Removing non‐crop flowers within orchards promotes the decline of pollinators, not their conservation: A comment on McDougall et al. (2021)

Diego N. Nabaes Jodar,Néstor Pérez‐Méndez,Cristina Botías,Lucas A. Garibaldi,Pablo L. Hunicken,Elena Velado‐Alonso,Carlos Zaragoza‐Trello
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/icad.12648
IF: 4.266
2023-05-19
Insect Conservation and Diversity
Abstract:McDougall et al. (2021) propose removing flowering ground vegetation within orchards after the crop bloom ends, as a pollinator conservation strategy based on reducing their exposure to pesticides. However, the expected reduction in pesticide exposure was not quantified, and significant decreases in pollinator abundance and diversity were reported after the removal of ground cover flowers within orchards. Alternatively, we champion the importance of accessible, sufficient, safe and seasonally spread feeding resources to crop pollinators, their potential for increasing pollinator pesticide tolerance, and the reduction in pesticide use. Abundant and diverse floral resources are needed for the preservation of pollinator populations and the services they provide to human societies. However, pollinators are negatively affected by several agricultural practices, among which pesticide use and 'weed' removal stand out. McDougall et al. (2021) published a paper titled 'Managing orchard groundcover to reduce pollinator foraging post‐bloom', where they propose removing the within‐field flowering ground vegetation after the mass flowering period of the crop ends, to reduce pesticide exposure. They consider this is a bee conservation strategy, after observing it reduces the abundance and diversity of pollinators within the crop. However, despite assuming this implied a realisation of an expected reduction in pesticide exposure, this was not quantified. Here, we give three main arguments against the proposal of the authors, that is, the need for providing accessible, sufficient, safe and seasonally‐spread feeding resources to crop pollinators, the potential role of diverse floral resources in their pesticide tolerance, and the urgent need to reduce pesticide use and impact in agriculture.
entomology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?