Abstract:Stimulated by informal conversations at the XVII International Small Angle Scattering (SAS) conference (Traverse City, 2017), an international team of experts undertook a round-robin exercise to produce a large dataset from proteins under standard solution conditions. These data were used to generate consensus SAS profiles for xylose isomerase, urate oxidase, xylanase, lysozyme and ribonuclease A. Here, we apply a new protocol using maximum likelihood with a larger number of the contributed datasets to generate improved consensus profiles. We investigate the fits of these profiles to predicted profiles from atomic coordinates that incorporate different models to account for the contribution to the scattering of water molecules of hydration surrounding proteins in solution. Programs using an implicit, shell-type hydration layer generally optimize fits to experimental data with the aid of two parameters that adjust the volume of the bulk solvent excluded by the protein and the contrast of the hydration layer. For these models, we found the error-weighted residual differences between the model and the experiment generally reflected the subsidiary maxima and minima in the consensus profiles that are determined by the size of the protein plus the hydration layer. By comparison, all-atom solute and solvent molecular dynamics (MD) simulations are without the benefit of adjustable parameters and, nonetheless, they yielded at least equally good fits with residual differences that are less reflective of the structure in the consensus profile. Further, where MD simulations accounted for the precise solvent composition of the experiment, specifically the inclusion of ions, the modelled radius of gyration values were significantly closer to the experiment. The power of adjustable parameters to mask real differences between a model and the structure present in solution is demonstrated by the results for the conformationally dynamic ribonuclease A and calculations with pseudo-experimental data. This study shows that, while methods invoking an implicit hydration layer have the unequivocal advantage of speed, care is needed to understand the influence of the adjustable parameters. All-atom solute and solvent MD simulations are slower but are less susceptible to false positives, and can account for thermal fluctuations in atomic positions, and more accurately represent the water molecules of hydration that contribute to the scattering profile.

Scrutinizing the protein hydration shell from molecular dynamics simulations against consensus small-angle scattering data

Benchmarking predictive methods for small-angle X-ray scattering from atomic coordinates of proteins using maximum likelihood consensus data

Combining molecular dynamics simulations with small-angle X-ray and neutron scattering data to study multi-domain proteins in solution.

Single Molecule Force Spectroscopy Studies on the Hydrophobic Hydration

Coherent X-ray Scattering Reveals Nanoscale Fluctuations in Hydrated Proteins

Characterizing Hydration of SDS Micelles by Contrast Variation Small Angle Neutron Scattering

Investigation of the hydration shell of a membrane in an open system molecular dynamics simulation

Small-Angle X-ray Scattering Signatures of Conformational Heterogeneity and Homogeneity of Disordered Protein Ensembles

Quantifying the Errors Introduced by Continuum Scattering Models on the Inferred Structural Properties of Proteins

Small angle x-ray scattering experiments of monodisperse samples close to the solubility limit

Contiguous Patches of Translational Hydration Dynamics on the Surface of K-Ras

Spatial Layouts of Low‐Entropy Hydration Shells Guide Protein Binding

Toward a Coarse-Grained Protein Model Coupled with a Coarse-Grained Solvent Model: Solvation Free Energies of Amino Acid Side Chains

Hydration Water Dynamics and Instigation of Protein Structural Relaxation

Protein and hydration-water dynamics are decoupled: A new model connecting dynamics and biochemical function is required

On the vibrational free energy of hydrated proteins

Dissecting Hydrophobic Hydration and Association

The structural order of protein hydration water

Peculiarities of the Dynamical Hydration Shell of Native Conformation Protein Using a Bovine Serum Albumin Example

Computing spatially resolved rotational hydration entropies from atomistic simulations

Predicting solution scattering patterns with explicit-solvent molecular simulations