Abstract:OBJECTIVE: The use of personal cooling systems to mitigate heat strain on first-responders achieves two potential performance benefits relative to the absence of such cooling: (1) the completion of a workload with less effort; and/or (2) the completion of a greater workload for the same effort. Currently, claims made by manufacturers regarding the capability of their products for use in conjunction with chemical/biological protective clothing remain largely unsubstantiated. The purpose of this investigation was to evaluate the means by which heat strain can be alleviated during uncompensable heat stress in chemical/biological clothing, using the ASTM F2300-10 methodology.METHODS: Eight healthy males completed five trials of continuous walking (4.5 km h-1; 35°C; 49% RH) for up to 120 min while wearing one of four cooling systems and/or a National Fire and Protection Association 1994 Class-3 chemical/biological ensemble. The four cooling methods (ice vest [IV], phase-change vest [PCM], water-perfused suit [WS], and combination ice slurry/ice vest [SLIV]) and no cooling (CON).RESULTS: We observed significant improvements in trial times for IV (18 ± 10 min), PCM (20 ± 10 min) and SLIV (22 ± 10 min), but no differences for WS (4 ± 7 min). Heart rate, rectal, mean skin, and body temperatures were significantly lower in all cooling conditions relative to control at various matched time points in the first 60 min of exercise. Thermal sensation, comfort and perceived exertion all had significant main effects for condition, and time, there were no differences in their respective interactions.CONCLUSION: The IV, PCM, and SLIV produced lower heart rate, mean skin, rectal and mean body temperatures in addition to improved work times compared to control. The WS did not improve work times possibly as a result of the cooling capacity of the suit abating, and magnifying thermal insulation. Considering the added time and resources required to implement combination cooling in the form of ice slurry and ice vest (SLIV), there was no significant additive effect for perception, cardiovascular strain, rectal temperature and total trial time relative to the phase change vest or ice vest alone. This may be a product of a "ceiling" effect for work limit set to 120 min as part of ASTM F2300-10.

Evaluation of Wearability, Kinetic and Kinematic Changes During Wearing of Three Layered Extreme Cold Weather Clothing

Wear trial assessment of layer structure effects on vapor permeability and condensation in a cold weather clothing ensemble

Study on the Performance of Personal Heating in Extremely Cold Environments Using a Thermal Manikin

Effect of base layer materials on physiological and perceptual responses to exercise in personal protective equipment

Thermal Insulation of Protective Clothing Materials in Extreme Cold Conditions

Thermophysiological Effect of Clothing Temperature Control in Cold Environment During Exercise

Development and Performance Evaluation of Body Armor for Wear Comfort Enhancement

Effect of Phase Change Materials on Temperature and Moisture Distributions in Clothing During Exercise in Cold Environment

The effect of the transfer abilities of single layers on the heat and mass transport through multilayered outerwear clothing for cold protection

Wet Military Uniforms Pose Low Risk of Hypothermia while Static in Mild Cold Air

Experimental Investigation of the Thermal Insulation and Evaporative Resistance of Protective Clothing on a Thermal Manikin in a Hot Environment

Explorations of clothing-typed wearable platforms: satisfaction evaluations and displacement measurements

Effect of Moisture Management on Functional Performance of Cold Protective Clothing

Effect of layering sequence and ambient temperature on thermal insulation of multilayer high bulk nonwoven under extreme cold temperatures

Cold-preventing simulation of low-temperature protective clothing based on an unsteady one-dimensional heat conduction model

Modeling of Interface Loads for EOD Suit Wearers

Analysing the Impact of Cloth Fabrics on Skin Temperature during and after Exercise using an FDM Model

Clothing resultant thermal insulation determined on a movable thermal manikin. Part II: effects of wind and body movement on local insulation

An Evaluation of Personal Cooling Systems for Reducing Thermal Strain Whilst Working in Chemical/Biological Protective Clothing

Effects of Multilayer Clothing System Array on Water Vapor Transfer and Condensation in Cold Weather Clothing Ensemble

Research on Thermal Insulation Characteristic of Multilayer Clothing