Unraveling the Changing Pattern of Prospective Teachers' Self-Confidence: Transition from Theory of Teaching to Practice
Zamir Iqbal,Nasir Mahmood
2010-01-01
Abstract:It is an implicit assumption that self-confidence is a necessary condition for success in teaching (Kalaian & Freeman, 1987; Malkin & Stake, 2004) like all other skill based professions (Kagan, 1992; Calderhead & Robson, 1991). Teacher preparation programmes are designed to build the foundation for strong pedagogical knowledge (Bleicher, 2007). Teacher training comprises of two broader modes i.e. training on basic principles of teaching and providing actual supervised teaching experience in real classrooms to prospective teachers. The hands-on teaching provides an opportunity to attain an equilibration between principles and practice (Bleicher, 2006). This transition causes changes in self-confidence of the prospective teachers, which is meaningful in several ways for utilizing as tool to follow the making of a teacher.Therefore, changes in self-confidence have attracted attention of several researchers from different dimenti ons (Ashton & Webb, 1986; Pigge & Marso, 1986; Tittle & Denker, 1981, Kalaian & Freeman, 1987; Bleicher, 2007). The researches in this field can be classified by themes; some of the studies have explored the relationship between prospective teacher's self-confidence and orientation towards teaching and reported that increased self-confidence contributes prospective teachers' perception of their role as teacher (Kalaian & Freeman, 1987), the relationship between positive attitude towards other group members and self-confidence (Malkin, & Stake, 2004; Hoberman, Lewinsohn & Tilson, 1988; Tschuschke & Dies, 1994; Malkin & Stake, 2004) and role of embedded field work (teaching practice, school visits etc) on selfassurance and confidence in initial teacher education program. Tracy and Gloria (1992) have studied and found meaningful relationship in changing self-confidence and prospective teachers' ability to evaluate student.The brief overview given here about range of researches in which changes in self-confidence were studied in relation to variety of related variables is not exhaustive by any means but provides a fair idea of central place of teacher's self-confidence in his/her professional development. This argument leads to conclusion that initial training program should have more opportunities for discussions concerning the conduct of the profession. Elements that aim to increase the confidence of the graduates may be particularly helpful (Enochs & Riggs, 1990; Jarret, 1999; Tasun, 2000; & Wingfield, Freeman, & Ramsey, 2000).The researches have consistently reported that with changes in confidence and enthusiasm, the attitude towards work, friendliness towards students' approachability, openness with students and rapport with colleagues and supervisors change (Chan & Leung, 2009). The other more frequently changes associated with self-confidence are transition from idealist to realist and dislike of teaching to love for teaching (Richards, Gallo & Renandya, 1998).Teaching being a skill cannot be taught merely through training during initial teacher education courses but course only equips prospective teachers build knowledge and sketch school classroom teaching environment as portrayed by the instructor (Gossert , Cracolice, Kampmeier, Roth, Strozak & Varma, 2001; Yost, Sentner & Forlenza - Bailey, 2000). It is commonly observed that such hypothetically constructed classroom situations and roles rarely match with actual classroom teaching and learning environment (Weinstein, 1990). The students do not behave the way prospective teacher expects them to behave (Saarnivaara & Sarja, 2007), school administration does not extend the degree of freedom and acceptance as expected by the prospective teacher (Epstein, 1993; Norm ore, 2003), the material required for innovation learned in course work are hardly available, tightly planned scheme of studies does not allow the flexibility expected by the prospective teachers to try out idealized teaching pedagogies (Kilgore, Ross & Zbikowski, 1990) and so on. …