Abstract:Bioenergetics models are routinely used to estimate food consumption or growth and are thus critical tools in applied science and decision‐making in aquatic ecosystem and species management. Even though fish telemetry is widely used and has enabled researchers to accurately document in‐situ temperatures aligned with dynamic fish behavior, that is, their realized thermal niche, the traditional use of lab‐derived optimum temperatures based on the physiological optimum theory in models still persists. In this study, we contrasted optimum and field temperature data in models and quantified the effects on growth and consumption of two widely distributed salmonids that occupy both marine and freshwater ecosystems. We demonstrate that significant biases in the model estimates of growth and lifetime prey consumption produced using lab‐obtained optimum temperatures could be eliminated by the adoption of realized thermal niche approach to bioenergetics modeling. Bioenergetics models estimate ectotherm growth, production, and prey consumption – all key for effective ecosystem management during changing global temperatures. Based on species‐specific allometric and thermodynamic relationships, these models typically use the species' lab‐derived optimum temperatures (physiological optimum) as opposed to empirical field data (realized thermal niche) that reflect actual thermal experience. Yet, dynamic behavioral thermoregulation mediated by biotic and abiotic interactions may provide substantial divergence between physiological optimum and realized thermal niche temperatures to significantly bias model outcomes. Here, using the Wisconsin bioenergetics model and in‐situ year‐round temperature data, we tested the two approaches and compared the maximum attainable lifetime weight and lifetime prey consumption estimates for two salmonid species with differing life histories. We demonstrate that using the realized thermal niche is the better approach because it eliminates significant biases in estimates produced by the physiological optimum. Specifically, using the physiological optimum, slower‐growing Salvelinus namaycush maximum attainable lifetime weight was underestimated, and consumption overestimated, while fast‐growing Oncorhynchus tshawytscha maximum attainable weight was overestimated. While the physiological optimum approach is useful for theoretical studies, our results demonstrate the critical importance that models used by management utilize up‐to‐date system‐ and species‐specific field data representing actual in‐situ behaviors (i.e., realized thermal niche).

Realized thermal niche approach eliminates temperature bias in bioenergetic model estimates

Realised Thermal Niches in Marine Ectotherms Are Shaped by Ontogeny and Trophic Interactions

Habitat-dependent metabolic costs for a wild cold-water fish

Predicted growth of lake trout and Chinook salmon in a warming lake

Chronic Exposure to Environmental Temperature Attenuates the Thermal Sensitivity of Salmonids

Calibrating acceleration transmitters to quantify the seasonal energetic costs of activity in lake trout

Laboratory Evaluation of a Walleye ( Sander Vitreus ) Bioenergetics Model

Methodological influence on detecting temperature effects on growth variability in juvenile Atlantic salmon

Individual variation in field metabolic rates of wild living fish have phenotypic and ontogenetic underpinnings: insights from stable isotope compositions of otoliths

Environmental variation associated with overwintering elicits marked metabolic plasticity in a temperate salmonid, Salvelinus fontinalis

Diet drives performance trade-offs along Atlantic salmon ontology

Predicting population-level impacts of projected climate heating on a temperate freshwater fish

Linking functional response and bioenergetics to estimate juvenile salmon growth in a reservoir food web

Incorporating otolith-isotope inferred field metabolic rate into conservation strategies

Smaller body size under warming is not due to gill-oxygen limitation in a cold-water salmonid

Multigenerational inspections of environmental thermal perturbations promote metabolic trade-offs in developmental stages of tropical fish

Temperature dependence of fish performance in the wild: links with species biogeography and physiological thermal tolerance

Post-exercise respirometry underestimates maximum metabolic rate in juvenile salmon

Temperature‐Dependence Assumptions Drive Projected Responses of Diverse Size‐Based Food Webs to Warming

Potential sources of bias in the climate sensitivities of fish otolith biochronologies

Advancing bioenergetics-based modeling to improve climate change projections of marine ecosystems