Abstract:The Newtonian constant of gravitation, $G$, stands out in the landscape of the most common fundamental constants owing to its surprisingly large relative uncertainty, which is attributable mostly to the dispersion of the values measured for it in different experiments. This study focuses on a set of measurements of $G$ that are mutually inconsistent, in the sense that the dispersion of the measured values is significantly larger than what their reported uncertainties suggest that it should be. Furthermore, there is a loosely defined group of measured values that lie fairly close to a consensus value that may be derived from all the measurement results, and then there are one or more groups with measured values farther away from the consensus value, some higher, others lower. This same general pattern is often observed in many interlaboratory studies and meta-analyses. In the conventional treatments of such data, the mutual inconsistency is addressed by inflating the reported uncertainties, either multiplicatively, or by the addition of random effects, both reflecting the presence of dark uncertainty. The former approach is often used by CODATA and by the Particle Data Group, and the latter is common in medical meta-analysis and in metrology. We propose a new procedure for consensus building that models the results using latent clusters with different shades of dark uncertainty, which assigns a customized amount of dark uncertainty to each measured value, as a mixture of those shades, and does so taking into account both the placement of the measured values relative to the consensus value, and the reported uncertainties. We demonstrate this procedure by deriving a new estimate for $G$, as a consensus value $G = 6.67408 \times 10^{-11} \,\text{m}^{-3} \, \text{kg}^{-1} \, \text{s}^{-2}$, with $u(G) = 0.00024 \times 10^{-11} \,\text{m}^{-3} \, \text{kg}^{-1} \, \text{s}^{-2}$.

Theoretical Value of the Gravitational Constant

Measurements of the gravitational constant using two independent methods

Precision measurement of the Newtonian gravitational constant

Measurement of the Newtonian Gravitational Constant Based on the Principle of Free Fall

Shades of Dark Uncertainty and Consensus Value for the Newtonian Constant of Gravitation

Historical Notes: The Gravitational Constant

Gravitational Coupling, Dynamical Changes of Units and The Cosmological Constant Problem

Fundamental constants: from measurement to the universe, a window on gravitation and cosmology

Foundations of a Theory of Gravity with a Constraint and its Canonical Quantization

Varying constants, Gravitation and Cosmology

Measuring the Newtonian constant of gravitation G with an atomic interferometer

Bayesian analysis of systematic errors in the determination of the constant of gravitation

Measurement of the Newtonian Constant of Gravitation $G$ by Precision Displacement Sensors

Non-metric Generalizations of Relativistic Gravitational Theory and Observational Data Interpretation

A citation history of measurements of Newtons constant of Gravity

Measurement of Newton's Constant Using a Torsion Balance with Angular Acceleration Feedback

Note on a New Fundamental Length Scale L Instead of the Newtonian Constant G

The new concepts of ether and calculation of the cosmological constant

The effect of the gravitational constant variation on the propagation of gravitational waves

Gravitational Effect on Fundamental Physical Observables

Short-range test of the universality of gravitational constant $G$ at the millimeter scale using a digital image sensor