Tracing tungsten-tin mineralization processes with tourmaline geochemistry in the Wangxianling-Hehuaping district, Nanling Range (South China)

Nan-Xing Li,Rong-Qing Zhang,Lei Zhu,Lin-Yan Kang,Bin Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oregeorev.2023.105806
IF: 3.3
2023-11-29
Ore Geology Reviews
Abstract:The mechanisms controlling the enrichment and separate precipitation of tungsten and tin ores are obscure. To unravel the physicochemical changes in the mineralization system during the magmatic-hydrothermal transition, we investigate the petrography, geochemistry, and boron isotopes of tourmaline in the Wangxianling-Hehuaping district (Nanling Range, South China). Four types of tourmalines were identified: Magmatic (Tur-W G ) and hydrothermal (Tur-W V ) tourmaline in the Triassic W-mineralized tourmaline-two-mica granite (ca. 220 Ma); Magmatic (Tur-Sn G ) and hydrothermal (Tur-Sn V ) tourmaline in the Jurassic Sn-mineralized biotite granite (ca. 155 Ma). Tur-W V and Tur-Sn V have lower Fe 3+ /(Fe 2+ + Fe 3+ ) ratios than those of Tur-W G and Tur-Sn G , suggesting that W-Sn mineralization occurred in a relatively reducing environment. In addition, the δ 11 B values of all four types of tourmalines are similar, suggesting that the ore-forming fluids were primarily exsolved from the granitic magma. Significant chemical variations (e.g., Mg, Fe, Sc, V, Ni, and REEs) between Tur-Sn G and Tur-Sn V may have been resulted from fractionation and intense ore fluid-wall rock reactions. In contrast, Tur-W G has similar chemical compositions to Tur-W V , suggesting that the Triassic W mineralization may have undergone a magmatic-hydrothermal process with little ore fluid-wall reaction. Tur-Sn V has exceptionally high F content, which could enhance the Sn solubility and enrichment. This explains the low Sn content of granitic magmas with large-scale Jurassic tin mineralization. Considering that W has a large melt-fluid partition coefficient, we conclude that in the Triassic, W is enriched in the exsolved fluid from the granitic magma and precipitated with temperature drop. This may have caused the decrease in W content in the protolith and limited the Jurassic W mineralization. Subsequently, the mantle-derived F addition along the Chenzhou-Linwu fault in the Jurassic had led to Sn enrichment in the fluids, and mineralization is triggered by temperature drop and fluid-rock reactions. Eventually, the extensive Triassic W mineralization and Jurassic Sn mineralization exhibit the separation of tungsten-tin mineralization. The separated tungsten-tin mineralization model based on different volatile components could also be applicable to other tungsten-tin metallogenic belts.
mineralogy,geology,mining & mineral processing
What problem does this paper attempt to address?