Letting the (Big) Cat(S) out of the Bag: a Case for Federal Prohibition of Exotic Big Cat Ownership in Pakistan

Hira Jaleel
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4398366
2023-01-01
SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract:Over the past decade, exotic big cat ownership has proliferated in Pakistan. People want to own big cats as pets, as symbols of wealth and status, and to express political affiliations. However, big cat ownership gives rise to serious animal welfare and public safety concerns, to which the Federal and Provincial Governments turn a blind eye. The Federal legislative scheme regulates the import of exotic big cats, but relinquishes jurisdiction as soon as the animals are inside Pakistan. Provincial laws fall into one of three categories: (1) permissive of big cat breeding and ownership; (2) unclear about whether the province can regulate exotic animals; or (3) restricting breeding and possession of big cats. This patchwork of laws and resulting loopholes have given rise to a thriving private market for the breeding, sale and purchase of big cats.This Article argues that the only solution to Pakistan’s big cat crisis is for the Federal legislature to forego regulation and impose a complete ban on the import, export, inter-provincial transport, sale and purchase of big cats for private ownership. The Article uses the United States as a case study to demonstrate the futility of relying on incremental federal regulation or state-wide approaches to curb the private possession of big cats. Ultimately, the Article recommends that Pakistan should pass legislation similar to the Big Cat Public Safety Act, which federally prohibits private breeding and ownership of big cats, with limited exemptions.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?