Harmonizing AI governance regulations and neuroinformatics: perspectives on privacy and data sharing
Roba Alsaigh,Rashid Mehmood,Iyad Katib,Xiaohui Liang,Abdullah Alshanqiti,Juan M. Corchado,Simon See
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fninf.2024.1472653
2024-12-18
Frontiers in Neuroinformatics
Abstract:In the rapidly evolving field of neuroinformatics, the intersection of artificial intelligence (AI) and neuroscience presents both unprecedented opportunities and formidable ethical challenges (Ienca and Ignatiadis 2020;Dubois et al. 2023;Parellada et al. 2023;Scheinost et al. 2023). As AI technologies increasingly underpin neuroscientific research, it is crucial to establish robust governance frameworks that not only match the ambitious scope of this research but also adhere to stringent requirements for privacy and data sharing (Eke et al. 2022;Jwa and Martinez-Martin 2024;Yuste 2023;UK Government 2018). This paper explores the urgent need to harmonize AI governance regulations with neuroinformatics practices, with a specific focus on the domains of data sharing and privacy.This opinion paper is grounded in a comprehensive analysis of over 4000 research articles and AI regulation documents, supplemented by referencing over 100 pivotal articles and documents. It offers a critical examination of current AI governance frameworks and the existing challenges at the intersection of AI and neuroinformaticsfoot_0 . Through this analysis, we systematically explore the stateof-the-art in neuroinformatics (Section 2), its challenges (Section 3), and the evaluation of AI governance (Section 4), identifying key alignments and gaps (Section 5). We conclude with strategic recommendations for better integration of these fields, aimed at enhancing research outcomes while ensuring privacy and fostering ethical practices (Section 6).By integrating these diverse perspectives, the paper aims to spark a constructive dialogue among policymakers, researchers, and practitioners. The objective is to develop a cohesive framework that not only supports innovation in neuroinformatics but also operates under the umbrella of conscientious and effective AI governance, ensuring that neuroinformatics can continue its rapid advancement in a responsible and ethically sound manner.Neuroinformatics has experienced transformative advancements through enhanced data sharing frameworks and technological innovations (Daidone et al. 2024;Weiner, Veitch, Aisen, Beckett, Cairns, Cedarbaum, Donohue, et al. 2015;MacGillivray et al. 2018;Cao et al. 2023). These developments have significantly improved research efficiency and fostered innovation, particularly in complex areas such as autism (Parellada et al. 2023;Zucchini et al. 2023;Saponaro et al. 2022) and Alzheimer's disease (Yao et al. 2023;Y. Zhang et al. 2022;Dubois et al. 2023).One of the most notable advancements in neuroinformatics is the standardization of data sharing practices (J. Wang et al. 2023;Alzheimer Europe 2021). Initiatives such as the Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI) (Weiner, Veitch, Aisen, Beckett, Cairns, Cedarbaum, Donohue, et al. 2015;Weiner, Veitch, Aisen, Beckett, Cairns, Cedarbaum, Green, et al. 2015) and the Common Data Element (CDE) Project in epilepsy research (Loring et al. 2011) exemplify how standardized practices, including shared ontologies, common data elements, and standardized data formats, facilitate robust validation of results across diverse studies and enable large-scale, multi-centre studies (L. Wang et al. 2023;MacGillivray et al. 2018;Yaseen et al. 2023). These elements are fundamental for integrating data from various sources, evident in the success of these projects (Ojo et al. 2020;Viejo et al. 2023). This integration is vital for the scalability and reproducibility of neuroinformatics research, leading to more reliable outcomes and faster scientific progress (Gurari et al. 2015;Baker et al. 2015;Sarwate et al. 2014).Technological enhancements such as electronic health records and sophisticated data repositories have revolutionized how data is collected, managed, and shared within the field (Gentili et al. 2021;Leoratto et al. 2023). These technologies are crucial for supporting longitudinal studies and comprehensive data analyses necessary for understanding long-term outcomes of neurological conditions including traumatic brain injury (Vallmuur et al. 2023;Yaseen et al. 2023). Moreover, the role of international collaborations cannot be overstated. Initiatives such as the Dominantly Inherited Alzheimer Network (DIAN) (Bateman et al. 2012) and global epilepsy research consortia (Galanopoulou et al. 2021;Mishra et al. 2022) highlight the importance of pooling resources and expertise to tackle complex scientific questions, significantly enhancing the scope and impact of research efforts (Chou et al. 2022). Privacy-preserving technologies including differential privacy, encryption, anonymization, and blockchain have become integral to maintaining data confidentiality, while enabling expansive research and clinical applications (Z. Zhang, Xu, and Xiao 2023;Yuste 2023;C. Yang, Yuan, and Feng 2023;Patel, Provenzano, and Loew 2023). Notably, federated learning and edge computing have gained att -Abstract Truncated-
neurosciences,mathematical & computational biology