With Application to Prediction of COVID-19 Cases

HierST: A Unified Hierarchical Spatial-temporal Framework for COVID-19 Trend Forecasting

A unified framework of epidemic spreading prediction by empirical mode decomposition based ensemble learning techniques

A novel hybrid supervised and unsupervised hierarchical ensemble for COVID-19 cases and mortality prediction

Predictive performance of multi-model ensemble forecasts of COVID-19 across European nations

A dynamic ensemble approach based on trend analysis to COVID-19 incidence forecast

Drivers and forecasts of multiple waves of the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic: A systematic analysis based on an interpretable machine learning framework

High-resolution short-term prediction of the COVID-19 epidemic based on spatial-temporal model modified by historical meteorological data

Ensemble Approaches for Robust and Generalizable Short-Term Forecasts of Dengue Fever. A retrospective and prospective evaluation study in over 180 locations around the world