Abstract:Abstract The European Union’s Green Deal proposal and Farm to Fork strategy call for both demand and supply measures to reduce emissions from the food system. While research clearly illustrates the importance of dietary transitions, impacts of potential supply-side measures are not well understood in relation to competitiveness concerns and leakage effects. This study assesses trade and GHG emission impacts of two supply-side mitigation strategies (intensification vs. extensification) in the EU, UK and Switzerland (EU + 2), against a 2050 baseline featuring healthy/sustainable diets adopted by European consumers. To capture potential leakage effects arising from changing external trade flows, the two supply-side strategies are assessed against three trade policy regimes (i.e. status quo, regional trade liberalization with and without border carbon adjustment), resulting in six scenarios formulated with detailed inputs from the EUCalc model and other literature and simulated with a purported-designed CGE model. Results show that intensification, while improving the EU + 2’s external trade balance, does not reduce emissions in the EU + 2, compared to the baseline. In contrast, extensification leads to a substantial emission abatement that augments reductions from the assumed dietary transition in the baseline, resulting in a combined 31% agricultural emission reduction in EU + 2 during 2014–2050. However, this is at the expense of reduced net agrifood exports by US$25 billion compared to the baseline and significant carbon leakage at a rate of 48% (i.e. nearly half of agricultural emission reduction in the EU + 2 ‘leaked’ to elsewhere). Furthermore, implementing the EU + 2’s prospective regional trade agreements results in increased territorial emissions. Although a border carbon adjustment by the EU + 2 can improve its trade balance and partially shift mitigation burdens to other countries, the associated reductions in global emissions (and carbon leakage) would be marginal. Finally, different trade and emission effects are identified between the crop and livestock sectors, pointing to the desirability of a mixed agriculture system with intensified livestock sector and extensified crop agriculture in the EU + 2 that balances emission reduction goals and competitiveness concerns.

Changes in global food consumption increase GHG emissions despite efficiency gains along global supply chains

China's changing diet and its impacts on greenhouse gas emissions: an index decomposition analysis

Impacts of supply-side climate change mitigation practices and trade policy regimes under dietary transition: the case of European agriculture

Balancing Food System Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reduction and Food Security in China

The greenhouse gas footprints of China's food production and consumption (1987-2017)

Changes in Non-CO 2 Greenhouse Gas Emissions From Livestock Production, Meat Consumption and Trade in China

Drivers of GHG emissions from dietary transition patterns in China: Supply versus demand options

Cutting carbon emissions from China’s food system by supply-demand coordination and optimizing spatial allocation of production

China's Trade of Agricultural Products Drives Substantial Greenhouse Gas Emissions

Global greenhouse gas emissions from animal-based foods are twice those of plant-based foods

Livestock increasingly drove global agricultural emissions growth from 1910-2015

Drivers of Global Methane Emissions Embodied in International Beef Trade.

Greenhouse gas emissions from food systems: building the evidence base

Half of the greenhouse gas emissions from China’s food system occur during food production

Decline in carbon emission intensity of global agriculture has stagnated recently

Land-use emissions embodied in international trade

A 130‐year Global Inventory of Methane Emissions from Livestock: Trends, Patterns, and Drivers

Impact of diet structure change on agricultural greenhouse gas emissions in China

Accounting greenhouse gas emissions of food consumption between urban and rural residents in China: a whole production perspective

Future warming from global food consumption

A Structural Decomposition Analysis of China’s Consumption-Based Greenhouse Gas Emissions