A dynamic panel threshold model analysis on heterogeneous environmental regulation, R&D investment, and enterprise green total factor productivity

Lu Liu,Rong Ren,Kaiyuan Cui,Lei Song

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-55970-1

IF: 4.6

2024-03-04

Scientific Reports

Abstract:Environmental regulations are important means to influence manufacturing enterprise green development. However, there are two completely different conclusions both in theoretical and in empirical research, namely the "Follow Cost" theory and the "Porter Hypothesis". The nonlinear mechanism needs to be considered. Therefore, this study aims to explain the threshold impact of heterogeneous environmental regulations on enterprise green total factor productivity. Environmental regulations are divided into different sub-categories, then based on the panel data of 1220 Chinese manufacturing listed companies from 2011 to 2020, this paper uses threshold regression model to examine the impact of heterogeneous environmental regulations on Chinese manufacturing enterprise Green Total Factor Productivity. The empirical results show that: (1) Command-controlled, market-incentive and voluntary-agreement environmental regulation all have a significant nonlinear impact on enterprise Green Total Factor Productivity. (2) Enterprise R&D investment plays a threshold role in the impact. (3) There are industry and equity type differences in the impact process. This study focuses on the micro level of enterprises and tests the threshold mechanism, which make some theoretical complement to previous researches. The research results are not only beneficial for the government to propose appropriate environmental regulatory policies, but also for enterprises to achieve green growth through heterogeneous R&D investment.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper aims to explore the threshold effects of different types of environmental regulations (command-and-control, market-based incentives, and voluntary agreements) on firms' green total factor productivity (GTFP) and analyze the role of firms' R&D investment in this process. Specifically:

1. **Research Background**:
- While China's economy is rapidly developing, environmental pollution is becoming increasingly severe.
- Traditional development models have led to high energy consumption and high emissions, affecting sustainable development.
- The Chinese government promotes green development in manufacturing firms through various environmental regulation measures.

2. **Research Objectives**:
- Explain the impact mechanisms of different types of environmental regulations on firms' green total factor productivity.
- Explore the threshold role of firms' R&D investment in this process.
- Analyze the differences in the impact of environmental regulations across industries and types of ownership.

3. **Research Methods**:
- Use a panel threshold regression model to analyze data from 1,220 listed manufacturing companies in China from 2011 to 2020.
- Classify environmental regulations into three types: command-and-control, market-based incentives, and voluntary agreements.
- Use firms' R&D investment as a threshold variable to examine its role under different environmental regulations.

4. **Main Findings**:
- Command-and-control, market-based incentives, and voluntary agreements all have significant nonlinear effects on firms' green total factor productivity.
- Firms' R&D investment plays a threshold role in the impact of environmental regulations on firms' green total factor productivity.
- There are differences in this process across different industries and types of ownership.

5. **Theoretical Contributions**:
- Explore the impact mechanisms of environmental regulations on firms' green total factor productivity at the micro level.
- Introduce firms' R&D investment as a threshold variable, clarifying its role under different environmental regulations.
- Conduct heterogeneity analysis based on industry and ownership type, providing references for firms and policymakers.

In summary, this paper attempts to explain through empirical analysis how different types of environmental regulations affect firms' green total factor productivity and emphasizes the critical role of firms' R&D investment in this process.