Abstract:Individual differences in cognitive performance in childhood are a key predictor of significant life outcomes such as educational attainment and mental health. Differences in cognitive ability are governed in part by variations in brain structure. However, studies commonly focus on either grey or white matter metrics in humans, leaving open the key question as to whether grey or white matter microstructure play distinct or complementary roles supporting cognitive performance. To compare the role of grey and white matter in supporting cognitive performance, we used regularized structural equation models to predict cognitive performance with grey and white matter measures. Specifically, we compared how grey matter (volume, cortical thickness and surface area) and white matter measures (volume, fractional anisotropy and mean diffusivity) predicted individual differences in cognitive performance. The models were tested in 11,876 children (ABCD Study, 5680 female; 6196 male) at 10 years old. We found that grey and white matter metrics bring partly non-overlapping information to predict cognitive performance. The models with only grey or white matter explained respectively 15.4% and 12.4% of the variance in cognitive performance, while the combined model explained 19.0%. Zooming in we additionally found that different metrics within grey and white matter had different predictive power, and that the tracts/regions that were most predictive of cognitive performance differed across metric. These results show that studies focusing on a single metric in either grey or white matter to study the link between brain structure and cognitive performance are missing a key part of the equation. Significance Statement This paper enriches the recent debates on the challenges of linking variation in brain structure to phenotypic differences (Marek et al., 2022). We demonstrate that using latent variables (to improve power), structural equation modelling (to allow greater flexibility in linking brain to behaviour), and by simultaneously incorporating multiple measures of grey and white matter in a large sample, we demonstrate relatively strong and robust brain-behaviour associations, which highlight the complementarity of grey and white matter metrics in predicting cognitive performance as well as the importance of incorporating the full complexity of these associations over 1-to-1 linkages. This finding should lead researchers to consider integrating both grey and white matter measures when demonstrating a more comprehensive picture of brain-cognition relationships.

The impact of early adversity and education on genetic and brain morphological predictors of cognitive ability

The impact of early adversity on the cerebral cortex - a Mendelian randomization study

Grey and white matter metrics demonstrate distinct and complementary prediction of differences in cognitive performance in children: Findings from ABCD (N= 11 876)

Longitudinally stable, brain-based predictive models mediate the relationships between childhood cognition and socio-demographic, psychological and genetic factors

The differential effects of common and rare genetic variants on cognitive performance across development

Genetic Influences on Individual Differences in Longitudinal Changes in Global and Subcortical Brain Volumes: Results of the ENIGMA Plasticity Working Group

The Interaction Effects of Age, APOE and Common Environmental Risk Factors on Human Brain Structure

Gene-environment interactions in the influence of maternal education on adolescent neurodevelopment using ABCD study

The relationship between cognitive abilities and mental health as represented by cognitive abilities at the neural and genetic levels of analysis

Associations Between Polygenic Scores for Cognitive and Non-cognitive Factors of Educational Attainment and Measures of Behavior, Psychopathology, and Neuroimaging in the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development Study

High-effect gene-coding variants impact cognition, mental well-being, and neighborhood safety substrates in brain morphology

Cognitive ability and education: how behavioural genetic research has advanced our knowledge and understanding of their association

Quantitative genetic modeling of variation in human brain morphology.

Healthy Lifestyle, Genetic Risk and Brain Health: A Gene-Environment Interaction Study in the UK Biobank

Genetic Contributions to Human Brain Morphology and Intelligence.

Genetic influences on brain and cognitive health and their interactions with cardiovascular conditions and depression

Brain structure and function show distinct relations with genetic predispositions to mental health and cognition

Genetic effects and gene-by-education interactions on episodic memory performance and decline in an aging population

Gene-environment correlation: The role of family environment in academic development

Genetics impact risk of Alzheimer’s disease through mechanisms modulating structural brain morphology in late life

Cognitive and brain development is independently influenced by socioeconomic status and polygenic scores for educational attainment