Abstract:The innovation process can be conceptualized as encompassing two stages: idea generation and idea implementation. However, to date, more early research has been focused on the idea generation stage, and these two subfields still remain stubbornly disconnected from one another. To integrate these two disparate subfields and advance our comprehensive understanding of the innovation process, the current study relied on self-determination theory and Yale attitude change approach to examine the effect of intrinsic motivational orientation of idea generators on idea quality, and further tested the effect of idea quality, rewards of the idea generators, and their interaction on idea implementation. To test the hypotheses in the proposed model, we collected data from 251 idea generators, 7 idea evaluators and the manager of an innovative proposal project at 3 different time points in a large financial company. In the first wave, 440 ideas proposed by 440 idea generators were recorded. In the second wave, all of the idea generators were invited to complete a questionnaire, including demographic information and intrinsic motivational orientation, and the number of valid questionnaires was 251; moreover, 7 in-house experts assessed the idea generators and the quality of each idea. Approximately six months later, the manager of this project reported the implementation degree of all of the ideas. Our hypotheses were examined using SPSS 22.0. By analyzing the multi-time and multi-source data, it was found in this study that: (1) intrinsic motivational orientation of the idea generators has a significantly positive effect on idea quality; (2) idea quality further facilitates idea implementation; (3) rewards of the idea generators positively influence idea implementation; and (4) idea quality and rewards of the idea generators interact to predict idea implementation. The findings presented here contribute to innovation literature in the following ways. First, this study tracks the innovation process from idea generation to idea implementation, bridging the theoretical divide between creativity research and idea implementation research. Second, this study clarifies the positive effect of intrinsic motivational orientation on idea quality, which is a beneficial supplement to, and promotion of the existing research on the relationship between intrinsic motivation and creativity. Third, Yale attitude change theory is introduced into idea implementation research, which not only expands the application scope of this theory, but also enriches theoretical perspectives of idea implementation research.

Does familiarity with an idea bias its evaluation?

Detecting Fixation Bias in Creative Idea Generation: Evidence from Design Novices and Experts

Greater variability in judgements of the value of novel ideas

When familiarity not novelty motivates information-seeking behaviour

Creative Evaluation: The Role of Memory in Novelty & Effectiveness Judgements

Curious? The relationship between curiosity and creativity is likely NOT novelty

The Journey of Business Opportunity Evaluation: When and Why Does Opportunity Novelty Promote Vs. Inhibit Opportunity Adoption?

Seeing value in novelty: Manager and employee social networks as keys in managers' idea evaluation and implementation decisions

The Importance of Separating Appropriateness into Impact and Feasibility for the Psychology of Creativity

Idea Convergence Quality in Open Innovation Crowdsourcing: A Cognitive Load Perspective

Evaluation standards regulate the generation and selection of novel ideas in creative behaviors: insights from individual differences in event-related potentials

Assessing the Impact of Recommendation Novelty on Older Consumers: Older Does Not Always Mean the Avoidance of Innovative Products

Surprise! Measuring Novelty as Expectation Violation

Where there's a will, there's a way: Intrinsic motivational orientation, idea quality, and idea implementation

The Performance Effects of Combining Rationality and Intuition in Making Early New Product Idea Evaluation Decisions

Neural Pathway of Renovative and Innovative Products Appreciation

Future thinking and managers' innovative behavior: an experimental study

Humans as Creativity Gatekeepers: Are We Biased Against AI Creativity?

Bridging the gap between design and behavioral research: (Re)searching the optimum design strategy for brands and new product innovations

An extension of the novelty-seeking model: Considering the plurality of novelty types and their differential interactions with memory

Concept evaluation dilemma: Presentation effect on product concept evaluation in the new product development (NPD) process