Abstract:Abstract Structural reliability methods are nowadays a cornerstone for the design of robustly performing structures, thanks to advancements in modeling and simulation tools. Monte Carlo-based simulation tools have been shown to provide the necessary accuracy and flexibility. While standard Monte Carlo estimation of the probability of failure is not hindered in its applicability by approximations or limiting assumptions, it becomes computationally unfeasible when small failure probability needs to be estimated, especially when the underlying numerical model evaluation is time consuming. In this case, variance reduction techniques are commonly employed, allowing for the estimation of small failure probabilities with a reduced number of samples and model calls. As a competing approach to variance reduction techniques, surrogate models can be used to substitute the computationally expensive model and performance function with an easy to evaluate numerical function calibrated through a supervised learning procedure. Both these tools provide accurate results for structural application. However, particular care should be taken into account when the reliability problems deal with high-dimensional or strongly nonlinear structural performances since the accuracy of the estimate is largely dependent on choices made during the surrogate modeling process. In this work, we compare the performance of the most recent state-of-the-art advance Monte Carlo techniques and surrogate models when applied to strongly nonlinear performance functions. This will provide the analysts with an insight to the issues that could arise in these challenging problems and help to decide with confidence on which tool to select in order to achieve accurate estimation of the failure probabilities within feasible times with their available computational capabilities.

Monte Carlo and variance reduction methods for structural reliability analysis: A comprehensive review

Machine learning-based methods in structural reliability analysis: A review

Studies on variance reduction technique of Monte Carlo simulation in composite system reliability evaluation

Quasi-Monte Carlo Method for Structural Reliability Analysis

Structural dynamic reliability analysis: review and prospects

Monte Carlo simulation of multivariate distribution and its application to structural reliability analysis

A Semi-Analytical Simulation Method for Reliability Assessments of Structural Systems.

System Reliability Analysis by Monte Carlo Based Method and Finite Element Structural Models

An adaptive Kriging-based structural reliability analysis method combing dichotomy and improved convergence criterion

Structural reliability software and calculation tools: a review

Improving Importance Sampling Method in Structural Reliability

Structural Reliability Analysis Method Based on Support Vector Machines and Monte Carlo and Its Application

Simulating the Numerical Computation Approach of Structure Reliability

High Dimensional Structural Reliability with Dimension Reduction

A Novel Adaptive Support Vector Machine Method for Reliability Analysis

Structural Reliability Analysis on the Basis of Small Samples: an Interval Quasi-Monte Carlo Method

A new adaptive analysis method based on the Kriging model for structural reliability analysis

Subset Simulation for Structural Reliability Sensitivity Analysis

A Novel Study of Structural Reliability Analysis and Optimization for Super Parametric Convex Model

Structural Reliability Sensitivity Analysis Method Based on Markov Chain Monte Carlo Subset Simulation

On the Robust Estimation of Small Failure Probabilities for Strong Nonlinear Models