Abstract:We provide a comprehensive comparison of CEO pay in public and private US firms over the period 1999 through 2008. The main difference between public and private firms is the existence for public firms of an active market for the firm’s shares. Consistent with the predictions of the optimal contracting models in which both managers and shareholders can trade in public equity markets we show that the structure of annual pay in public firms contains significant equity-based incentives, while private firms rely more on salary and bonus. Despite the larger amounts of equity-based pay, however, public firm CEOs have lower overall portfolio incentives. Additionally, pay in public firms is positively related to both accounting and stock price performance, while private firm pay is basically unrelated to firm performance. We also show that, all else equal, public firm CEOs earn an 18% pay premium over private firm CEOs—a result that appear to be driven by labor market segmentation between public and private firms. Finally, when firms transition from private to public status, we find that both the structure and level of pay change significantly in ways that corroborate our findings from the cross-section.

Profit Puzzles or: Public Firm Profits Have Fallen

Income inequality, managers’ compensation and the falling rate of profit: Reconciling the US evidence

The Beginning of the Trend: Interest Rates, Profits, and Markups

Rate of Profit in the United States and in China (2007–2014): A Look at Two Trajectories and Strategic Sectors

The Micro-Aggregated Profit Share

Zipf's Law, Pareto's Law, and the Evolution of Top Incomes in the U.S.

Large Firms, Consumer Heterogeneity and the Rising Share of Profits

Do Gender Disparities in Employment Increase Profitability? Evidence from the United States

A conjecture on the distribution of firm profit

A Comparison of CEO Pay in Public and Private US Firms

Corporate Profitability and the Dynamics of Competition in Emerging Markets: A time Series Analysis

Are CEOs in Public U.S. Firms Overpaid? New Evidence from Private Firms

LONG WAVES, INSTITUTIONAL CHANGES, AND HISTORICAL TRENDS: A STUDY OF THE LONG-TERM MOVEMENT OF THE PROFIT RATE IN THECAPITALIST WORLD-ECONOMY

Estimating the Cost of Capital and the Profit Share

A Comparison of CEO Pay in Public and Private US Firms *

The economics of PIPEs, revisited

Is Aggregate Market Power Increasing? Production Trends Using Financial Statements

Corporate Discount Rates

The Profitability and Investment Premium: Pre-1963 Evidence

Information, Impact, Ignorance, Illegality, Investing, and Inequality

Endless Accumulation, Limits to Growth, and the Tendency for the Rate of Profit to Fall