Abstract:Knowledge engineering is the process of creating and maintaining knowledge-producing systems. Throughout the history of computer science and AI, knowledge engineering workflows have been widely used given the importance of high-quality knowledge for reliable intelligent agents. Meanwhile, the scope of knowledge engineering, as apparent from its target tasks and use cases, has been shifting, together with its paradigms such as expert systems, semantic web, and language modeling. The intended use cases and supported user requirements between these paradigms have not been analyzed globally, as new paradigms often satisfy prior pain points while possibly introducing new ones. The recent abstraction of systemic patterns into a boxology provides an opening for aligning the requirements and use cases of knowledge engineering with the systems, components, and software that can satisfy them best. This paper proposes a vision of harmonizing the best practices in the field of knowledge engineering by leveraging the software engineering methodology of creating reference architectures. We describe how a reference architecture can be iteratively designed and implemented to associate user needs with recurring systemic patterns, building on top of existing knowledge engineering workflows and boxologies. We provide a six-step roadmap that can enable the development of such an architecture, providing an initial design and outcome of the definition of architectural scope, selection of information sources, and analysis. We expect that following through on this vision will lead to well-grounded reference architectures for knowledge engineering, will advance the ongoing initiatives of organizing the neurosymbolic knowledge engineering space, and will build new links to the software architectures and data science communities.

On reference architectures

Standardizing Knowledge Engineering Practices with a Reference Architecture

Towards Reference Architectures for Trustworthy Collaborative Cyber-Physical Systems: Reference Architectures as Boundary Objects

Enterprise Modeling and the Elements of Reference Architecture Study

Architecture Definition in Complex System Design Using Model Theory

Insight, innovation, and the big picture in system design

A model-based reference architecture for complex assistive systems and its application

Constraint based Modeling according to Reference Design

A Reference Architecture and Modelling Principles for Architectural Stability based on Self-Awareness: Case of Cloud Architectures

A formal basis for architectural connection

Effective integration of low-cost digital manufacturing systems: a reference architecture driven approach

Architectures for Industrial AIoT Applications

Identifying and Consolidating Knowledge Engineering Requirements

An Architecture Of Adaptive Interface And Its Implementation

Software Architectures for Mobile Robots

Thoughts on Architecture

The Mathematical Syntax of Architectures

Internet of Things: System Reference Architecture

MORPH: A Reference Architecture for Configuration and Behaviour Self-Adaptation

Big Data Architecture and Reference Models.

ABIDI: A Reference Architecture for Reliable Industrial Internet of Things.