Abstract:Natural resource managers are often challenged with balancing requirements to maintain wildlife populations and to reduce risks of catastrophic or dangerous wildfires. This challenge is exemplified in the Sierra Nevada of California, where proposals to thin vegetation to reduce wildfire risks have been highly controversial, in part because vegetation treatments could adversely affect an imperiled population of the fisher (Martes pennanti) located in the southern Sierra Nevada. The fisher is an uncommon forest carnivore associated with the types of dense, structurally complex forests often targeted for fuel reduction treatments. Vegetation thinning and removal of dead-wood structures would reduce fisher habitat value and remove essential habitat elements used by fishers for resting and denning. However, crown-replacing wildfires also threaten the population’s habitat, potentially over much broader areas than the treatments intended to reduce wildfire risks. To investigate the potential relative risks of wildfires and fuels treatments on this isolated fisher population, we coupled three spatial models to simulate the stochastic and interacting effects of wildfires and fuels management on fisher habitat and population size: a spatially dynamic forest succession and disturbance model, a fisher habitat model, and a fisher metapopulation model, which assumed that fisher fecundity and survivorship correlate with habitat quality. We systematically varied fuel treatment rate, treatment intensity, and fire regime, and assessed their relative effects on the modeled fisher population over 60 years. After estimating the number of adult female fishers remaining at the end of each simulation scenario, we compared the immediate negative effects of fuel treatments to the longer-term positive effect of fuel treatment (via reduction of fire hazard) using structural equation modeling. Our simulations suggest that the direct, negative effects of fuel treatments on fisher population size are generally smaller than the indirect, positive effects of fuel treatments, because fuels treatments reduced the probability of large wildfires that can damage and fragment habitat over larger areas. The benefits of fuel treatments varied by elevation and treatment location with the highest net benefits to fisher found at higher elevations and within higher quality fisher habitat. Simulated fire regime also had a large effect with the largest net benefit of fuel treatments occurring when a more severe fire regime was simulated. However, there was large uncertainty in our projections due to stochastic spatial and temporal wildfires dynamic and fisher population dynamics. Our results demonstrate the difficulty of projecting future populations in systems characterized by large, infrequent, stochastic disturbances. Nevertheless, these coupled models offer a useful decision-support system for evaluating the relative effects of alternative management scenarios; and uncertainties can be reduced as additional data accumulate to refine and validate the models.

Simulating Timber Harvest to Assess Potential Impacts to Forest Wildlife Habitat on State Lands in Minnesota, USA

Potential conflicts between timber supply and habitat protection in the boreal mixedwood of Alberta, Canada: a simulation study

Emulating boreal forest disturbance dynamics: Can we maintain timber supply, aboriginal land use, and woodland caribou habitat?

Protecting wildlife habitat in managed forest landscapes—How can network connectivity models help?

Using stochastic simulation to evaluate competing risks of wildfires and fuels management on an isolated forest carnivore

Integrating Habitat Quality of the Great Spotted Woodpecker (Dendrocopos major) in Forest Spatial Harvest Scheduling Problems

Assessing the trade-offs between timber supply and wildlife protection goals in boreal landscapes

Modelling stand development after partial harvesting in boreal mixedwoods of eastern Canada

Multi-objective optimization for timber harvest management incorporating wildlife habitat goals

Maintenance of flying squirrel habitat and timber harvest: a site-specific spatial model in forest planning calculations

Spatial Simulation of the Effect of Fire and Harvest on Aboveground Tree Biomass in Boreal Forests of Northeast China

Effect of forest management choices on carbon sequestration and biodiversity at national scale

Comparing Effects Of Climate Warming, Fire, And Timber Harvesting On A Boreal Forest Landscape In Northeastern China

Simulating spatial complexity in dry conifer forest restoration: implications for conservation prioritization and scenario evaluation

Mapping recent timber harvest activity in a temperate forest using single date airborne LiDAR surveys and machine learning: lessons for conservation planning

Survey effort and targeted landbird community metrics at Indiana lowland forest restoration sites

Forest management optimization across spatial scales to reconcile economic and conservation objectives

Forest management affects seasonal source-sink dynamics in a territorial, group-living bird

A hierarchical model for jointly assessing ecological and anthropogenic impacts on animal demography

The long shadow of woody encroachment: An integrated approach to modeling grassland songbird habitat

A review of the long-term effects of post-harvest silviculture on vertebrate wildlife, and predictive models, with an emphasis on boreal forests in Ontario, Canada