Progressive collapse analysis and robustness evaluation of a propped excavation failed due to inappropriate strut removal

F. Yi,J. Su,G. Zheng,X. S. Cheng,H. T. Pei,X. M. Liu,J. W. Jia
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11440-023-01929-x
2023-06-14
Acta Geotechnica
Abstract:Collapse accidents of deep excavations occurred frequently in soft soil areas. In this paper, a deep excavation failure case caused by inappropriate strut removal before casting floor slabs is introduced, and the finite difference method was used to investigate the progressive failure mechanism and learn some lessons. The internal forces and damage states of the structure members in the retaining system after the inappropriate strut removal were analyzed to identify the progressive failure path. The progressive collapse phenomenon in the numerical simulation was similar to that in the case. Local inappropriate strut removal led to internal force redistribution in the remaining system, and the stress patterns in structural components would not be conform with the design patterns and cause the structural components to fail progressively. The failure sequence in this case was found to be: kingposts, capping beam and waler beam, strut and retaining piles. At last, the retaining piles became cantilevered and were broken by bending moment and led to the collapse of the excavation. In addition, different strut removal sequences would cause slightly different progressive failure paths. To evaluate the progressive collapse resistance capacity, evaluation methods that can measure the extent of load transfer and robustness of the retaining system were proposed. For excavation retained by propped piles, increasing the load transmission paths of the retaining system, such as adding diagonals to horizontal strut system reasonably, can increase the robustness to resist the progressive collapse.
engineering, geological
What problem does this paper attempt to address?