Abstract:As-built Building Information Models (BIMs) are becoming increasingly popular in the Architectural, Engineering, Construction, Owner and Operator (AECOO) industry. These models reflect the state of the building up to as-built conditions. The production of these models for existing buildings with no prior BIM includes the segmentation and classification of point cloud data and the reconstruction of the BIM objects. The automation of this process is a must since the manual Scan-to-BIM procedure is both time-consuming and error prone. However, the automated reconstruction from point cloud data is still ongoing research with both 2D and 3D approaches being proposed. There currently is a gap in the literature concerning the quality assessment of the created entities. In this research, we present the empirical comparison of both strategies with respect to existing specifications. A 3D and a 2D reconstruction method are implemented and tested on a real life test case. The experiments focus on the reconstruction of the wall geometry from unstructured point clouds as it forms the basis of the model. Both presented approaches are unsupervised methods that segment, classify and create generic wall elements. The first method operates on the 3D point cloud itself and consists of a general approach for the segmentation and classification and a class-specific reconstruction algorithm for the wall geometry. The point cloud is first segmented into planar clusters, after which a Random Forests classifier is used with geometric and contextual features for the semantic labelling. The final wall geometry is created based on the 3D point clusters representing the walls. The second method is an efficient Manhattan-world scene reconstruction algorithm that simultaneously segments and classifies the point cloud based on point feature histograms. The wall reconstruction is considered an instance of image segmentation by representing the data as 2D raster images. Both methods have promising results towards the reconstruction of wall geometry of multi-story buildings. The experiments report that over 80% of the walls were correctly segmented by both methods. Furthermore, the reconstructed geometry is conform Level-of-Accuracy 20 for 88% of the data by the first method and for 55% by the second method despite the Manhattan-world scene assumption. The empirical comparison showcases the fundamental differences in both strategies and will support the further development of these methods.

Modeling of 3D geometry uncertainty in Scan-to-BIM automatic indoor reconstruction

Scan-to-BIM method in construction: assessment of the 3D buildings model accuracy in terms inventory measurements

A Novel Method for Analyzing the Influence of Relative Attitude of Laser Profile Scanner on 3D Measurement System

A parametric approach towards semi-automated 3D as-built modeling

Deviation analysis method for the assessment of the quality of the as-is Building Information Models generated from point cloud data

QUALITY EVALUATION OF 3D BUILDING MODELS BASED ON LOW-ALTITUDE IMAGERY AND AIRBORNE LASER SCANNING POINT CLOUDS

SCAN-TO-BIM method and analysis of measurement accuracy on the example of a historic church

Digital twin-enabled error and uncertainty mapping for 3D scanning

A Numerical Simulation Procedure for Evaluating the Accuracy of 3-Dimensional Photogrammetric Models and Its Application to Geometric Parameters of Discontinuities in Rock Masses

An Overview of Constructing Geometric Models of Buildings Using Point Clouds

Accuracy evaluation of the semi-automatic 3D modeling for historical building information models

ACCURACY INVESTIGATION ON IMAGE-BASED CHANGE DETECTION FOR BIM COMPLIANT INDOOR MODELS

BIM RECONSTRUCTION: AUTOMATED PROCEDURAL MODELING FROM POINT CLOUD DATA

A Practical Application Using Parametric Modeling for As-Built BIM Generation from Point Clouds

Automatic reconstruction of as-built building information models from laser-scanned point clouds: A review of related techniques

Quality analysis on 3D building models reconstructed from airborne laser scanning data

A SCAN-TO-BIM WORKFLOW PROPOSAL FOR CULTURAL HERITAGE. AUTOMATIC POINT CLOUD SEGMENTATION AND PARAMETRIC-ADAPTIVE MODELLING OF VAULTED SYSTEMS

Leveraging Deep Learning for Automated Reconstruction of Indoor Unstructured Elements in Scan-to-BIM

Comparison of 2D and 3D wall reconstruction algorithms from point cloud data for as-built BIM

Automated BIM generation for large-scale indoor complex environments based on deep learning

Point Cloud Validation: On the Impact of Laser Scanning Technologies on the Semantic Segmentation for BIM Modeling and Evaluation