Abstract:Hydrogen is the lightest and most abundant element in the universe. Ever since Wigner and Huntington's prediction that pressure induced metallization might happen in solid hydrogen, understanding the hydrogen phase diagram has become one of the greatest challenges in condensed matter and high pressure physics. The light mass of hydrogen means that the nuclear quantum effects could be important in describing this phase diagram under high pressures. Numerical evaluations of their contributions to the structural, vibrational, and energetic properties, however, are difficult and up to now most of the theoretical simulations still remain classical. This is particularly true for the energetic properties. When the free-energies of different phases are compared in determining the ground state structure of the system at a given pressure and temperature, most of the theoretical simulations remain classical. When nuclear quantum effects must be taken into account, one often resorts to the harmonic approximation. In the very rare case, the anharmonic contributions from the nuclear statistical effects are considered by using a combination of the thermodynamic integration and the at initio molecular dynamics methods, which helps to include the classical nuclear anharmonic effects. Quantum nuclear anharmonic effects, however, are completely untouched. Here, using a self-developed combination of the thermodynamic integration and the at initio path-integral molecular dynamics methods, we calculated the free-energies of the high pressure hydrogen at 100 K from 200 GPa to 300 GPa. The harmonic lattice was taken as the reference and the Cmca phase of the solid hydrogen was chosen. When the bead number of the path-integral (P) equals one, our approach reaches the so-called classical limit. Upon increasing P until the results are converged, our approach reaches the limit when both classical and quantum nuclear anharmonic effects are included. Therefore, by comparing the free-energy of the harmonic lattice and the thermodynamic integration results at P equals one, we isolate the classical nuclear anharmonic effects. By comparing the thermodynamic integration results at P equals one and with those when they are converged with respect to P, we isolate the quantum nuclear anharmonic effects in a very clean manner. Our calculations show that the classical nuclear anharmonic contributions to the free-energy are negligible at this low temperature. Those contributions from the quantum nuclear anharmonic effects, however, are as large as ～15 meV per atom. This value also increases with pressure. This study presents an algorithm to quantitatively calculate the quantum contribution of the nuclear motion to free-energy beyond the often used harmonic approximation. The large numbers we got obtained also indicate that such quantum nuclear anharmonic effects are important in describing the phase diagram of hydrogen, at/above the pressures studied.

Theory of high pressure hydrogen, made simple

High-pressure Raman Study of Solid Hydrogen Up to 300 GPa

Hydrogen at extreme pressures (Review Article)

High-pressure II-III phase transition in solid hydrogen: Insights from state-of-the-art ab initio calculations

Classical and Quantum Ordering of Protons in Cold Solid Hydrogen under Megabar Pressures

A Comparative Study Using State-of-the-art Electronic Structure Theories on Solid Hydrogen Phases under High Pressures

Ultrahigh-pressure Isostructural Electronic Transitions in Hydrogen

Quantum Monte Carlo study of the phase diagram of solid molecular hydrogen at extreme pressures

Thermodynamic anomalies and three distinct liquid-liquid transitions in warm dense liquid hydrogen

Density functional theory study of phase IV of solid hydrogen

Quantum phase diagram of high-pressure hydrogen

On the Room-Temperature Phase Diagram of High Pressure Hydrogen: an Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics Perspective and A Diffusion Monte Carlo Study

X-Ray Diffraction And Equation Of State Of Hydrogen At Megabar Pressures

The Hydrogen‐bond Effect on the High Pressure Behavior of Hydrazinium Monochloride

Dense Molecular Hydrogen: Order, Disorder, and Localization

A Fully Quantum Description of the Free-Energy in High Pressure Hydrogen

Proton Transfer in Phase IV of Solid Hydrogen and Deuterium

Structures of solid hydrogen at 300K

Phase Transition in Solid Molecular Hydrogen at Ultrahigh Pressures.

Predicted reentrant melting of dense hydrogen at ultra-high pressures

Hexagonal to Monoclinic Phase Transition in Dense Hydrogen Phase III Detected by High-Pressure NMR