Abstract:Abstract Teachers’ belief systems about the inclusion of students with special needs may explain gaps between policy and practice. We investigated three inter-related aspects of teachers’ belief systems: teachers’ cognitive appraisals (e.g., attitudes), emotional appraisal (e.g., feelings), and self-efficacy (e.g., agency to teach inclusive classrooms). To date, research in this field has produced contradictory findings, resulting in a sparse understanding of why teachers differ in their belief systems about inclusive education, and how teachers’ training experiences contribute to their development of professional beliefs. We used meta-analysis to describe the level and range of teachers’ beliefs about inclusive education, and examine factors that contribute to variation in teachers’ beliefs, namely (1) the point in teachers’ career (pre-service versus in-service), (2) training in special versus regular education, and (3) the effects of specific programs and interventions. We reviewed 102 papers (2000–2020) resulting in 191 effect sizes based on research with 40,898 teachers in 40 countries. On average, teachers’ cognitive appraisals, emotional appraisals, and efficacy about inclusion were found to be in the mid-range of scales, indicating room for growth. Self-efficacy beliefs were higher for preservice ( M = 3.69) than for in-service teachers ( M = 3.13). Teachers with special education training held more positive views about inclusion than regular education teachers ( d = 0.41). Training and interventions related to improved cognitive appraisal ( d = 0.63), emotional appraisal ( d = 0.63), and self-efficacy toward inclusive practices ( d = 0.93). The training was particularly effective in encouraging reflection of beliefs and, eventually, facilitating belief change when teachers gained practical experience in inclusive classrooms. Six key findings direct the next steps.

The Racism and Inequity Beliefs Questionnaire: Construction and Initial Validation

Construction and validation of the Racially Biased Reasoning Scale: A measure of beliefs about police interactions with people of color.

Preliminary Development of the Racial Equity-Oriented Social-Emotional Learning Practices Measure

Validity Evidence for the Behavioral and Emotional Rating Scale—3: Factor Analysis and Measurement Invariance Across Race and Ethnicity

Measuring Fairness and Justice in the Classroom: A Systematic Review of Instruments' Validity Evidence

Teachers’ Beliefs About Inclusive Education and Insights on What Contributes to Those Beliefs: a Meta-analytical Study

Anti-racist Quantitative Research: Developing, Validating, and Implementing Racialized Teaching Efficacy and Racial Fragility Scales

Assessing Role Conflict and Role Ambiguity: A Cross Validation Study

Relationships Among the Knowledge, Efficacy, and Practices Instrument, Color-Blind Racial Attitudes Scale, Deamonte Driver Survey, and Defining Issues Test 2

The Culturally Responsive Classroom Management Self-Efficacy Scale: Development and Initial Validation

Development and validation of domain specific school diversity model scales among pupils and teachers: A multilevel approach

Unveiling disparities: examining differential item functioning's impact on racial health equity among white and black populations

Structurally Unjust: How Lay Beliefs about Racism Relate to Perceptions of and Responses to Racial Inequality in Criminal Justice

A Rasch Analysis of the Teacher Social and Emotional Learning Beliefs Scale (TSELBS) in Chinese Context

Development and Validation of a Preliminary Measure of African American Women’s Gender Role Beliefs

Race-based Bullying Victimization and Adjustment Difficulties: Racial-Ethnic Differences in the Protective Role of School Equity

What's Race Got to Do with It? Relationships Between Racial Match and School Psychologists' Perceptions in School-Based Consultation

Teachers' Conceptions of Fairness in Classroom Assessment: An Empirical Study

Historical information and beliefs about racial inequality

Assessing teachers' intervention-related expectations and self-efficacy: An examination of the factor structure of the implementation beliefs assessment

Someone who knows and someone I trust: Investigating how and with whom U.S. 8- to 14-year-old youth seek to learn about racial inequality.