Abstract:To evaluate the performance of deep learning methods (DL) for reference evapotranspiration estimation and to assess the applicability of the developed DL models beyond the study areas where they were trained, three popular DL models named deep neural network (DNN), temporal convolution neural network (TCN), and long short-term memory neural network (LSTM) were developed to estimate daily reference evapotranspiration (ETo) using incomplete meteorological data in the Northeast plain, China. The performances of the three DL models were compared to two classical machine learning models (CML)—support vector machine (SVM) and random forest (RF)—and empirical equations, including two temperature-based (Hargreaves (H) and modified Hargreaves (MH)), three radiation-based (Ritchie (R), Priestley-Talor (P), and Makkink (M)), and two humidity-based (Romanenko (ROM) and Schendel (S)) empirical models, in two strategies: (1) all proposed models were trained, tested, and compared in each single weather station, and (2) all-weather stations were split into several groups using the K-means method with their mean climatic characteristics. Then, in each group, stations took turns testing the proposed models which were trained by rest of the stations. The results showed that (1) the coefficient of determination (R2) values of the TCN and RF were 0.048 and 0.035 significantly higher than that of MH, respectively, and the relative root mean error (RMSE) values of TCN and RF were substantially 0.096, and 0.074 mm/d lower than that of MH, indicating that TCN and RF performed better than empirical models in the first strategy, and TCN and LSTM exhibited an RMSE that was significantly decreased by 0.069 and 0.079 mm/d, showing that TCN and LSTM outperformed empirical models in the second strategy, compared with the MH method; (2) in both strategies, compared with the Ritchie (R) model, TCN, LSTM, DNN, RF, and SVM increased R2 and decreased RMSE significantly, especially the TCN model; (3) similarly, TCN, LSTM, DNN, RF, and SVM models all augmented R2 and reduced RMSE substantially in comparison to humidity-based empirical models in both strategies, especially the TCN model. Overall, when temperature-based features were available, the TCN and LSTM models performed markedly better than temperature-based empirical models beyond the study areas, and when radiation-based or humidity-based features were available, all of the proposed DL and CML models outperformed radiation-based or humidity-based empirical equations beyond the study areas in which they were trained.

Deep learning model for temperature prediction: an empirical study

Predicting Temperature of Major Cities Using Machine Learning and Deep Learning

Weather Prediction Using CNN-LSTM for Time Series Analysis: A Case Study on Delhi Temperature Data

Hybrid deep learning approach for multi-step-ahead prediction for daily maximum temperature and heatwaves

Recurrent neural network modeling of multivariate time series and its application in temperature forecasting

Deep Learning Based Forecasting of Indian Summer Monsoon Rainfall

Deep Learning Based Prediction Of Weather Using Hybrid_stacked Bi-Long Short Term Memory

Prediction of Daily Temperature Based on the Robust Machine Learning Algorithms

Temperature Prediction in Data Center Combining with Deep Neural Network

Deep Learning-Based Maximum Temperature Forecasting Assisted with Meta-Learning for Hyperparameter Optimization

Deep Learning for Weather Forecasting: A CNN-LSTM Hybrid Model for Predicting Historical Temperature Data

Air temperature prediction models for pavement design: a gradient boosting-based approach

Prediction of sea surface temperatures using deep learning neural networks

Low-cost nature-inspired deep learning system for PM2.5 forecast over Delhi, India

Improved prediction of daily pan evaporation using Deep-LSTM model

A Deep Learning-Based Weather Forecast System for Data Volume and Recency Analysis

Comparison between ARIMA and Deep Learning Models for Temperature Forecasting

Estimating daily reference evapotranspiration based on limited meteorological data using deep learning and classical machine learning methods

Air quality index prediction using multivariate deep neural networks: A case study of a proposed state capital in India

Deep learning approach for one-hour ahead forecasting of weather data

Soft computing techniques for predicting vegetation dynamics in Delhi