Abstract:Effective engagement is crucial for enhancing environmental decision-making processes, fostering more sustainable and equitable outcomes. However, the success of engagement is highly variable and context-dependent. While theoretical frameworks have been developed to explain outcome variance in engagement in environmental decision-making, they have not yet been tested in digital contexts, leaving their applicability to digital engagement processes unclear. More broadly, there are unanswered questions about the effectiveness of digital tools in achieving the goals of engagement, which have become increasingly pertinent amidst growing concerns about the potential of digital technologies for exacerbating exclusions, ethical issues, and systematically undermining democratic progress. This paper addresses this evidence gap by presenting findings from interviews with practitioners in UK public, private, and third sector organisations. Our results provide empirical insights into the technical, ethical, and inclusivity debates surrounding digital tools and their effectiveness in promoting accessible engagement, high-quality social interaction, place-based decision-making, and more trustworthy and credible outcomes. Our findings indicate that while current engagement theories are applicable to digital environments, the key explanatory factors acquire new dimensions in digital compared to in-person contexts. Drawing on the findings, this study contributes novel insights to expand current theory for explaining "what works" in engagement in environmental decisions, enhancing its relevance and applicability in the digital age. The paper concludes with evidence-led recommendations for environmental practitioners to improve engagement processes in digital and remote settings.

Dropping off the bandwagon: a puzzle for the resource mobilisation perspective on civil society contestation networks

Digital resource abundance: How social media shapes success and failure of online mobilisation

Preserving Space for Volunteers: Exploring the Links between Voluntary Welfare Organisations, Volunteering and Citizenship

Open networks and secret Facebook groups: exploring cycle effects on activists’ social media use in the 2010/11 UK student protests

How do community organizations develop successful strategies of resistance? Revisiting institutional embeddedness and agency

Interaction Ritual Chains and the Mobilization of Conscientious Consumers

The limits to bridging social capital: Power, social context and the theory of Robert Putnam

From Groups to Communities: A Resource Mobilization Theory Perspective on the Emergence of Communities

From Moment to Movement: Empowerment and Resilience as a Framework for Collective Action in Hong Kong

Resisting or enabling? The roll-out of neoliberal values through the voluntary and community sector in Northern Ireland

Dynamics of collective action to conserve a large common-pool resource

Civic engagement, political participation and the radical right in Central and Eastern Europe

Policy Wars for Peace: Network Model of NGO Behavior

From imagination to activism: Cognitive alternatives motivate commitment to activism through identification with social movements and collective efficacy

Participating or Not Participating? A Sociomaterial Perspective of the Embeddedness of Online Communities in Everyday Life

Conceptualizing contexts or contextualizing concepts? On some issues of the modeling of relational spaces in the study of collective action

Users as Citizens: Collective Action and the Local Governance of Welfare

Power, discourse, and learning global citizenship

Mobilizing From Scratch: Large-Scale Collective Action Without Preexisting Organization in the Syrian Uprising

Engagement in the digital age: Understanding "what works" for participatory technologies in environmental decision-making

From Mobilisation to Radicalisation: Probing the Persistence and Radicalisation of Social Movements Using an Agent-Based Model