Vocal individuality in owls: a taxon-wide review in the context of Tinbergen's four questions

Malavika Madhavan,Pavel Linhart
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10336-024-02230-8
2024-11-09
Journal of Ornithology
Abstract:The ability to recognize and be recognized underlies the social behavior of many animals. Individual-level recognition holds special importance in intra-specific recognition, where it is key to central processes like reproduction, locating one's own offspring, degree of escalation of territorial conflicts with conspecifics, etc. Individual identity signaling involves producing unique, identifiable signatures that remain stable over time. A comparative study of vocally individual traits can reveal commonalities in related species, or common selective pressures in both related and unrelated species. Here, we conducted a literature review on vocal individuality in the owl clade. Owing to their nocturnal habit, the acoustic channel is very important for communication in owls. Territorial calls in many owl species have also been shown to be individually distinct and stable over several years. Further, we also classified the studies as fitting into one or more of Tinbergen's "four questions" (ontogeny, mechanism, phylogeny, and function) whenever possible. Investigating individuality in the context of these four questions can inform us not only of the mechanism of how and where identity is encoded, but also of the evolution of individuality through the life span of species and through phylogeny. In total, we collected 34 papers on vocal individuality in owls, representing 22 species from 9 genera. Besides elaborating on relevant examples of studies fitting into one or more of the categories, we also highlight the gaps in research so far, and suggest steps to advance the research of vocal individuality in owls.
ornithology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?