Abstract:A key challenge for Earth system models is improving the representation of plant functional diversity. Experiments with vegetation demographic models show that water limitation leads to divergence between tree allocation strategies that are most competitive versus those that maximize biomass or productivity in monoculture. Earth system models (ESMs) have a limited capacity to represent plant functional diversity and shifts in trait distributions. Approaches to improving the representation of this complexity in ESMs include (i) optimality‐based approaches that predict trait–environment responses and (ii) explicitly modelling coexistence and community assembly. These approaches are expected to converge only when optimality‐based approaches identify competitively dominant strategies, which often differ from strategies that maximize ecosystem functioning or fitness components in monoculture. We used two models, LM3‐PPA (a vegetation demographic model designed as an ESM component) and BiomeE (a computationally efficient analog for LM3‐PPA), to explore how water limitation affects carbon allocation strategies of canopy trees. We compared competitive allocation strategies and those that maximize biomass or productivity in monoculture. We did not explicitly model coexistence or community assembly. Rather, we used model experiments to identify competitive and maximizing strategies in a two‐dimensional trait space under different precipitation and mortality scenarios. At 10 eastern US locations, we simulated historical, wet and dry climate scenarios, novel drought and three different mortality scenarios (low, medium or high sensitivity to water deficit). For each site and scenario, we identified the competitive strategy and three maximizing strategies (maximum biomass, productivity or drought‐tolerance). Root: leaf ratios tended to increase and leaf area tended to decrease with increasing water stress (increasing water limitation and its effects on mortality). However, relative to maximizing strategies, competitive strategies shifted towards greater allocation to roots and leaves with increasing water stress. Competitive overinvestments (greater allocation to roots and leaves by competitive strategies compared with maximizing strategies) were robust across different modelling contexts, including vegetation parameter sets (Acer vs. Populus), models (LM3‐PPA vs. BiomeE) and uncalibrated vsersus calibrated BiomeE versions. Synthesis: The theoretical prediction that competitive and maximizing allocation strategies differ under water limitation is confirmed for a demographic model designed as an ESM component. Optimality‐based trait predictions can simplify representing trait diversity in ESMs but do not always correspond to competitive outcomes. Explicitly modelling coexistence and community assembly in ESMs is challenging but is likely the most general approach to representing trait diversity.

Water limitation intensity shifts carbon allocation dynamics in Scots pine mesocosms

Enhanced root growth but reduced belowground carbon allocation are the initial responses to water limitation in model Scots pine-soil systems

Carbon budget of Pinus sylvestris saplings after four years of exposure to elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration

Quantitative wood anatomy and stable carbon isotopes indicate pronounced drought exposure of Scots pine when growing at the forest edge

Rhizosphere activity in an old-growth forest reacts rapidly to changes in soil moisture and shapes whole-tree carbon allocation

Amplifying effects of recurrent drought on the dynamics of tree growth and water use in a subalpine forest

Assessing environmental and physiological controls over water relations in a Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) stand through analyses of stable isotope composition of water and organic matter

Long-term effects of drought on tree-ring growth and carbon isotope variability in Scots pine in a dry environment

Effects of water limitation and competition on tree carbon allocation in an Earth system modelling framework

Here comes the flood! Stress effects of continuous and interval waterlogging periods during the growing season on Scots pine saplings

Drought impacts on tree carbon sequestration and water use - evidence from intra-annual tree-ring characteristics

Drought impacts on tree carbon sequestration and water use – evidence from intra‐annual tree‐ring characteristics

Carbon starvation following a decade of experimental drought consumes old reserves in Pinus edulis.

Water-use Efficiency and Transpiration Across European Forests During the Anthropocene

Soil nutrient availability alters tree carbon allocation dynamics during drought

Hyperspectral Imaging Reveals Differential Carotenoid and Chlorophyll Temporal Dynamics and Spatial Patterns in Scots Pine Under Water Stress

Chronic water stress reduces tree growth and the carbon sink of deciduous hardwood forests

Tree allocation dynamics beyond heat and hot drought stress reveal changes in carbon storage, belowground translocation and growth.

Responses of species-specific sap flux, transpiration and water use efficiency of pine, spruce and birch trees to temporarily moderate dry periods in mixed forests at a dry and wet forest site in the hemi-boreal zone

Prolonged warming and drought modify belowground interactions for water among coexisting plants

The combined effects of a long‐term experimental drought and an extreme drought on the use of plant‐water sources in a Mediterranean forest