Contingent Effects of Multinational Marketing Mode: A Customers' Perspective
Feng Zhang,Xiaoyun Wu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2011.06.011
2011-01-01
Abstract:Could customers in host countries accept standardized marketing? The empirical results of prior literature were ambiguous.Thus,the purpose of this study is to address the two questions of whether and when standardized marketing could positively affect customers’ mindset(cognition,emotional response,and loyalty).Such works are arranged as follows: firstly,two scenarios for studying marketing standardization(i.e.,home-host country and host-host country scenarios) are differentiated based on the literature review and field studies of Hua Wei,Pricewaterhouse,and Ting Hsin.Secondly,from multi theoretical perspectives,the authors analyze the effect of marketing standardization on customers’ mindset and the moderating effect of market similarity between them.Thirdly,considering the difficulties and complexities of a cross-cultural study,the authors explain the measurement design,the choosing of product categories and samples,and data collection in details,e.g.,international students with cross-national experience are chosen as samples.Finally,the empirical results of SEM under two scenarios indicate that:(1) the degree of marketing standardization significantly affects customers’ cognition,emotions and behaviors;(2) the market similarity between home and host countries or between host and host countries positively moderates the effects of marketing standardization on customers’ mindset;(3) in more similar markets,marketing standardization makes greater effects on customers’ mindset,i.e.,if MNCs adopt consistent marketing modes among countries which are similar in social culture,customs,customers’ preference,they will more easily be accepted by customers and enjoy the benefits from the standardization;(4) in less similar markets,marketing standardization makes nearly no significant or even negative effects on customers’ mindset,i.e.,if MNCs adopt consistent marketing modes among countries which are different in social culture,customs,customers’ preference,they will be resisted by customers.In the last section,managerial implications are discussed for Chinese firms via analysis of some detailed cases.Firstly,customers’ acceptance should be recognized as an important criteria of evaluating firms’ marketing modes;secondly,marketing standardization could be an option for MNCs under some certain contexts;thirdly,when MNCs plan a marketing standardization strategy in different countries,they should firstly consider the degrees of market similarities among them;finally,if MNCs implement a standardization strategy,three paths could be adopted.