Patterns of farmer irrigation behavior under conditions of water insufficiency and fixed electricity tariff: Evidence from Vidarbha

P. Deshpande,S. Phansalkar
Abstract:Maharashtra State Electricity Board shifted from a metered tariff to Horse Power linked fixed tariff in the eighties. From 2000, it has shifted all the new connections to metered tariffs. A large majority of the electric pump users in Vidarbha are on fixed tariff system. Barring a small minority in the foothills of Satpur in Nagpur and Amarawati districts (the orange belt), most farmers rely on open dug wells that retain water only up to March. Quantum ofwater that can be pumped is also quite uncertain. Behavioral patterns in this region under fixed tariff are complex. Most farmers adopt 'Wait & Watch' attitude is remarkable due to various reasons. Area under cotton cultivation has been reduced to half and substituted by Soybean. Gram is taken after soyabean. No consumer desires disconnection of his line. Therefore, even though he deliberately postpones payment he behaves and pays the bill when circumstances become decisive. Affordability of HPT system is a function of land holding and water availability. These two accordingly govern the behavior ofthe farmers. Evidently there is a gap between the policies & actual implementation of the same regarding levying electricity bills. The enforcement is weak and allows farmers plenty ofroom to maneuver. Implications ofour understanding are subtle. Undoubtedly fixed tariff is more convenient to administer. It is possible to argue that the level at which the tariff is fixed is determined by taking averages ofpumping hours and these regions represent "outliers ", Yet it is desirable that hard rock regions that are otherwise poor, do not have any suiface water sources and have uncertain shallow water aquifers not be hit with a double whammy by a very hostile tariff regime, At the least the tariff regime needs· to differentiate between those who have tube wells that access deep water aquifers and others who access shallow. water aquifers through open dug wells. This would mean a graded fixed tariff system oue that charges less amount for single phase and small HP motors and those that have say 10 HP and more. Se.condly there is an urgent need to improve enforcement. Farmers betting on slackness in enforcement is an evidence of ineptitude in collection and enforcement. Finally, clearly it is desirable that farmers shift to better water distribution methods slich as micro-irrigation techniques, In general, micro-irrigation organizations IJeed to focus on hard rock regions that dominantly rely on dug wells since farmers here depend on the little water they can access to prOVide security oftheir livelihoods.
Environmental Science,Economics,Agricultural and Food Sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?